4 ms·
The poor IT guys there probably asked for a couple thousand for backups instead and were previously denied. Ransomeware first rose to prominence three years ago
by MattGaiser 6y ago
The poor IT guys there probably asked for a couple thousand for backups instead and were previously denied. Ransomeware first rose to prominence three years ago.
Yet seemingly little has been learned?
- sliken 6y agoLarge compromises of sensitive data also have to consider the release of sensitive info, not just recovery. So even with backups there's an incentive to pay.
- MattGaiser 6y agoAh yes. NetWalker seems like a particularly bad variant as it does at least claim to steal the data.
- RNCTX 6y agoI know the university I attended has learned nothing at all. State university in a wealthy US area with over 30,000 students. They still think security is forcing everyone to change passwords once every 6 months. No offer of 2fa of any sort for any service. I stopped using my email address between transcript requests because the whole student/faculty directory is rampant with student employees of local businesses sending spam within the system. A permanent link is a complete mystery of a concept to them as well. Every time sun shines on an article in public media for them the glory is sure to be short lived, because google's link will be broken in 6 months tops.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> A permanent link is a complete mystery of a concept to them as well. Every time sun shines on an article in public media for them the glory is sure to be short lived, because google's link will be broken in 6 months tops. I am baffled that universities (and so many others) don't just use WordPress for publishing their media.
- ElCapitanMarkla 6y agoWhy would you use crappy free Wordpress when you can pay a couple hundred thousand for a vastly superior MS SharePoint setup...
- HAL9OOO 6y agoWouldn't happen to be UMD would it? I still remember when they had everything leaked in plain text...
- RNCTX 6y agoNah, mine is in Texas. But I'm sure we can probably apply the same story to hundreds of universities.
- conanbatt 6y agoHaving personally dealt with UCSF IT, I'd say that they don't deserve sympathy.
- hhs 6y agoWhat type of insurance does UCSF have for ransomware? Last year, ProPublica noted how some insurance companies like to pay ransom for their business [0]. [0]: https://www.propublica.org/article/the-extortion-economy-how-insurance-companies-are-fueling-a-rise-in-ransomware-attacks https://www.propublica.org/article/the-extortion-economy-how...
- Veserv 6y agoThat poses at most a minor roadblock. You just take over the backup-and-restore service for a little while and corrupt the backups as they get made. If anybody tries to verify the backups they just restore them correctly until they make their demand. Would probably add between $10K and $100K to the cost of attack (probably closer to $10K), so would probably be immaterial to the profitability of this attack. Therefore, even if they did it they would almost absolutely still be attacked with exactly the same consequences if they did not pay the ransom. Simple "common sense" solutions are pretty close to useless in these scenarios since they provide no meaningful impediment to halfway competent attackers. They stop children and script kiddies which is helpful in that there are a lot more of them, but essentially every actual economically-motivated attack remains viable. To provide an analogy, the fence around a military base does good work stopping people from just walking onto base, but it does not stop the enemy tanks. That does not mean the fence is useless, it stops one kind of threat, but if tanks might actually attack the base you either need to have a way to stop them or be willing to take the loss. Throwing up more fences so it takes longer for the tanks to roll over all of them is not really meaningful if losing the base is still an unacceptable loss.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoEhh, a decent backup service (https://www.tarsnap.com/ https://www.tarsnap.com/) will give you the ability to make write-only backups over time, i.e. you should be able to roll back to 6 months ago without any chance of something corrupting the backup process. Of course, it depends how much data you're backing up.
- Veserv 6y agoTo clarify I meant at the time of backup. When the data is being sucked out of the system to the backup they encrypt. All that requires is taking over the system pushing the data out to the backup for however long you want to deny backups. Obviously this requires not getting caught during that time, but the median time to discover a data breach is 279 days (~9 months) according to IBM [1] and this is actually easier to hide in many senses than a data breach since you are just messing with an existing data flow instead of trying to do the much more suspicious data exfiltration. [1] https://www.ibm.com/security/data-breach https://www.ibm.com/security/data-breach
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoHow big is their endowment? Why do people donate to universities when they squander money like this?