3 ms·
If you read and want to refute the article, how do you counter the accusation that most of these loans are used for daily necessities and not for starting a bus
by smt88 6y ago
If you read and want to refute the article, how do you counter the accusation that most of these loans are used for daily necessities and not for starting a business?
Why would a desperately poor person use a loan to start a business when they can't get enough for their children to eat?
Just in theory, a loan is only useful for someone who is already stable enough to think about long-term investments like starting a business. It doesn't help the hundreds of millions of people who don't have daily necessities.
> Looking at interest rates in isolation is meaningless.
Untrue. No one claiming to benefit the poor should ever charge, for example, 50% interest.
You might argue that the risk profile of these loans demands 75% interest, and 50% is a big discount by a nonprofit. That may be true, but it's still unbearable for people struggling to buy food and it still highlights the fact that loans are not a solution to systemic poverty in mismanaged countries.
> Capital is what turns poor people into middle class people.
Citation needed. Is capital fixing the poverty, or is capital arriving because something else has already started fixing the poverty?
The US and India have waged wars on poverty with success. These may have been boosted by capital, but they were not initiated or driven by it. As in all cases where poverty is alleviated, they were driven by grants and social programs.
In fact, the political interests of the holders of capital have reversed some of this progress.
- ip26 6y agoEven if capital isn't starting a business, simple things like a grant or loan to replace your thatch roof with a more expensive metal roof can reduce the amount of time & energy spent on daily survival and free up time & energy to invest in yourself. Thatch roofs are cheap but require ongoing maintenance and harbor pests and fungi. It's the basically the African version of the boots theory of socioeconomic unfairness.
- neximo64 6y agoYou got to live in a poor country to understand the simple difference. These trivial sums are able to buy more capital goods than in a developed country. A wheelbarrow is ~$2 vs ~$150. Microfinance is a game changer & its very visibly so. Comments like yours are just so obviously from a developed country/western viewpoint because they basically assume the cost of life/goods/services is the same between the local market you live in vs the developing country with microfinance. The basic refutation can come from a PPP basket of goods that goes even more basic to things people use every day. Flour, Chicken, i.e not a Big Mac index & not an equivalent goods-for goods comparison of the basket. There is no McDonalds in Nigeria fyi - the items of consumption are different too. The most expensive item in someone living in a developing country is typically phone airtime & never rent/mortgage which is probably your biggest outgoing in the developed world.
- smt88 6y agoYou seem to be arguing against a point I didn't make. I never said anything about the absolute dollar value or buying power of the loans. Regardless of the amount of the loans, most are being used for daily necessities. Feeding your kids with a 30+% loan cannot alleviate poverty. Knowingly making such loans is predatory.
- neximo64 6y agoActually you did make the point, which is why I alluded to it being an assumption of your point of view. The entire notion of your argument breaks down because of it. If I was to translate it backward to something an exact equivalent - you get a $250k loan for your business/startup in SF but you spend it on feeding yourself/kids and paying rent because you absolutely have to do those things and you're struggling to pay your bills/rent & SF is damn expensive. You don't exactly do that though with your 250k loan/predatory startup bond, though. You're basically saying, albeit in a different frame of reference, the entity giving you the 250k loan is predatory because you are incentivised to pay your rent and you might be struggling to do so. The assumption, once again, is the relative purchasing powers are different in the developing world vs your frame of reference.
- em-bee 6y agonow that i have read both of your arguments, i still do not understand what is right. are loans used for food? how does one pay back a loan with a high interest rate? maybe some concrete examples of how those loans work would help. i have seen reports on the positive effects of microloans, so i am inclined to believe that they work, but i still do not understand how.
- rayiner 6y ago> you counter the accusation that most of these loans are used for daily necessities and not for starting a business? The article cites “consumption loans” which are often for things like water sanitation or home repairs. > It doesn't help the hundreds of millions of people who don't have daily necessities. Being able to buy capital equipment can dramatically improve food production. > No one claiming to benefit the poor should ever charge, for example, 50% interest. Why? > Citation needed. See Bangladesh, India, South Korea, etc. > Is capital fixing the poverty, or is capital arriving because something else has already started fixing the poverty? Capital arrives because a country fixes certain basic rule of law, education, etc., issues. But foreign aid can’t lift a country from poverty into middle income status. > The US and India have waged wars on poverty with success. False. https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2016/12/29/14112084/war-on-poverty-brooklyn-great-society https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2016/12/29/14112084/... https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/the-war-on-poverty-what-went-wrong/ https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/the-war-on-poverty-what-w... There is a very timely comparison to the situation in the US with the black-white income gap. It is the same today as back in the 1960s when the country was still legally segregated. Decades of government education programs, etc., haven’t had any effect on the gap at all. It obviously can alleviate suffering in the near term. But only the infusion of capital can actually change their financial condition meaningfully. The same thing is true for Bangladesh. Don’t get me wrong: foreign assistance has been a boon in terms of helping reduce mortality rates and malnutrition, increasing education, etc. But that, by itself, can’t reduce poverty. Educated labor is useless if there is no capital. Bangladesh has received foreign aid for decades. But in the last 20 years, it has liberalized its economy and started receiving significant foreign capital. It has added $225 billion to its GDP since 2000. Foreign assistance could never accomplish that, because no country is going to be sending $225 billion to Bangladesh each year. You need to increase the production capacity of the local economy, and foreign investment of capital does that.
- sukilot 6y agoIt's ridiculous to equate poverty in the US with poverty in Africa. Nigeria GDP per capita is under $2500/yr.
- rahimnathwani 6y ago"Just in theory, a loan is only useful for someone who is already stable enough to think about long-term investments like starting a business." It may seem obvious that someone who we consider to be poor, and to have unstable circumstances, has no use for a loan. I suggest you read 'Portfolios of the Poor'[0]. The book is based on financial diaries kept by people in precarious situations in poor countries. These diaries chronicle a surprising array of financial instruments used by people whose personal balance sheets are smaller than many HN readers' weekly snack budgets. [0] http://www.portfoliosofthepoor.com/ http://www.portfoliosofthepoor.com/