10 ms·
How is this going to avoid becoming like Voat? Reddit already has competitors. It is just that they are cesspools as the only people who have a strong reason t
by MattGaiser 6y ago
How is this going to avoid becoming like Voat?
Reddit already has competitors. It is just that they are cesspools as the only people who have a strong reason to leave reddit are those reddit has banned.
- phoe-krk 6y agoSee how the Fediverse works - it has largely avoided becoming like Voat. Most alt-right instances, such as Gab, are hugely defederated by instance admins and therefore isolated from most of the network.
- fxtentacle 6y agoYou speak in a language too cryptic for regular consumption ;) Which "Fediverse"? As I understand the concept, it applies to social networks in general. But it appears that you are referring to one specific network which contains the Gab server in it.
- input_sh 6y ago"Fediverse" = federated universe. Basically a bunch of smaller social networks speaking together through common protocols. Think: being able to follow a YouTube channel straight from your Twitter account — no need to create a YouTube account. The most popular of such networks is Mastodon (https://joinmastodon.org/ https://joinmastodon.org/), which everyone can run on their own server (often referred to as an "instance"). By default, you create an account on one server and just speak to everyone like if you were on the same server. If one of such servers turns out to be a cesspool full of bigots (like Gab is), an admin can simply say "my server will no longer communicate with that server". When a bunch of servers do that, Gab is pretty much isolated, even though it's using an open protocol. To put it in layman's terms: if a lot of spam comes from user@example.com, Gmail can just dismiss the emails coming from all addresses that end in @example.com. Server owners are usually transparent and keep lists of servers they're not speaking to on GitHub or somewhere.
- fxtentacle 6y agoThank you for the great explanation :)
- phoe-krk 6y agohttps://fediverse.party/ https://fediverse.party/
- young_unixer 6y agoWhich has the same problem of the community being an echo chamber, the only difference being that it's a left wing echo chamber instead of a right wing echo chamber like voat.
- raldi 6y agoThe only redditlike sites that outcompete Reddit are ones with more moderation (e.g., HN), not less.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoModeration should be similar to a database view. I would love a browser extension and backend store like Lemmy that posts to both the site I’m on but also Lemmy (each site would be a distinct “namespace”). What is a forum but a collection of post identifiers with a corresponding tree of comments. If a mod removes, hides, or takes other mod action on a comment or post, the browser extension and federated storage system still allows me to see and interact with that content and it’s writer (“showdead” globally). You could subscribe to “mod actions” (which is just curation) by mod, which would govern your experience of the content. I appreciate the mod work here, for example, but I also want to be able to bypass that “filter opinion” so I can still interact with folks and content out of band if I so choose (one person’s “flame war” is another person’s vigorous debate).
- ralusek 6y agoYes. Even just the existence of different subreddits with different moderation policies is already close to a perfect solution. I don't understand why people are so hellbent on getting subreddits that exceed their tolerances removed from the platform. There are orders of magnitude more subreddits that I ignore altogether than the ones that I choose to subscribe to.
- antepodius 6y agoBecause it isn't about protecting yourself from harm, it's about attacking people you hate.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoSpeaking only of the US legal framework, hate speech is still free speech. Ignore speech you prefer not to consume instead of supporting the curtailment of rights.
- rglullis 6y agoIt's federated, each instance would be a subreddit. Don't like a instances because it is run by a deplorable? Don't subscribe to it. Is a deplorable posting deplorable things on the instances you are subscribed to and trying to piss on your pool? Downvote/mute/ban them.
- zacharycohn 6y agoHow is that different than Reddit, except with less ability to control cross-subreddit brigading?
- MattGaiser 6y ago> Don't like a instances because it is run by a deplorable? Don't subscribe to it. How is that different from how Reddit/Voat currently are?
- rglullis 6y agoThe difference would be for the deplorable, who now has no "mah free speech" and "reddit is censoring me!!11!!" excuses to fall on and justify its deplorability. More seriously though, the important thing about ActivityPub is that it removes central points of control. No matter how much you agree/disagree with the governance of Reddit/Facebook/Twitter et caterva, they are just too big for the good of society. Federated systems is one chance to take this power from them and bring to people - if not directly (say, because you don't want the pain of hosting/managing all that crap) at least you can delegate this power to someone closer to you - or at very least to a bigger number of smaller providers who will them have no monopoly and will have to keep your interests first.
