4 ms·
Ugh, this is a tired meme. FWIW I'm British and living in Sweden, so you can derive from that anything you like. But from my perspective there has been a lot
by dijit 6y ago
Ugh, this is a tired meme.
FWIW I'm British and living in Sweden, so you can derive from that anything you like.
But from my perspective there has been a lot of narrative in my lifetime that tells me our country is quite important, but that narrative is definitely not supported by the facts.
the EU doesn't face an "existential crisis", the issue's that the EU face is:
1) Is the EU still big enough to challenge the US and Russia?
2) Why is euroscepticism on the rise? how can we combat false information when we have no budget for public relations?
3) How can we ensure that the exit of the UK doesn't end messy (messy leaving things unsure, unresolved or confusing)
w.r.t. Nuclear weapons and population size, 70M is paltry in comparison to most countries, so unless you're only comparing EU countries to the UK then you're mistaken that it's globally significant.
The fact is that we have disproportionate influence compared to our land/population size, and that is because historically we colonized a third of the planet, our wealth from that time is dwindling, we have smeared our influence with the rise of the right wing and the childish way we divorced ourselves from our closest allies.
Thousands of migrants enter the EU; the right wing media would have you believe that they almost all want to come to the UK, the fact is that /some/ want to come to the UK because they already speak English and learning another language is difficult in their situation, there are other reasons but this is by-in-large the most common one.
- growlist 6y agoYou forgot at least a couple of big ones e.g. the indefensible calamity that is the destruction of millions of young people's life chances due to the Euro, the near-collapse of unity and immediate reversion to national self-interest in the face of a genuine disaster i.e. CV, persistent stagnation and lack of growth, gleeful destruction of the EU's natural environment in stark contrast to political virtue signalling, etc. etc.
- dijit 6y agoThis is liable to become a shit slinging fest I imagine, because I believe that while the EU does have issues it is not as bad as we make out and we blind ourselves to the issues we have at home. How about we agree that the UK has done much worse than the EU regarding its governance? (I mean we have: Grenfell, our homeless problem, our funding of NHS, our human rights violations, our de-regulated banking system, our selling of fishing rights to EU companies and then crying foul, our reliance on hand-outs for agriculture, our housing crisis fuelled by foreign "investment", our massive inequality between the north and the south, social mobility being stifled for generations due to Conservative cuts to the poorest areas such as Coventry, our national transport system that costs more than any other EU country and is less reliable- AND london focused for some reason, the house of lords, the russian collusion dossier that Boris will not release, the defence of Dominic Cummings breaking lock-down (I mean, rules for thee but not for me)) I will not begin to defend things like the euro because it's mainly in hindsight that it's a bad idea. But aside from a few very real mis-steps by the EU it's overwhelmingly more democratic, fair and has far /fewer/ issues than the UK Government does. I sincerely believe we needed reforms at home before we looked to the EU.
- mellosouls 6y agoNot to point out the obvious, but all of those cases of poor governance have been while the UK has been in the EU (and some Brexiteers would claim that's why we need to be free of it so we can govern things properly - not a claim I am making btw). This is liable to become a shit slinging fest I imagine Agree, so best not to make claims that have immediate counters from those on the other side of the debate. Nobody is necessarily right or wrong here, each side has opinions and ideology.
- nicky0 6y agoIn what way are EU's institutions remotely democratic? The only one that is actually elected is the EU parliament, which has little actual power and exists only as a (very expensive) fig leaf of democracy. We can argue about how good a job the British government is doing but at least it is directly democratically accountable to the British public.
- dijit 6y agoThis is so profoundly stupid of an opinion that I am having difficulty engaging in it properly. Are you aware of the House of Lords? Did you know that the European Commission is elected by our representatives in the EU parliament? Did you know that the speaker of the house in the UK will not have his seat contested? In fact he won’t serve his constituency at all and they will be left without an acting MP of any kind. How democratic is that? Taxation without representation- from the House of Commons no less. You can’t sit there with a straight face and tell me our representative democracy with an unelected (and sometimes hereditary) upper house of peers and enacted through monarchy is /more/ democratic than what is considered the most modern and fair functioning government the world has ever seen. Just because you don’t bother to turn up to vote doesn’t mean it’s not democratic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_legitimacy_of_the_European_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_legitimacy_of_the_E...
