4 ms·
Militaries are reliant on domestic production and labor. (Paying Chinese solider costs the government a fraction as much as an American soldier.) So instead of
by rayiner 6y ago
Militaries are reliant on domestic production and labor. (Paying Chinese solider costs the government a fraction as much as an American soldier.) So instead of an exchange rate conversion, you should be doing a purchasing-power conversion. For these three countries, that means multiplying by 2x to 4x.
Also, the US is particularly inefficient at capital spending. It costs us a billion dollars to build a mile of subway, and costs countries like France a fraction of that. So that weighs further in favor of discounting our spending in that comparison.
- CydeWeys 6y agoThe majority of DoD's budget is not salaries. Only the salaries should be scaled in this way. E.g. many other countries are buying our F-35s at the same price we are. Other countries simply can't get equally effective jet fighters, aircraft carriers, etc., at a third to a quarter of the price.
- icegreentea2 6y agoYou're correct, personnel costs is not the majority of DoD costs. However, their "pay and benefits" take up 40% of it's budget (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States#For_personnel_payment_and_benefits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_...) Procurement (the most visible part of the budget we hear about) is 20% of the DoD budget.
- samstave 6y agoAlso, one needs to take into account Black Budgets - as they are totally opaque and we have no idea what amount of the budget they consume, assuming they are even accounted for in the 700 billion dollar number the budget claims to be.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 6y agoWhy would only salaries be scaled that way? It costs China a fraction as much as the U.S. to build a train line. Do you think it costs them the same amount in nominal dollars to build a landmine?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jupp0r 6y ago> So instead of an exchange rate conversion, you should be doing a purchasing-power conversion. Are soldiers with greater purchasing power more effective on the battlefield?
- samstave 6y agoThats a really interesting question. My brother was a Colonel in the airforce, Commander of the 10th Medical Wing. He is a really successful doctor who then led the VA for the state of alaska... He is now CEO for a hospital in Idaho. The point is that his life path was truly successful for him through the military and he has added great value to the nation through that experience. Had he been a minion in a more oppressive style regime, such as China - or North Korea, or even Russia, then I would expect he would have been less effective at being such a positive value to those nations as he is to the US. And this is due only in a small part as to his ability to have a happy, successful material life here in the US and also raise an amazing family.
- tsimionescu 6y agoI can only applaud your brother's accomplishments! That said, why do you believe that he succeeded because of the military and not in spite of it? Is his story in any way typical for veterans? From my understanding, not at all. Also, why do you assume that Russian or Chinese military service is less valued or constructive for their service members than US service? Are you basing this on something, or just the general image created by US media about the Chinese and Russian armed forces?
- samstave 6y agoThanks for your reply -- Ill be honest - I evaluated my statement based on your response, and the only thing I can come up with WRT what I am basing it on is actually a bias to my understanding of how corrupt those regimes are.... now, thats not to say that the US doesnt have a problem with corruption (its getting worse, here in the US, whereby politicians are enriching themselves at the expense of others -- see "politicians made millions from stock trade before the pandemic information was released" type stories)
- catalogia 6y agoNo matter which way you slice it, America has a very capable blue water navy while China's barely qualifies. They're on tier with India, Italy, and Russia; only capable of force-projection in their neighborhood. Besides the US, France and the UK are capable of global power projection; that's it. And both of those are in NATO too.
- nl 6y agoFrance isn't in NATO. Edit: ok they are. But they did attempt to withdraw and were only stopped by the 20 year rule. And they still don't have unified nuclear command. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Withdrawal_from_NATO https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Withdrawal_from_NATO
- detaro 6y agoFrance is a founding member of NATO.
- catalogia 6y agoFrance was a member of NATO from the very beginning. In the 60s France had some manner of dispute with the rest of NATO and disassociated themselves in some capacity, but technically remained a member. Since 2009, French/NATO relations have been largely normalized, I think with the exception of how the French government chooses to control France's nukes. > Edit: ok they are. But they did attempt to withdraw and were only stopped by the 20 year rule. And they still don't have unified nuclear command. Be that as it may, I don't think Americans need an expensive navy to protect themselves from the French.
- tenuousemphasis 6y agoThat would be news to NATO. https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/nato_countries.htm https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/nato_countries.htm
- fauigerzigerk 6y ago>So instead of an exchange rate conversion, you should be doing a purchasing-power conversion. For these three countries, that means multiplying by 3x or 4x. Where did you get those numbers from? According to the OECD the renminbi PPP rate is 4.198 whereas the the current exchange rate is 7. That's 1.67x not 3x. https://data.oecd.org/conversion/purchasing-power-parities-ppp.htm https://data.oecd.org/conversion/purchasing-power-parities-p...
- Lineup 6y agoNow equalize labor cost... tada!
- fauigerzigerk 6y agoPPP does include labour. Whether or not it adequately reflects the share of labour costs for the Chinese military I don't know.