2 ms·
> cases are growing exponentially again and deaths will follow. The positive test number is not really connected to anything. The number of actual infections i
by pessimizer 6y ago
> cases are growing exponentially again and deaths will follow.
The positive test number is not really connected to anything. The number of actual infections is probably an order of magnitude greater than the number of positive tests. The only somewhat worthwhile testing number is the percentage of tests given that come up positive, and that's not great - testing was focused on at-risk of death, older people, and has now become more general, including younger people who have a comparable tiny risk of dangerous complications. The previous group have been completely isolated, and are generally more isolated, so shouldn't be spreading the virus very quickly. You'd expect a higher proportion of positive tests if tests were being expanded to a younger, more social distance violating population. You wouldn't expect that to be an indicator of a significantly higher number of deaths or complications, because the rise is in people who are the least likely to have them, and is possibly an artifact of less-restrictive selection criteria for testing.
I don't know anyone under 50 that has been tested (who weren't horribly sick) and my 89 year old grandparents were just tested for a second time.
Social distancing restrictions being lifted also has a greater effect on younger people than older people, who frequently have been completely left out of that. My grandparents have been in the same room for nearly four months, and plenty of people that age are socially isolated at the best of times. Young people have been on protests, or coronavirus truthers testing their "strong immune systems" at bars and other social get-togethers.
The death rate is at a fifth of what it was at peak. I'm currently as social distanced as I ever was (because I am risk averse), but I do not understand the insistence that the coronavirus threat is currently getting worse, especially since it seems to come with a deemphasis on the death/hospitalization numbers and an exaggeration of the precision of the cumulative absolute positive test as an indicator. It seems entirely political.
George Floyd was murdered over a month ago, with massive attendant protests, and death rates are lower than they've ever been.
- ethbro 6y agoOnly one number that matters, the current / effective reproduction number [e.g. 0]. Everything else is a consequence of that. Deaths within cohort are decreasing because of increasingly effective treatment options [1]. The medical system works a lot like our adaptive immune system when faced with a novel pathogen, and it takes some time for best practices to be discovered and promulgated. Even symptom treatment is going to seriously decrease all-cause mortality. Having volunteered at a large US metro board of health over the last two months, booking testing appointments and arranging result reporting, I can tell you that a substantial number of under-50s are being testing. Primarily families and people with exposure to a known case. Effectively, there are a few groups the virus spreads through: (Won't shelter)|(Can't shelter) + (Won't protect)|(Can't protect) + (Will protect) + (Will shelter). The spikes we're seeing are a consequence of public health policy + current SEIR proportions in those various groups. As more vulnerable groups are increasingly infected, they become immune (aka recovered), which decreases the ability the virus to transmit in those groups. And left with less vulnerable groups of susceptible individuals, effective reproductive number decreases. The danger of SARS-CoV-2, given the relatively low mortality (and based on genetic modeling of potential mutations), was never that it was going to crest with Ebola-like proportions (you get it, you die), but that it was going to crest with a magnitude that would overwhelm available medical resources. Unfortunately, that crest is a binary proposition: either you have spare medical capacity (and serious Covid-19 patients receive high-quality care) or you have none (and serious Covid-19 patients receive no treatment). So the danger is not death rates now. The danger is (effective reproductive number) -> (expected case count) -> (serious, hospitalized cases of Covid-19) -> (exhausted medical capacity) -> (Italy-esque spike in deaths). [0] https://rt.live/ https://rt.live/ [1] https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2020/06/17/dexamethasone-for-coronavirus-infection https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2020/06/17/de... [2] https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2020/05/15/good-news-on-the-human-immune-response-to-the-coronavirus https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2020/05/15/go...