2 ms·
Audit can only spot certain types of problems. But the trouble with the Big Four is that their record on spotting those problems is terrible. If they made break
by tialaramex 6y ago
Audit can only spot certain types of problems. But the trouble with the Big Four is that their record on spotting those problems is terrible. If they made breakfast cereal you'd be reading a story every week about severed fingers found in a kid's breakfast or somehow a factory making choco-puffs exploded killing a thousand people.
Of course the reason is that being terrible at their jobs is profitable, whereas factory explosions generally cost the manufacturer money even if they aren't held liable for killing all those people.
I think company audit needs a regime like the Paris MOU port state inspection regime. Government employed auditors would re-audit a sample of companies proportional to a current estimate of how bad their existing auditor is at finding problems. This would inform subsequent rounds of re-auditing, while also detecting non-compliances at companies whose auditor is bad in the process. I'm confident that such a scheme could effectively pay for itself in reduced economic damage from surprise corporate failures and improved tax revenue as re-audits find money that was "accidentally" not revealed in the official audit.
The Paris MOU scheme drastically improved safety, not just because now governments that cared were doing inspections but because governments that don't directly care were incentivised to hire competent inspectors. "Let's just do a bad job and keep the money" ceased to make sense and scarcely any countries offer that now.
(The US is currently greylisted in the Paris MOU by a narrow margin, under a different executive I assume there'd be focus on improving US oversight to get back onto the white list but today who knows, maybe the Marines will be instructed to attack Zeebrugge to "free" American cargo ships or something)