3 ms·
Ironically, I'd argue that FLOSS has simply served to enable proprietary software vendors. In embedded/IoT, devices might use FLOSS but they are usually violat
by pabs3 6y ago
Ironically, I'd argue that FLOSS has simply served to enable proprietary software vendors.
In embedded/IoT, devices might use FLOSS but they are usually violating the licenses and the parts that make the device special are usually proprietary (think robot vacuums running Linux with a proprietary daemon doing house mapping etc). Often there are proprietary drivers or firmware too.
In servers FLOSS operating systems have indeed won, but lower level hardware-facing software like UEFI has not and indeed most proprietary UEFI implementations are based on FLOSS implementations, but with proprietary features or hardware support added that means users can't use the FLOSS version.
On the web FLOSS has indeed won, it is fairly rare to use proprietary JS/backend frameworks, but the things that are built using FLOSS web tools are mostly proprietary.
On the cloud FLOSS may have won the VM side, but the hypervisor side is trade secret land and management interfaces are mostly proprietary, very few cloud vendors use OpenStack.
Gaming consoles may use some bits of FLOSS internally, but they are locked down and proprietarised.
Mobile OSes may use some bits of FLOSS internally, but they are locked down and proprietarised to the extent that it takes a lot of work to get Linux running on a newly released device, sometimes even requiring exploiting security vulnerabilities.
Enterprise Software might be based on FLOSS but it is all proprietary at the end of the day.
On the desktop, the trend continues, macOS is FLOSS+proprietary, Chrome OS is FLOSS+proprietary.
- foobar_ 6y agoPrecisely, this is why I think open data should be the next battle. All code takes input and gives output. I don't mind closed source as long as the interfaces are open ... but data being bought and sold is really troubling. Apart from public data sets, most data sets are closed. I am not sure if there are companies that publish all the data they collected openly.
- pabs3 6y agoThe data issue is that it most of it shouldn't be collected in the first place, not that it should be public.
- foobar_ 6y agoWell thats a chicken and egg problem in a way. Without data you can't build some types of software. I think you have three types of data. 1. Private data / Linked Data This is the data contributed by the user. Shopping data for example. I think the EU data laws are meant to guard this. I think it is both unethical and illegal to sell / publish primary data without the user's consent. 2. Public data In social networks you also get interaction data, which the user had made public. I don't see any reason for companies not to publish this. Right now people use crawling to get this data. 3. Insights This is the data generated by ML and statistical analytics. By open data I mean user should be able to get a dump of all three and the organisation should? publish 2 openly and 3 if it wants to openly as well. Also see: http://www.veen.com/jeff/archives/000810.html http://www.veen.com/jeff/archives/000810.html