6 ms·
Crispr gene editing in human embryos wreaks chromosomal mayhem
- vikramkr 6y agoThis highlights why it was so irresponsible to create CRISPR babies, and why you take things slow in science. Don't let the analogies about bio being programmable just like a computer fool you - it's not that easy or that simple. Bio is messy and complex. Note: looks like these findings are from preprint, and so still need to undergo peer review. This is a phenomenon that was anticipated however based on the science, even though as the article states there some controversy around the specific mechanisms at play.
- shpongled 6y agoAs a biologist and programmer, nothing makes me roll my eyes harder than SV types talking about biology like a computer. The analogy might hold if we treated CPUs like a magical artifact that we don't have the technology to understand.
- vikramkr 6y agoI don't know if that would be enough to make the analogy hold, since what we do know about biology includes a lot of things that are distinctly non-computer like. At the end of the day, one is a system designed by humans for humans, while the other is a system that's an emergent phenomena of billions of years of chemistry, physics, and statistics. In computers you create the rules and then build systems that follow the rules, and then push the rules to their limits to see what you can do. In bio the only rule is that an arrangement of atoms that's more likely to replicate a version if itself into a future time period will be more likely to be found in that future time period compared to an arrangement of atoms that isn't. And that principle has had 4+ billion years to play with the rules of physics to see what it can do, and we're just trying to decipher that now.
- shpongled 6y agoI mean, I think that there is some merit to biology-computer analogies, I just don't think anyone can expect those analogies to hold in reality. But you are exactly on point. There are presumably "rules" in biology, but they are occluded by spooky action a distance and oodles of hidden and ever-changing state.
- jfarlow 6y agoI think it's important not to say that biology is somehow 'spooky', or not governed by physical rules. We actually know the outlines of those rules pretty well - they're just complicated. The really big difference is that biology computes at overlapping time and distance scales, simultaneously. There are biological computational processes that occur at microseconds, to millennia, from fractions of a nanometer to kilometers all happing in concert and referencing each other. In the building of our own computational tools we generally try to avoid mixing physical scales like that. The analogies to computers aren't inherently wrong, they just need to mix in a lot more complexity.
- shpongled 6y ago"Spooky action at a distance" doesn't imply that it's not governed by physical rules - and I think it's certainly a valid descriptor for biological systems as a whole. Yes, we can break down aspects of biology into nice subsystems that we can define rules for - e.g. we have a pretty good idea of how DNA polymerase, or the ribosome carry out their duties (in isolation). It's when we start looking at the emergent properties of having all of these things in one larger system that our understanding starts to break down.
- Johnjonjoan 6y agoBiology is more like a class where everything's private and there was no documentation on the public methods (for us)
- Barrin92 6y agoin biology nothing is private or even in a class because in biology there is no designer, so there is no need for encapsulation. One of the more and more prominent insights in biology is that almost every gene apparently appears to influence everything else.[1] Which is why I think methods like CRISPR are fundamentally misguided for anything but the most simple problems. Trying to impose deliberate change on biological systems by editing a single gene is like trying to turn a story from drama into comedy by switching out individual letters. [1]https://www.quantamagazine.org/omnigenic-model-suggests-that-all-genes-affect-every-complex-trait-20180620/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/omnigenic-model-suggests-that...
- Johnjonjoan 6y agoI'm curious why you're so sure there isn't a designer.
- discreteevent 6y agoOne can never be sure, but from all the evidence it looks like that if there was a designer, they weren't operating at this level, so the parents point is unaffected by this concern.
- Johnjonjoan 6y agoI'm unsure, the only contradictory point to my proposition was that there was no designer. "in biology nothing is private or even in a class because in biology there is no designer, so there is no need for encapsulation." How can the point be unaffected if you are rightly saying the point is in question? Are we on the same level as the implementation when we write our classes?
- 6y ago
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> This highlights why it was so irresponsible to create CRISPR babies, and why you take things slow in science. Don't let the analogies about bio being programmable just like a computer fool you - it's not that easy or that simple. Bio is messy and complex. > As a biologist and programmer, nothing makes me roll my eyes harder than SV types talking about biology like a computer. Same. But in truth, I'm glad this experiment took place, we need to adhere to the rigors that uphold the notion of incremental progress for a desirable end, and this begins by quantifying just how immense this problem really is. I'm glad that Dr. Jiankui He did it anyway. It cost him his career and he will likely remain as a cautionary tale for all other future biologists in academia, but in Biohacking scene he is really no different then the pioneers in cell biology that often resorted to self experimentation, History in Biology is such a fickle thing: we'll laud them when the outcomes favour conventional wisdom and it accepts there methods, but infamy awaits anyone who defies to go out of its per-ordained confines. Even though we all accept that the walled garden of peer-reviewed publication is flawed and riddled with so many unnecessary things that encumber its ability to live up to its potential when it can use unorthodox or unconventional means and methods. The Health Sciences, specifically that of genetics and cellular and molecular biology, has a history of being the punk-rock branch. Where even a monk playing with peas in his free time can help establish the notion of inheritable mutation (Mendelian genetics) based on adaption created by a British Medical school drop out who took to sea-fairing and island hopping to create the concept of what we'd eventually call Darwinian Evolution. This is our History and as a Cell/Molecular Biologist myself, I take great pride in it and I have tried my best to live up to this reputation and apply this to my work in Agricultural and Food Sciences after abandoning my career as a lab scientist. Dr. He got consent from the parents to undergo this procedure and move Biology in a territory it otherwise would never go for another couple of decades at the earliest. This is more than what some physicians did not too long ago, and the data we obtained from those experiments proved incredibly useful to this day.
