3 ms·
> He first states he doesn't know where the revenue comes from and then makes a lot of details decisions based on revenues (android apparently needs only a few
by MattGaiser 6y ago
> He first states he doesn't know where the revenue comes from and then makes a lot of details decisions based on revenues (android apparently needs only a few buildings and engineers).
He proposes 5 spin off companies.
Advertising is fine.
It’s not clear that YouTube is profitable. And it does have a big synergy in the immense infrastructure.
Android he admits isn’t a business beyond trying to bill every user for using it.
I doubt Maps has much value except in combination with the ad business unless they stopped doing consumer stuff and mostly focused on GPS and corporate guidance systems. It would be fundamentally different.
With Cloud, he assumes that it is the vendor of every other service. Why would they bother with consumer stuff if they now have to pivot to infrastructure for the successor companies? It would turn into the equivalent of a REIT and would just pay a dividend. That is where investors take companies that have reliable cash cow businesses with limited growth potential.
- LatteLazy 6y agoTo me it felt really dishonest because at least some of these services would die and others would become the sort of shitty cash hungry monopoly we see elsewhere in the economy if it weren't for Googles (far from perfect) stewardship. I even empathise with the monopoly/privacy/advertising concerns. I just think he's either writing a protest article he knows can never be implimented (or taken seriously) OR he's trying to achieve his goal by tricking people into something most don't actually want.
- tarsinge 6y agoShitty cash hungry monopoly like OpenStreetMap? I’m ready to bet Google Maps dying could lead to a huge interest in improving OSM instead of the opposite today. Also email is an interoperable standard so I don’t see a monopoly coming soon, it’s not AOL era anymore. Before monopolies there is competition, and if monopolies come then break them. It’s not like it never happened before and “these times it’s different”. Edit: I have nothing against Google but it’s not a charity, if some of their services are now essential and are not adequately provided by private entities then it simple it’s a public service. What would you say if Google was starting a service to give free food? I’m not it’s the big Corp displacing government dystopia future I want.
- LatteLazy 6y agoDo you really think Openstreetmap is an alternative to Google maps? Really? This is our vision for the future? Anyone who spends 5 minutes on there will be begging to give Google their data. We're meant to be improving things, not just reverting to the 1940s approach but with a website to look at the paperwork on...
- emptysongglass 6y agoI use OSM all the time in the form of the app, OsmAnd. Fantastic app, gets me where I'm going, has most shops indexed: the few times it didn't I added them myself and benefited everyone. I especially like that, as a cyclist, it always picks the greener path for me to get through Copenhagen. Huge feature over Google Maps for me. I'd really like to see better transit directions. OsmAnd does have them but not stop-by-stop.
- tarsinge 6y agoMy point is that Google Maps prevents the development of OSM.
- dorgo 6y ago>Also email is an interoperable standard If emails from no-name servers/domains are increasingly dropped/refused (considered spam), is email still interoperable?
- tarsinge 6y agoThat's not my experience, but if that's the case then one more reason for the break up.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agoMaps would have to be ad-based to be viable. The question is if it would be viable without feeding to/from the rest of Google's ad business, or if it would have to resort to Yelp-style thinly disguised extortion to survive. "Nice restaurant you got there, it'd be a real shame if it fell to page 17 in the listings and all the one-star reviews were listed first. Did you know you can delete negative reviews and get guaranteed first page if you buy the Premium package?"