3 ms·
This is just a very extended rewrite of a stock right-wing trope: you can't trust educated people, because they're fakes and they don't understand real down-to-
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
This is just a very extended rewrite of a stock right-wing trope: you can't trust educated people, because they're fakes and they don't understand real down-to-earth hard working middle class Americans.
I don't think he's wrong about tech being primarily about increasingly automated bureaucracy, and not about open innovation - certainly not in business, and even less so socially and culturally.
But ultimately this is decided by Wall St, which is controlled by money, most of which is ultimately managed by billionaires, some of whom have exotic far-right sympathies.
Note there's no criticism of right wing story-telling - propaganda - outfits like the Kochs or the Mercers. The targets are exclusively on the progressive side.
Trump may have won as a not-business-as-usual candidate, but that doesn't mean he was ever truly a not-business-as-usual president. It means that was the story sold to voters who felt left behind and excluded - just as Obama was sold as the black history redemption candidate, who turned out to have limited interest in doing anything too controversially concrete or transformative with the opportunity.
Instead of challenging the cynical sleight-of-message involved in the industrial manipulation of all demographics, the author chooses to slant his thesis towards praising one demographic at the expense of another.
It's a good attempt and more literate than most - but it's not nearly as incisive or even-handed as it pretends to be.
- csa 6y ago> This is just a very extended rewrite of a stock right-wing trope: you can't trust educated people, because they're fakes and they don't understand real down-to-earth hard working middle class Americans. Interesting. My takeaway is about 180 degrees from this. I think he’s saying that the vast majority of college graduates are not particularly well-educated. Furthermore, this class of people is just filling the role of very middle class bureaucrats while being sold on the narrative of being something more (e.g., part of the creative class or upper / upper middle class), all while being incredibly conformist in their non-conformity. You say that the targets are “progressives”, but I would say his targets are “poseur progressives”. As someone who highly values the former and is ambivalent about the masses of the latter (esp. in the Bay Area), I agree with the author’s lament of the rise of faux progressives (if, in fact, that is what he is lamenting).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- runawaybottle 6y agoI think the author doesn’t go after the right-wing house of mirrors because it has far less indirection. What veil do you think the right-wing puts up over your eyes that distorts their message? It’s pretty clear what they mean to say, and what they believe. The mental gymnastics are all occurring on the new left and hyper vain social media stratosphere where true values and beliefs are a muddled mess. Since they are in this amorphous stage, they are vulnerable to solidifying into forms that propagate the status quo.