- judge2020 6y agoIf i'm a redditor that looks at r/dankmemes and r/gifs all day, or a creator for those subreddits, I don't see why I would leave reddit for a competitor. Without these people coming from reddit, it'll have the same problem as voat where nobody is looking for - or even willing to try - alternatives unless they were rejected.
- hypersoar 6y agoVoat was created intentionally and specifically for the (mostly far-right) trolls too unsavory for Reddit. So, if Lemmy is not that, it'll have a head start.
- badRNG 6y agoThis seems to be the outcome of all of these Reddit clones, even the ones made with the best of intentions. Take for instance Ruqqus, another site created as a free speech reddit alternative. It consistently has horrifying content on the front page regularly; viciously racist content, anti-Semitic memes, unironic pro-Nazism/pro-genocide discussion posts, and generally terrible content. This is likely because it is exactly this content that is being "censored" from Reddit, not these harmless free speech advocates who are silenced by a big company. Can anyone actually tell me what valuable discussion is being censored on Twitter, Reddit, etc? Banning this type of content is mandatory if you want a platform that is safe and available for trans people, Jews, gay people, women, etc. People shouldn't have to tolerate people @ing them with slurs, be exposed to "reasoned" arguments for their extermination, or memes dehumanizing them for the sake of "free speech."
- detaro 6y agoWhy do you assume that all alternatives have to be "free speech = allowing abuse" alternatives? E.g. a large subset of Fediverse (Mastodon etc) communities are communities that avoid Twitter because they don't feel Twitter is doing enough to be safe for them. And instances have a varying policies about how they handle instances with different moderation standards.
- kiba 6y agoAll good alternatives will have rule, thus moderation. Where does the line between "free speech" and moderation exists?
- xupybd 6y agoThe problem is access to platforms. We haven't found a good way to do this. People should be free to opt in or out of the content they want. What offends one will not offend another. For example a thread on hunting will offend some who love the animals they hunt. There is no universal right or wrong there. On should have access to an online community the other should have the ability to disagree or avoid that community. The problem is when an organisation like Twitter picks a side that free speech becomes an issue. Only because of the monopolistic nature of the platform. But that's what makes the platform good, everyone is there.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- detaro 6y agoVoat explicitly branded itself like that. In comparison, a large source of Fediverse users (Mastodon etc) are people that leave Twitter because they think it isn't moderated well enough.
- jchw 6y agoIt’s true that “thing but not” sites tend to have issues with getting the unwanted population of the original “thing” website. And of course, some of that “unwanted” population is actually not necessarily bad, but a lot of it certainly is. I think the main way you can combat this is by disincentivizing users to bring their unwanted behaviors to the new site while incentivizing existing users to check it out. Obviously network effects dominate, but that hasn’t stopped there from being small niches where Mastodon instances and Matrix chats are good and healthy. OTOH, the point of sites like Voat and Gab were to support users who were not welcome on Reddit and Twitter, and therefore it quickly became a problem. But I don’t like the notion that you can’t directly compete with established sites - I feel like back in the day this is Exactly what happened with news aggregators. Digg and Reddit were once fairly similar sites; although Digg always had a nicer interface, they served an extremely similar purpose at the end of the day, and yet it was possible for them to compete. I think it’s harder now, but probably still doable if you can be novel enough, or if the big site becomes too annoying (Reddit seems to really be trying at this, to be honest; just try using their website on a mobile browser!)
- holidaygoose 6y agoCan we try to figure out sociologically, why by default unmoderated social forums become far-right oriented? Is it because: - People on the far-right are magnitudes more vocal and active online than those on the left? That they spend a magnitude more time posting and voting on the internet? - Or when people are anonymous, they reveal their "true selves" more which exhibits more far-right (selfish, tribal, conservative) values. - Or we are underestimating how many people are on the far right, because they are constantly censored so in our minds we think they are the minority but maybe they're about half of the online population? I'm just trying to figure out why it takes herculean effort to shift things enough to the left to be publicly palatable. And if so, then then it seems like any social forum is going to require heavy censorship/moderation to even be tolerable to the general public.
