4 ms·
I see your point with respect to the US, there's a very corporatist oligarchic tendency on the right, but I really don't see that in Europe at all. Europe has g
by simonh 6y ago
I see your point with respect to the US, there's a very corporatist oligarchic tendency on the right, but I really don't see that in Europe at all. Europe has gone to great lengths to stand up to corporations, and that includes many European conservatives of which I count myself one. There's a much broader acceptance among moderate European conservatives that regulation is essential to well functioning market economies for example.
In terms of facing up to Putin though, despite the fact that European governments, and as a result the EU, are less corporatist than the US they also tend to be softer on Putin. The Germans particularly, for example their support for the Russian gas pipeline.
Meanwhile the US has tended to want to be much tougher on Putin. In this respect Trump is an outlier. He definitely does seem to see Putin as a kindred sprit personally and seems incapable of dealign with him effectively, but this is not at all representative of Republican policy and attitude towards Putin over the last few decades. If anything it was the Democrats who tended to be over-optimistic about the chances of rapprochement with Russia as in the failed "reset' of relations under Obama.
So yes there are definitely corporatist oligarchic forces in the west that bear comparison with the Russian system, but I see them as mainly being US based not western in general. However that doesn't make them natural allies with Russian oligarchism, rather they're directly competitive power structures. Their similarities can potentially make them less compatible with each other not more. If they were to work out how to become compatible with each other we'd really be in terrible trouble.
- netsharc 6y agoI commented to a sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23676128 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23676128 Well, Merkel is "pro-business". Even she said auto dealers could reopen after a few weeks of lockdown, because of the German car lobby (it's sort of defensible if one considers automotive jobs are a big chunk of voters too). Meanwhile LuxLeaks is about tax breaks/evasion to the biggest corporations. Sadly, with this sort of elite, populists have it easy...
- toyg 6y agoRepublicans are anti-Russian from a military perspective, because some of their traditional interests are rooted in that industrial area and will always benefit from a heightened state of military urgency. That's the "John Bolton" wing, basically, which is mad at Trump for squandering their best opportunities of payday (you can't sell weaponry without an enemy, and it's hard to get a credible enemy when the key guy is so friendly to all the best candidates). That drives a lot of their other objections to Putin's reach. From an economic perspective, imho they display the same oligopolistic tendencies that Putin's Russia exhibits: lip service to competition and open markets (mostly abroad), ruthless devotion to monopolistic positions and cartels at home. The definition of "free markets" is declined differently depending on circumstances, in opportunistic fashion. I think that's what you mean by "competitive power structures" - they are competing entities, sure, but I personally don't see them as particularly different in the way they behave. Trump lays this bare by dropping the hypocrisy: him and Putin speak the same language, in the same way Putin and Berlusconi did. Both Trump and Berlusconi spent their lives in the trenches of "the Market". I don't think this is a coincidence. I also disagree on the view of Europe being significantly more anti-corporatist than the US, but I admit that my Anglo-Italian view might be excessively pessimistic in that area and it's a complex discussion anyway, so I won't go there. However, the difference in "softness" towards Putin imho is not there - the Eastern block in the EU, for example, is rabidly anti-Russian for understandable reasons. We simply know that we cannot live without Russian energy at the moment, and that results in some hard pragmatism.
- jgaa 6y agoRead the book. Pay attention to how russian money flow into London, the English elite and the conservative party there. Putin got at least one of his people /very/ close to Boris Johnson. Europe may pretend to have principles, something USA seems to have given up upon, but in the end, - for a huge part of the ruling class - it's all about the money.
- simonh 6y agoOh I’m sure there are plenty of people in the west who would like it to be all about the money, Trump for example looks at the corrupt oligarchic system in Russia and sees huge commercial opportunities, it’s right up his street. The trouble is the Russians keep insist on playing their stupid Cold War spy, assassination and destabilisation games mucking things up.