4 ms·
> according to standard economics, and all economists from right to left agree on this: money is the measure of value to society. Only for a very strict defini
by pessimizer 6y ago
> according to standard economics, and all economists from right to left agree on this: money is the measure of value to society.
Only for a very strict definition of "value to society" that is a tautological summing of individual relative desire that is measured in dollars. Luckily, we're not restricted to defining value that way when speaking generally.
edit: coincidentally, I was recently reading an article by an ex-scientologist reflecting on the complicated process of indoctrination that keeps them in the church. A large part of it seems to be redefining common words (usually making them more specific, but sometimes intentionally creating definitions of words which explicitly denigrate their common meanings) and justifying this as a technical language (or I guess in Scientology, the "words" of a "tech"?) Next, they teach that deviation from those definitions is the source of all error, and that all doubt can be cured by going between the sentence that has caused you to doubt and the official definitions of the words in that sentence, back and forth, until you understand that the sentence is correct, and that LRH is always correct.
Doing that for long enough could probably convince one that somebody buying horrible stepped on street heroin to keep from being sick is valuable to society. Isn't not being sick nice?
- WalterBright 6y ago> horrible stepped on street heroin Is a consequence of heroin being illegal, thus people who buy bad heroin have no recourse in the courts. Free markets rely on a court system.
- sukilot 6y agoPeople buy horrible prescription opiates generally with no recourse to the legal system, and that's legal.
- WalterBright 6y agoIt's not adulterated drugs. There have been no allegations that the opiates were not the chemicals they were advertised as being.
- sukilot 6y agoThey were falsely advertised as non-addictive, and they were prescribed by bribed doctors violating their fiduciary duty to their patients.
- WalterBright 6y agoThe false advertising and bribery is illegal, and they are being pursued by the court system both criminally and civilly.
- sukilot 6y agoThis process is documented at length in the book 1984, including a special appendix dedicated specifically to what the author termed "Newspeak" and "doublethink", or "doublespeak". https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak
- fsckboy 6y ago"when I said "money is the measure of value to society" I accompanied it with a quotation that mentioned both "money" and "value to society" and I did so to make the point that OP was failing to make a point. if you'd like to defend the original quote, go ahead, I'll bite on that, but here you've just changed the context to no profit. > Only for a very strict definiton of "value to society" well, as I was looking for a strict definition of money, great!