5 ms·
For a professor, the author does a terrible job presenting the complete picture, and like most in academia, select those data points which "support" their claim
by verdverm 6y ago
For a professor, the author does a terrible job presenting the complete picture, and like most in academia, select those data points which "support" their claims. You should not trust their opinions.
If you look at the stats, Covid is less deadly than the typical flu for those under 30. Time to stop destroying the youth by de-educating them. Stop being so scared. Let locals decided how to handle things. Stop picking isolated stories and applying blanket rules.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Zigurd 6y ago"Less deadly than the typical flu" itself amounts to cherry picking. Weeks to months of symptoms, and 4%+ rate of hospitalization for COVID-19 even in the college age group makes it much worse than a typical flu and capable of overwhelming health care systems if you put people in the college age group indoors in lecture halls, labs, meeting rooms, and faculty offices for 45+ minutes several times a day grouped with different people each time. This also involves an invalid comparison: College-age students, if they were broken-out by age among flu deaths, would show a very low death rate from flu, and COVID-19 death rates would be 5X+ higher, as they are proportionately for other age groups. Now let's talk about sacrificing the faculty on the alter of reopening.
- xbmcuser 6y agoEven if younger people are not dying some have reported lasting problems after. We will find out after 1-2 years only the actual effect on the survivors not dying doesn't mean nothing happened
- mrfusion 6y agoWhat percent of infected young people have lasting problems?
- ci5er 6y agoI understand that lung scarring for the "lightly" symptomatic can be ... not insignificant. I know it is for me (age: 55 y.o. or so), and while it isn't being currently problematic, but I have no idea about how it might present in 20 years.
- chadash 6y agoCan you point out some specifics that you disagree with? The author doesn't make the case that students are gonna die. It's more the staff and faculty, plus the possibilities that students are vectors for spreading the virus.
- yardie 6y agoThat’s a serious assertion you are making. COVID-19 is 10 times deadlier than the flu across the population. Dropping to almost 0 for babies. But we can’t let infants run the country while everyone > 30 stays home.
- claudeganon 6y agoWe initially thought it might be true for the young, but the deaths of infants and severe complications in children now suggests otherwise. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/05/200511142153.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/05/200511142153.h...
- bobthechef 6y agoFWIW, he’s a clinical professor at NYU and a showman.
- geofft 6y ago> If you look at the stats, Covid is less deadly than the typical flu for those under 30. By "less deadly" you mean "once infected, more people survive covid than the flu," right? But isn't it more infectious - and doesn't the longer incubation time make it more deceptive? It's fairly easy to control flu outbreaks, even in environments like college campuses, by telling people to stay home. (And you usually don't even need to tell them that, because they'll feel too sick to not stay home.)
- michaelmrose 6y agoGetting covid at 30 is more dangerous than getting the flu at 30. If you want to argue otherwise please provide an actual peer reviewed study not a non scientists opinion piece or a pre print of a non peer reviewed study. Even if it were merely as dangerous getting the flu at 30 doesn't result in you infecting as many people and not as many of those people subsequently die. Many people pass it on before they get any sort of symptoms and therefore are unable to just stay home and not pass it around. Please stop passing around dangerous misinformation. Your advice could literally kill people.