3 ms·
My opinion is informed by my experience with JS. I love the web that actual dynamic logic on the frontend has allowed. I want more of that, not less. The alte
by fastball 6y ago
My opinion is informed by my experience with JS.
I love the web that actual dynamic logic on the frontend has allowed. I want more of that, not less.
The alternative to web apps that can do these things is native apps that can do these things. If you don't think native apps are tracking your behavior, you are sorely mistaken.
- buran77 6y ago> I love the web that actual dynamic logic on the frontend has allowed. I think you missed my point, I also truly love that 1% of useful stuff that JS brings and wouldn't want to lose the functionality. But I absolutely hate the other 99% which I have no control over or I have to jump through uMatrix hoops to control. Let's put it another way. You probably love that electricians and plumbers exist to fix your stuff. But if once you let them in they could invisibly camp in any room of your house without you even knowing where they are and what they're doing, would you still open the door for them? These APIs can either give you a relatively broad "Allow on this site" option, or they can flood you with granular choices. The first opens the door for them camping in bed with you. The second is like someone triggering your alarm every 5 seconds until you disable it. Accept all. Then they can camp in bed with you. Doesn't your experience tell you the same? > If you don't think native apps are tracking your behavior, you are sorely mistaken You see, this is exactly what I meant. "Those guys are screwing you over so it's OK if these ones do too". This is how the "screw the user over" arms race happens where everybody tries to outdo the others with even more invasive techniques, and users take it because each is just a slight escalation from before. When native apps were adding these "features" someone loved them for one reason or another. Frog in hot water. P.S. Example of how the innocent battery API access can be sold as "to save battery" and then repurposed to screw you over: https://metro.co.uk/2019/09/27/uber-charge-battery-lower-10778303/ https://metro.co.uk/2019/09/27/uber-charge-battery-lower-107...
- floatingatoll 6y agoUnequal progress of privacy improvements on the web and app fronts does not make it okay to walk back progress on the web front just to provide API parity.
- fastball 6y agoIf the only way to have privacy is to nuke functionality, then I’d rather have the functionality. Luckily you can have both, despite Apple wanting to pretend otherwise.
- buran77 6y ago> Luckily you can have both I have a bridge to sell you...
- vanviegen 6y agoPlease just explain your point, instead of being snarky. I think there are ways to get (a bit of) both. It's not simple though.
- Karunamon 6y agoThe point (which I vehemently disagree with) is that prompting for permission is insufficient because illiterate users will just click accept on the dialogs. So apparently we now have to restrict all interesting functionality in the name of keeping the lowest common denominator from shooting their metaphorical feet. If there's a more charitable way to read their stance, I'd love to hear it.
- buran77 6y ago> The point (which I vehemently disagree with) is that prompting for permission is insufficient because illiterate users will just click accept on the dialogs. I had 2 points actually, which I thought I made very legibly. I didn't think they they need a fourth reading but here we are... They are both solidly confirmed by present day reality. 1) is what you mentioned already. As seen with cookie prompts, app permissions, actual scientific studies, etc. if you pester people with alerts and popups they are desensitized and start ignoring and accepting them. 2) is that once you give a website permission you lost control. They lack even the modicum of oversight apps receive. > So apparently we now have to restrict all interesting functionality All? Hyperbole much? Or did you just decide that these 16 APIs are the crux of "interesting functionality" and freedom? It doesn't matter how much you allow there's always going to be someone to shout "they restricting eeeeverything around here". This is what security and privacy measures do, restrict some things because the benefit doesn't outweigh the cost/risk. All those features are sold as "essential" when in fact most of them at best address some minor nuisance. Then they're promptly hijacked for nefarious purposes because there's always going to be some wannabe coder who insists that his website needs to know my battery level for some (undoubtedly good) reason. Care to ponder how we got here in the first place? With every piece of tech around trying to steal data from you one way or another, usually in a dishonest way? There's a reason Google is championing this and it's not that they want to give you "interesting features". It's always a compromise and for the past decade+ we've been compromising a lot more on the privacy side. If you truly believe you can have both privacy and aaaaalll interesting functionality in the real world you're either naive or sitting on a gold mine.