5 ms·
Why does the dark matter stop? Don't colliding galaxies stop due to gravity, which dark matter is equally affected by?
by lostmsu 6y ago
Why does the dark matter stop? Don't colliding galaxies stop due to gravity, which dark matter is equally affected by?
- yongjik 6y agoGalaxies are drawn toward each other due to gravity, but when they meet ordinary matters "stop" because lumps of gas plow against each other, causing them to lose energy and stop. Dark matter doesn't interact with anything else (or even itself) so they pass right through each other.
- chadcmulligan 6y agoSo does that mean there are some galaxies without dark matter - because of a previous collision? And then some dark matter only galaxies, because they left their galaxy behind? I suppose this is unknown - but does the dark matter reappear in the galaxy later somehow, or it's left behind forever? Edit: well there are galaxies without dark matter (maybe) [1] and there are dark matter galaxies [2] [1] https://www.space.com/19-galaxies-missing-dark-matter.html https://www.space.com/19-galaxies-missing-dark-matter.html [2] https://www.space.com/33850-weird-galaxy-is-mostly-dark-matter.html https://www.space.com/33850-weird-galaxy-is-mostly-dark-matt...
- corty 6y agoreappearance is possible in collision sims, but the timescale is too long to be easily observable.
- The_rationalist 6y agoI remember that a few years ago a galaxy had been discovered with a claimed ~>90% of dark matter. Personally I believe the theory is epistemologically weaker than MOND
- nwallin 6y agoSame reason cars stop when they hit a brick wall. Most of the mass of galaxies isn't in their stars (which, for the most part, keep moving with the dark matter) it's in gas clouds and dust formations. When two galaxies collide, the gas and dust effectively halts. What we see when galaxies collide is that most of the mass of the galaxies move straight through each other without appreciably decelerating. And most of the matter, the gas clouds and star forming regions, halt in the middle. MOND was taken seriously as a theory from its inception in the '70s through the end of the 20th century, but because of the bullet cluster, it is effectively dead. MOND is falsified by observational evidence. For this article to discuss MOND so thoroughly, but not mention the bullet cluster once... It doesn't pass the smell test. This is pseudo-scientific trash. There's other evidence against MOND and various alternative-gravity models (there are several of them, it's a large umbrella) but most of them do a very poor job at explaining the edge cases, such as the bullet cluster and ultra diffuse galaxies. Some ultra diffuse galaxies have a conspicuous absence of gravitational lensing and stars which orbit extraordinarily slowly; ie, they have very little dark matter. If the explanation for dark matter was that we had the laws of physics wrong, the newly revised gravitational theories should apply equally well to these galaxies- which they don't.
- manquer 6y agoWhile the article is perhaps not written as well it could have been, alternative gravity is probably indeed bust, the point that other theories need to be funded and studied is valid. it is not a either/or scenario. The argument the article makes is that just because emergent gravity or many alternative candidates potentially cannot explain all of evidence that dark matter can , does not mean it should be thrown out completely and rejected, it could be still funded and studied to see if it can explain some of it. The real issue is given the way modern academic funding works we have been tending more and more towards narrower research with main line theories and lesser riskier proposals perhaps being incentivised. This is not just limited not dark matter , this phenomenon is evident in string theory research and many other fields as well.
- narrator 6y agoHow about we fund somebody like a George Church to just a have a lab and pursue whatever he feels like in cosmology instead of such a narrow "school of thought" picked by a donor?
- pdonis 6y ago> Why does the dark matter stop? The dark matter doesn't stop; it keeps going. > Don't colliding galaxies stop due to gravity Not really. As others have noted, they stop due to non-gravitational interactions between the ordinary matter (mainly gas and dust clouds).