This is such an interesting take. I find it exceedingly difficult to argue with any of your points but I might add one which, though subjective or arguable, may

This is such an interesting take. I find it exceedingly difficult to argue with any of your points but I might add one which, though subjective or arguable, may change your mind or at least offer some insight into why some people love his work. I find Herzog to be low-key hilarious. Pretty much all my friends, who also dig his work, do as well. I think he tips his hand in this regard quite a bit with Bad Lieutenant 2. Also, notice how when he speaks to live audiences the way he feeds off their laughter and I would argue here is also playing them for laughs in a way a comedian would. I’m not saying that Herzog is a pure comedic film maker such as Mel Brooks or something but his movies take on a whole new dimension when you realize that yes he is taking a hard look at horror sometimes but I think he also laughs at absurdity quite a bit as well. Also, his DIY attitude and strong work ethic are admirable qualities as well.