- throwaway4666 6y agoPeer-review has its problems but I don't think the solution is 'we need more people carelessly injecting themselves and others with things with unknown effects'. I think the covid crisis aptly showed that the 'plucky outsider that defies a reactionary authority' archetype doesn't actually exist in real life. And biohacking itself is largely a grift.
- CWuestefeld 6y agoSV types What's "SV"?
- tyingq 6y agoSilicon Valley.
- crawfordcomeaux 6y agoI wonder what your take is on this. "Brain computation by assemblies of neurons" https://www.pnas.org/content/117/25/14464 https://www.pnas.org/content/117/25/14464
- vaidhy 6y agoThe double negative in the title of the original article is bad editing - it either wrecks the chromosomes or creates a mayhem. If it wrecks the mayhem, it is a good thing(TM).
- shpongled 6y agoThe title says "wreaks", not "wrecks".
- dafoex 6y agoYes, I believe that is correct. The expression is, after all, "wreaks havoc".
- satvikpendem 6y agoWreaks, not wrecks.
- mrfusion 6y agoI’m confused. Don’t we use crispr all the time on other organisms? Mice, drosophila, etc. wouldn’t we already have seen this?
- Amorymeltzer 6y agoBrief background: CRISPR originated as a pseudo-adaptive immune system in bacteria to fight against phage viruses, including the Cas9 protein. We can use it outside of bacteria (ie, in eukaryotes) because we can customize the adapter/recognition RNA molecules used, usually around 25-30 baseppairs long IIRC. Some quick reasons: - A 25 base-pair RNA can probably kinda-sort-sometimes bind/recognize sequences as short as around 5 basepairs. It may not be the majority of incidences, but it can happen. - There are different Cas9 proteins. They do many things, with some are more effective at certain activities and some eliciting a stronger host response. There's a balancing act. - The human genome is somewhere around 1000 times larger than a bacteria like E. coli. - We have seen them! Tons of them! Scientists will customize and tweak proteins and RNAs to match a given organism. It's obviously harder in humans...
- rwbhn 6y agoFTA: Previous work using CRISPR in mouse embryos and other kinds of human cell had already demonstrated that editing chromosomes can cause large, unwanted effects.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- _nothing 6y agoWhat makes you think we haven't? "Previous work using CRISPR in mouse embryos and other kinds of human cell had already demonstrated that editing chromosomes can cause large, unwanted effects. But it was important to demonstrate the work in human embryos as well, says Urnov, because different cell types might respond to genome editing differently." It says of one study "Of 18 genome-edited embryos, about 22% contained unwanted changes". Such a failure rate probably isn't such a big deal in some applications. In embryos, especially human embryos, it's definitely a big deal.
- reedwolf 6y agoLooks like biological systems are kind of complicated.
- RocketSyntax 6y ago"the researchers used CRISPR–Cas9 to create mutations in the POU5F1 gene, which is important for embryonic development." Title should say "researcher succeeds in disrupting embryo development"
- dafoex 6y agoBiological noob here, but isn't Cas9 not well suited for humans? I recall that I read or heard somewhere that Cas12 was preferred for this usecase.
- aurizon 6y agoLet's face it. Crispr was evolved by bacterial cells in the grip of a phage virus invader. It had to act with enormous speed to try to get ahead of the virus's high speed reproduction machinery and spread the word to successor generations - if any. Fidelity was sacrificed to make an RNA threshing machine and even then it lost more often than it won against the phage. The winners trapped those palindromically patterned bits and lived to breed another day - maybe.
- xvilka 6y agoMy intuition suggests that the precise editing will not work out no matter the technology used. What I see is something that can read and combine traits from multiple places scattered all over DNA, calculate some kind of acceptable range, be able to change that range that "recalculates" DNA then edit it in multiple places simultaneously. This will work on just tuning the genome though.
- xvilka 6y agoI wonder why I haven't heard about the efforts to design gene editing tools from scratch using protein design. So they will not "steal" some poor bacteria IP, but will build a customized tool based on the requirements. Hard problem? Absolutely. But it will pay out in the long-term, also will allow to improve these proteins over time.
- aurizon 6y agoThis exact scenario is now evolving in dozens of labs the world over to use the essence of the initial CRISPR mechanism in a new and superior(patentable) way to perform gene edits in the precise location with the precise new information required. It will end up better, but probably slower and surer.