- osmarks 6y agoI'd expect that it's because if you have some new forum without (as many) restrictions, you get both: - people who disagree with the restrictions of other places on principle and want a freer alternative - people who can't say what they want to anywhere else, because it's generally disliked and most people probably do not want to read stuff from the second group.
- MattGaiser 6y agoEveryone else has no strong reason to leave the existing platform.
- agensaequivocum 6y agoThere are quite a few people on the left in the gun community who do.
- jka 6y agoMy guess would be that attention-seeking and disruptive behaviours are part of the explanation. In a forum with ten reasonable conversation threads and one highly controversial one, attention is likely to move towards the controversial topic. The phrase "don't feed the trolls" is well-intentioned but it's difficult to scale the message when so many people are online and can witness and partake in minor and major conversations alike. It also doesn't help that engagement (regardless of reason for engagement and any human stress created as a result; they're harder for software and metrics to capture) tends to be seen as something to optimize for, both within companies themselves and also by their investors. Controversial conversations are sometimes necessary. People who repeatedly raise controversial topics to gain notoriety or attention are generally not - although their behaviour may be a sign that they need help in other ways.
- as1mov 6y agoIt's a weird issue honestly. I've been on reddit for almost a decade, and I don't like what it has become. I would love to switch to a better alternative, but the problem is any alternative that pops up seems to be filled with extremists as soon as it starts. This doesn't imply that anyone who wants to leave reddit is a neo-nazi, a lot of us are stuck with reddit because everything else is filled with shit.
- foolfoolz 6y agothere’s extremists on every platform
- MattGaiser 6y agoThere is poo on every surface. The key question is the amount of poo relative to the other stuff.
- edw 6y agoHere’s another question: Would any of our lives be any worse — or would they be better? — if we simply chose to walk away and not be a part of any of these platforms, HN included? How much of our lives is made up of karma whoring, level grinding, and falling into the <https://xkcd.com/386/> https://xkcd.com/386/> trap?
- beervirus 6y agoI learn stuff on HN every time I visit. Reddit is (somewhat) entertaining, but I don’t usually learn anything important there.
- the_af 6y agoDoesn't this depend on the subreddit? Some are "chatty" or full of memes, but others are very informative for some niches. If you want a subreddit for enthusiasts of $NICHE, you're likely to find it, and it's likely to be useful.
- djsumdog 6y agoVoat attempted several design choices to make it solve certain complaints about Reddit, and most of those choices ended up being terrible ideas: https://battlepenguin.com/tech/voat-what-went-wrong/ https://battlepenguin.com/tech/voat-what-went-wrong/ I think the right answer is federation. Having a lot of instances moderated by different people gives people a lot more freedom of choice.
- zackees 6y agoReddit is infiltrated with corporate sock puppet accounts. A documentary has been made about it. Any reddit that supports Trump and becomes popular get's dismantled. A good example is the the_donald, who's moderators were kicked out and the community had to leave.
- philipkglass 6y agoMost of the arguments about social media content policies center around American politics, but Reddit has been banning other potential lightning rods for controversy. They banned DarkNetMarkets, Deepfakes, and SanctionedSuicide in 2018. They banned WatchPeopleDie last year [1]. It's not hard to see why Reddit would ban any of these, but at some point there may be a critical mass of too-controversial-for-Reddit content that isn't just interesting to the Voat crowd. Is that point now? I'll have to wait and see how Lemmy turns out. The other theoretical advantage of a federated service is that smaller instances are less expensive to run than one big centralized service. There are a lot of people who could afford to run a service on a $10/month VPS as a hobby but who couldn't afford to run anything at actual Reddit scale without corresponding revenue. That's important considering that Reddit leavers are more likely to be posting not-safe-for-brand content even if it's not specifically hateful content. [1] Not a sub I ever visited, but by most accounts surprisingly non-toxic as a community, considering the subject matter.