- iamstupidsimple 6y agoMy take on it is this: The more layers removed an average voter is from an election, the more anti-democratic. Voting for MPs who vote for EU parliament representatives who vote for commission members is too far for me. One effect of this: elites always vote for other elites. There have definitely been many MPs who come from a working-class background, but that is impossible in the EU because normal voters aren't able to put those people in power. Basically, if I (or the other common man) do not have a direct vote on someone in power, then we are in an anti-democratic system.
- dmd 6y agoI don't really have a horse in this game, but "70M is paltry in comparison to most countries"? 70M puts the UK at the 21st most populous out of 235 countries. https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/population-by-country/ https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/population-by...
- dijit 6y agoI understand what you're saying, what I intended was that our population size is not as impressive as some other countries which do not boast our influence, and therefore is not a useful predictor of influence as the parent implies. I would not say that we have influence that is in proportion to our size. Would you? I would argue we're probably in the top 10 influential countries list, if not top 5, we overwhelmingly got our way when we were in the EU so we had quite significant amounts of influence there too which gave us even more power on the world stage, certainly not '21st'.
- thu2111 6y agoWho is "we", in these sentences? It sounds like you mean the EU. The EU has a massive public relations budget. Most estimates place it at over half a billion euros per year just on self-promotion, although the true figure can be much larger if you consider the money "donated" by member states for subsidies and projects, that are then rebranded as EU funding: https://fullfact.org/europe/how-much-does-eu-spend-promoting-itself/ https://fullfact.org/europe/how-much-does-eu-spend-promoting... The EU spends significant time and effort on combating false information. The problem is that most of the information it tries to combat isn't actually false, so it ends up backfiring. For example, this "myth busting" page: https://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/en/policy/what/myth-busting/ https://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/en/policy/what/myth-bus... The response to the so-called myth, "useless projects are funded with EU money" is some bland corporate-speak that says nothing: "National and regional authorities in the EU countries select projects which they think meet their needs best in line with the strategies and priorities agreed with the Commission" It's a response to stories like this one: https://www.taxpayersalliance.com/how_european_union_aid_is_squandered_on_wasteful_projects https://www.taxpayersalliance.com/how_european_union_aid_is_... which revealed the EU spent money on: • Weekly free trapeze lessons for people in Tanzania (nb: not in the EU) • Courses on how to make art from plastic bags in Dar Es Salaam (also not in the EU) • Nearly 200k EUR on EU self-promotion in Jamaica • Half a million EUR to a Zimbabwean "culture fund" whose CEO was a staunch defender of Mugabe etc. So the reason euroscepticism is on the rise isn't due to lack of money spent on propaganda, far from it. It's on the rise because the EU is extremely corrupt and its own attempts to defend itself are useless.
- pjc50 6y agoWhere's the corresponding one mocking UK public and foreign policy spending? The "tax payers alliance" is one, murkily-funded, extremely partisan guy.
- beerandt 6y agoI think the more relevant point is not that political propaganda/ pork spending is automatically and inherently wasteful, but that the political value thereof is highly subjective and varies greatly based on locale. The US career politicians have arrived at a basic understanding, where loads of widely distributed pork spending is the acceptable cost of doing politics their way. The EU is not quite to the point where naming every local post office and govt building requires (supra-)national political capital and cooperation to accomplish.
- goatinaboat 6y agoWhy is euroscepticism on the rise? how can we combat false information If you think euroscepticism is purely because of false information then perhaps your analysis is not as objective as it might be. For example the Greeks and Italians have seen their economies devastated by an interest rate set to favour Germany. That’s factual.