3 ms·
> Both sides have free speech rights and both have outcomes that support that speech... "Free speech rights" don't apply between two private entities, only bet
by arcticbull 6y ago
> Both sides have free speech rights and both have outcomes that support that speech...
"Free speech rights" don't apply between two private entities, only between the government and a private entity.
- bt4u3 6y agoWhich is a nice loophole when we know the battle for votes is primarily fought on social media
- arcticbull 6y agoDoesn't the concept of freedom of speech necessitate the freedom from speech, ie. the right to remain silent? To force a company to say something they don't want to is in my opinion worse than allowing them to say nothing. I don't expect Breitbart to voice my opinions, for instance, and I don't expect Twitter to voice theirs if they don't want to.
- bt4u3 6y agoCompanies are not people. We impose tons of restrictions on companies that would be unreasonable to impose on individuals. Besides they are legally platforms and thus they're not saying anything although their users might. If my friend said something it does not mean I said it or even agreed with it
- koheripbal 6y agoYou are conflating The First Amendment (a law) with Freedom of Speech (a principle). FoS is something we should support in any context because the only speech worth hearing is the stuff you don't like hearing.
- criddell 6y ago> the only speech worth hearing is the stuff you don't like hearing What's an example that supports this? I can only think of examples that indicate the opposite.
- fzeroracer 6y agoThis seems rather ironic, since TD was banning people that went against the majority opinion. If TD is repeatedly violating freedom of speech principles what exactly is your recourse to ensure they comply and adhere to freedom of speech? If we accept that TD has the right to ban users it doesn't like, then we accept that Reddit has the right to ban subreddits it doesn't like.
- afiori 6y agoTo repeat a trite argument, that is the case for the free speech that is guaranteed under the US constitution. Free speech advocates usually claim that either reddit does indeed violate that constitutional right (similarly to how it applies to federally funded private companies) or that the human right of free speech is violated. This second version is assumed to exist a priori from any state/law similarly to how international human right conventions Recognize human rights rather than Create them.