4 ms·
> The revolutions in Georgia and Ukraine of 2004-5 fed Putin’s “dark paranoia” that the Kremlin was threatened by a western plot to topple his regime. The Kreml
by roenxi 6y ago
> The revolutions in Georgia and Ukraine of 2004-5 fed Putin’s “dark paranoia” that the Kremlin was threatened by a western plot to topple his regime. The Kremlin has subsequently revelled in escalating conflicts with the western powers as a marker of Russia’s newly regained stature on the world stage.
The US has spent a generation pushing first the Soviets, then Russia, back into a very tightly confined sphere of influence. There is no obvious limit to the amount of harm the US has been wishing on Russian interests.
It is a remarkably cycloptic perspective call such fears 'paranoid' or to paint Russia as some sort of aggressor. Russia isn't the one with military bases set up in North America. Russia isn't cutting people off from the global trade network or invading every other country in Western Asia. They are a relatively neutral country on the world stage in terms of aggressive foreign posture, even accounting for this article.
- maharajatever 6y agoThe bit that you miss is that the people who had the misfortune to live in the Russian "sphere of influence" did not want, and will never want to be in it. The former Russian "spheres of influence" are very happy to be out of it, and terrified by the prospect of finding themselves drawn into it.
- roenxi 6y agoI am the first person to criticise the Russian sphere of influence. They did a terrible job from the rise of the proletariat through to today. Even I could do a better job if left to administer the country. However to call them aggressors is a total perversion of the word aggression. Their posture is backs-to-the-wall defensive in relation to Western powers.
- redis_mlc 6y agoNo, Russian doctrine is to occupy neighboring countries to fight outside their own borders. Just because they're afraid of having their "backs-to-the-wall" doesn't mean their doctrine is legitimate.
- redis_mlc 6y agoDescription of how Russian military doctrine resulted in the annexation of the Baltic states in WW2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupation_of_the_Baltic_states https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupation_of_the_Baltic_state...
- toyg 6y ago> They did a terrible job from the rise of the proletariat They did a terrible job even before that, with "The Great Game" and all that. In fact, it was so bad even their own people had had enough.
- dreen 6y agoThey are absolutely aggressors, and the defensive posturing is something they (Russian leaders) have used for centuries to excuse aggression. Their armies never conquer, they "liberate". This is not a tactic unique to them, but one they excel in.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- slezyr 6y ago> such fears 'paranoid' or to paint Russia as some sort of aggressor. Did you missed how Russia invaded those both countries? It's an aggressor.
- roenxi 6y agoI don't think anyone in Russia is going to mistake either Georgia or the Ukraine for a major western power plotting to overthrow Putin's regime.
- orbital-decay 6y agoYou're making their point, kind of. The conflict of 08.08.08 started with Georgians attacking a city of Tskhinvali with MRLs, a very indiscriminate weapon. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Tskhinvali#Georgian_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Tskhinvali#Georgian_...
- wickerman 6y agoYou hit the nail right on the head. The underlying rusophobia that has been eaten and digested by the english-speaking world after the cold war never ceases to amaze me, particularly in the face of the global threat that is the american military power. America has military bases outside of their own country all over the world and has a proven track record of interfering in other countries' politics, causing several wars, yet Russia is always the bad guy?
- TomMarius 6y agoI am very thankful for all the American bases protecting my formerly Warsaw Pact country from being in the pact again. This is how Russia behaves to us, I think my position is understandable. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/apr/10/russia-opens-criminal-case-after-czech-officials-remove-soviet-statue https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/apr/10/russia-opens-c...
- surewhynat 6y agoTry taking down an American statue right now, and enjoy your mandatory sentence. Enjoy your bases.
- lovelyviking 6y agoYour position is very understandable. I wish Ukraine would be in that position.
- ForHackernews 6y ago> invading every other country in Western Asia No, only its nearby neighbors. Maybe ask Ukrainians or Georgians how they feel about the Russian sphere of influence.
- trabant00 6y agoYou blew it in the second paragraph. Russia is not a very active aggressor these days because it was successfully contained by the west, not by choice.
- 082349872349872 6y agoNot as successful as it might have been. US troops had once been on russian soil[1] but were withdrawn. If they'd provided more assistance Wrangel might've had more luck in ukraine[2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Expeditionary_Force,_North_Russia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Expeditionary_Force,_... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Civil_War#South_Russia,_Ukraine_and_Kronstadt_(1920–21) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Civil_War#South_Russia...
- dgellow 6y agoRussia invaded Ukraine in 2014. I don’t know what else you want them to do to be considered aggressors.
- Synaesthesia 6y agoWhat about the western backed coup in Ukraine and the fact that in eastern Ukraine the people asked Russia to intervene.
- fit2rule 6y agoDon't bother, most of the people with an interest in discussing Russia have not one iota of understanding of the difference between 'invading' a country and 'annexing' it, or they choose to willingly conflate the two since it works against American's interest in this discussion: Russia annexed Crimea. America invaded Iraq.
- nieve 6y agoWell yes, America's "invasion" was a muddle of confused goals & retaliation while Russias "annexation" was conquest. You're quite right that they're different. One does massive incompetent damage while not intending to stay, the other does its damage deliberately with an eye towards the long term health of their newly conquered territory. Russia's imperial ambitions on their western borders aren't exactly new.
- fit2rule 6y agoYour attempt to cast Russias annexation of territory it has had claims on for hundreds of years as a misdeed isn't really effective. There were actual Russian civilians being protected by Russian forces during that process. There was a fully armed nuclear base that was under threat of falling into the wrong hands during the Ukraine uprising (which, incidentally, the rest of the world knows full well was funded by the CIA). Iraq lost 5% of its population during the American invasion. How many Americans were in Iraq, who were under direct threat of violence from a fascist group involved in a coup d'etat? Russia hasn't reached America's level of evil, destructive, criminal warfare, that is for sure. The claim that America was surgical and careful in its invasion(s) is specious at best, but really just downright evil. Literally millions of people are still suffering from the effects of America's callous invasion. 4 million innocent people have lost their lives under America's war machine. How many Ukraine soldiers did Russia take during the annexation? Not even comparable levels of magnitude, no matter how finely tuned your moral relativism chops are ..