3 ms·
Putin and his friends do a pretty decent job of running an old-school oligarchy. That's not really the problem, there is nothing groundbreaking in their approac
by toyg 6y ago
Putin and his friends do a pretty decent job of running an old-school oligarchy. That's not really the problem, there is nothing groundbreaking in their approach.
The problem is that the "Western" bloc (if there ever was such a thing, really) is currently ruled by elites that fundamentally share those values: weak collective institutions, strong private corporations, the bottom line as the final measure of virtue, and exploitation of the weak as socially acceptable. That means "we" end up fundamentally unable to oppose putinism on a principle basis, let alone in practice.
That's how we end up with what the study reports: Western interests fundamentally welcome Putin's money and influence on a systemic level. "We" now run the world on gangster capitalism, and Putin is fairly good at playing that game. In fact, we will see more and more Putin-like figures appearing as time goes on.
Unless we significantly change the game, Putin will keep winning.
- w_t_payne 6y agoThat's a very interesting perspective. I shall have to ponder on that for a while.
- netsharc 6y agoJust look up https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luxembourg_Leaks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luxembourg_Leaks, and who got to be president of the European Commission for many years. Or what Paul Krugman (and Matthew Yglesias) surmised: https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/02/09/greece-the-tie-that-doesnt-bind/ https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/02/09/greece-the-tie-... ; when Greece got a bunch of left "radicalists" into power, it got the elite to bully mode, because usually (prime) ministers could be offered cushy European gigs as long as they do what the "elite" wants, but the non-tie-wearing Greeks actually wanted to save their population. The book "Adults in the Room" by Yanis Varoufakis is also an eye opener...
- simonh 6y agoI see your point with respect to the US, there's a very corporatist oligarchic tendency on the right, but I really don't see that in Europe at all. Europe has gone to great lengths to stand up to corporations, and that includes many European conservatives of which I count myself one. There's a much broader acceptance among moderate European conservatives that regulation is essential to well functioning market economies for example. In terms of facing up to Putin though, despite the fact that European governments, and as a result the EU, are less corporatist than the US they also tend to be softer on Putin. The Germans particularly, for example their support for the Russian gas pipeline. Meanwhile the US has tended to want to be much tougher on Putin. In this respect Trump is an outlier. He definitely does seem to see Putin as a kindred sprit personally and seems incapable of dealign with him effectively, but this is not at all representative of Republican policy and attitude towards Putin over the last few decades. If anything it was the Democrats who tended to be over-optimistic about the chances of rapprochement with Russia as in the failed "reset' of relations under Obama. So yes there are definitely corporatist oligarchic forces in the west that bear comparison with the Russian system, but I see them as mainly being US based not western in general. However that doesn't make them natural allies with Russian oligarchism, rather they're directly competitive power structures. Their similarities can potentially make them less compatible with each other not more. If they were to work out how to become compatible with each other we'd really be in terrible trouble.
- netsharc 6y agoI commented to a sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23676128 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23676128 Well, Merkel is "pro-business". Even she said auto dealers could reopen after a few weeks of lockdown, because of the German car lobby (it's sort of defensible if one considers automotive jobs are a big chunk of voters too). Meanwhile LuxLeaks is about tax breaks/evasion to the biggest corporations. Sadly, with this sort of elite, populists have it easy...
- toyg 6y agoRepublicans are anti-Russian from a military perspective, because some of their traditional interests are rooted in that industrial area and will always benefit from a heightened state of military urgency. That's the "John Bolton" wing, basically, which is mad at Trump for squandering their best opportunities of payday (you can't sell weaponry without an enemy, and it's hard to get a credible enemy when the key guy is so friendly to all the best candidates). That drives a lot of their other objections to Putin's reach. From an economic perspective, imho they display the same oligopolistic tendencies that Putin's Russia exhibits: lip service to competition and open markets (mostly abroad), ruthless devotion to monopolistic positions and cartels at home. The definition of "free markets" is declined differently depending on circumstances, in opportunistic fashion. I think that's what you mean by "competitive power structures" - they are competing entities, sure, but I personally don't see them as particularly different in the way they behave. Trump lays this bare by dropping the hypocrisy: him and Putin speak the same language, in the same way Putin and Berlusconi did. Both Trump and Berlusconi spent their lives in the trenches of "the Market". I don't think this is a coincidence. I also disagree on the view of Europe being significantly more anti-corporatist than the US, but I admit that my Anglo-Italian view might be excessively pessimistic in that area and it's a complex discussion anyway, so I won't go there. However, the difference in "softness" towards Putin imho is not there - the Eastern block in the EU, for example, is rabidly anti-Russian for understandable reasons. We simply know that we cannot live without Russian energy at the moment, and that results in some hard pragmatism.
