5 ms·
That author is all over the place. It's a general rant about the obvious. At the beginning, he's on to something. Fiction has a plot shortage. "Across TV, mov
by Animats 6y ago
That author is all over the place. It's a general rant about the obvious.
At the beginning, he's on to something. Fiction has a plot shortage. "Across TV, movies, and novels it is increasingly difficult to find a compelling story that doesn’t rely on gimmicks." Movies are stuck in the Star [Wars|Trek|Gate] ditch, and the Marvel Overextended Universe. The 25th James Bond movie is supposed to come out this year, if anybody cares.
Some of this is simply the entertainment glut. Everyone has seen all the possible plot twists. Go back in history and read some of the Canterbury Tales from around 1400. Read a story half way through, then ask yourself how it will end. You'll be right. There are no plot twists. Back then, entertainment was so scarce that they weren't needed.
A more serious problem is that there's no shared vision of a better world. Fiction doesn't help us get to a better place. This hit science fiction first. Science fiction of the 1930s to the 1960s was quite upbeat, showing a picture of a marvelous future. It's been downhill since the 1970s. Today SF is mostly space opera. Dystopian visions used to be rare. Now most SF is dystopian. Even much non-SF is dystopian. From The Wire to Game of Thrones, the world sucks.
- csa 6y agoYou seem to be reviewing this essay as though it is about entertainment narratives. I see it being a fairly scathing critique of the disingenuous narrative of modern day middle class bureaucrats.
- Animats 6y agoThat essay is all over the place. I just started at the beginning.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Go back in history and read some of the Canterbury Tales from around 1400. Read a story half way through, then ask yourself how it will end. You'll be right. There are no plot twists. Back then, entertainment was so scarce that they weren't needed. Well no, entertainment wasn't scarce. Different, but not scarce. Audience desires could be different, too: http://arthurkingoftimeandspace.com/2199.htm http://arthurkingoftimeandspace.com/2199.htm