- tenebrisalietum 6y agor/watchpeopledie if anything made you take safety very seriously. Much of the content was work-related and car-related accidents.
- goatsi 6y ago/r/DarkNetMarkets was banned because of the FOSTA-SESTA anti-sex "trafficking" bill. The government forced Reddit's hand on that. https://medium.com/@pylorns/the-reddit-spring-the-great-libation-migration-b181a09f9292 https://medium.com/@pylorns/the-reddit-spring-the-great-liba...
- dbbljack 6y agoezpz dont federate with racists
- aqme28 6y agoHilarious to make that comment on HackerNews. This site is undeniably a reddit competitor, but it doesn't feel like a cesspool to me.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoAs someone that has probed this community on different basic morality subjects for years and gotten downvoted to the lowest possible score (-4), I can reliably say that there's a portion of the user base that hold beliefs and perspectives that are not making the world a better place and sometimes make this feel like a cesspool. Sometimes the lack of exposure to real-world problems creates people that are completely disconnected from reality.
- colordrops 6y agoThe reason Voat is so bad is because it's the only alternative so the extremists are all shunted there. If a federated group of many forums was available with different moderation policies, then there would be breathing room for non-extremists.
- bluedino 6y agoThere a situation going on at SomethingAwful where if ownership isn’t transferred, a vocal group of users is going to leave. Some of them have suggested BreadnRoses.net, which advertises supporting an open community and being inviting to all. However, it’s too far to the left and focused on solidarity to take all of SA’s threads and even forums. You have such a mix over there, everything from tech to politics, guns, drugs... a lot like reddit.
- intothemild 6y agoLooks like ownership will be transferred.. but we're talking about Lowtax here.. he's rather unpredictable
- TulliusCicero 6y ago> Some of them have suggested BreadnRoses.net, which advertises supporting an open community and being inviting to all. It does? > B+R is a community-owned space that seeks to foster solidarity between people from all backgrounds that share a common character. We reject policies of social dominance, Neo-liberalism, patriarchy, the gender binary, white supremacy, and other social ills espoused by capitalism. We support worker/union/trans rights, empowering those without a voice, and each other. > Do not advocate for obvious bad shit like landlords/cops/capitalism/etc. This is a leftist space. Sounds like they're quite explicit about what things they're non-open/inviting about. Their attitude sounds like D&D/C-SPAM turned up to 11. Even as a Bernie-loving social democrat, I'd have to say 'pass'.
- heavyset_go 6y agoThere are a few Reddit-alikes that aren't cesspools. They have guidelines for contributions and a moderation policy for people who don't meet them.
- shahsyed 6y agoThat's a pretty general statement, one that I would avoid without proof or evidence.
- glenstein 6y ago>How is this going to avoid becoming like Voat? It has a number of things going for it. First, it's on activitypub, and will have the same kind of granular federating controls as mastodon, at least at the instance level. And as another commenter mentioned about initial culture, the politics/cultural tilt of the devs are unapologetically anti-righ wing troll, which is a great start, and a lot of the stuff people post about is linux/open source/libre/fediverse stuff, which is a focused interest that doesn't fall back to the lowest common denominator of trolling. I think it's off to a good start, it's starting with a good culture that's explicitly conscious of the trolling problem, and it shares a lot of the spirit and mission of the other fediverse projects which are driven by conscious concern in mitigating these issues.
- austincheney 6y agoI left Reddit. I got tired of the echo chamber nonsense and deleted my account.
- reedwolf 6y agoSo when was the last time you were on Reddit?
- austincheney 6y agoI think January 2018, but am not certain. It could be 2017.
- Thorentis 6y agoTrue, but just don't fall into the trap of thinking Reddit is a centrist, unbiased platform that only bans those that upset the equilibrium. Reddit is partisan, applies bans selectively, and permits astroturfing when it agrees with the cause.
- luckylion 6y ago> How is this going to avoid becoming like Voat? Like as in "used by right-wing people who got kicked out of Reddit"? Probably by heavy moderation, the Lemmy developers are left to far-left as far as I can see form a glance. Like as in "used to create an echo chamber for ideologically aligned people to talk to each other"? That may well be the goal.