- jgaa 6y agoRead the book. Pay attention to how russian money flow into London, the English elite and the conservative party there. Putin got at least one of his people /very/ close to Boris Johnson. Europe may pretend to have principles, something USA seems to have given up upon, but in the end, - for a huge part of the ruling class - it's all about the money.
- lnsru 6y agoWell, Putin is a trained spy. As I read Viktor Suvorov books, I see, that Soviet Union provided decent training and these people know how to reach their goals.
- pritovido 6y agoPutin is hated outside of Russia but is loved in Russia, because he cares about Russian interest first. Russia is the biggest country in the world. Has so many natural resources so has always been coveted by Empires: The French one and the German, now the US and financial elites Empire. It also counterweights US military power, something the US does not tolerate, they need to to destroy it like Roman Empire had to destroy Carthage in order to secure its hegemony. The president of Russia that would make US media happy is the kind of president that would make Russian people unhappy. A puppet from foreign powers. They want to break Russia in 10 or 20 pieces so they become much weaker and they can benefit bidding against each other. Your arguments are deeply flawed and based in dogmatism, not data. Western interest does not welcome Putin's money, Russia has very little money compared with Europe, the US and even China, it is a poor country. They care about energy and resources because in Germany people can not survive in Winter without energy. Is that simple. The industry also could not survive. Oh, and by the way the Russian also have nuclear weapons that could destroy Western countries in seconds. That also gives them influence. Nothing to do with capitalism. Several European countries spend more money in the public sector than in the private one, so you can call them socialist instead. With either socialism or capitalism, in Germany or Sweden you get -30 C in Winter. I was raised in a country with -(1-5)C and it is a completely different league. I am not Russian myself but completely understand their position.
- curation 6y agoAs someone who works in Russia for a few months every year, to say that Putin is loved by Russia is the same as saying Trump is loved by America. Putin has a base.
- toyg 6y agoRussian money is absolutely welcome over here - London is positively awash with it, from “Chelski” on down. It got to a point where laws had to be passed to stop the worst excesses (if one’s wealth is “unexplainable” now the UK government can crack down on it) and maintain a shred of decency. The post-Crimea sanctions annoyed a lot of people over here, I can assure you. Russia might be poor but Russian oligarchs are definitely not, and they do business like any other global oligarch does.
- chaoz_ 6y agoThe rate of Putin's acceptance has dropped by factor of 2 since 2015. I think the ease of information exchange is the game-changer. The point you're missing is that Russian gangsters've made some terrible decisions (from economic perspective) and now the only voters they only get old people who only have TV access. Which is still enough to manipulate elections, but I don't think it's going to continue forever. EDIT: There is also another social group that supports Putin. "Siloviki" and their families, which happens to be >1% of Russian population.
- pjc50 6y ago> gangsters've made some terrible decisions (from economic perspective) and now the only voters they only get old people who only have TV access. In America, that's an electable majority. Bit of voter suppression and making sure that it's difficult for working age people to vote just helps to push it over the line. Even more so in the UK, where 44% of the vote share gives total control.
- chaoz_ 6y agoI would not compare election quality of "Russia" with UK/US. For example, now we have a voting procedure during pandemics where nobody wants to go not to get infected with corona. But the old people get their voting papers home delivered by pro-Putin activists (Good targeting). It's also not rare for police to arrest key people from opposition and for us to see videos of voting stations based on the stump (literally) in the countryside. In US you have whole war of Facebook not handling AI enough and your "branches of power" do somewhat work. For sure you have your own problems, but Russia is on another level.
- fit2rule 6y ago>Unless we significantly change the game, Putin will keep winning. How we change the game - do these same studies on our own oligarchs. Treat the members of the CFR with the same interest in their financials.