3 ms·
This growing societal condemnation for every sin (past, present, or associated) may be called "virtue signaling" or "cancel culture" these days, but it already
by kirse 6y ago
This growing societal condemnation for every sin (past, present, or associated) may be called "virtue signaling" or "cancel culture" these days, but it already had a personified name thousands of years ago - self-righteous Pharisee-ism - and it's ultimately what put Jesus on the cross. Say what you want about the resurrection, he at least lived an innocent life but was beaten and hung for execution by the shame-filled rage of the masses.
Ironically we live in a society that now claims more than ever to know what it means to "do right", but that growing moral burden of "doing right" produces an ever greater internal sense of shame (for missing the mark) that is often projected outwards onto easy targets. Outrage is what wins eyeballs in the media, because messages of shame penetrate to the core. Thanks to social media, these messages clone themselves far more easily. Acts of injustice stir up outrage via a message of shame, and the cycle often perpetuates itself with further acts of outrage/injustice.
America has a growing self-righteousness induced shame problem is what this is, and until we identify that source of grace [1] that can transform sin into honor, shame into dignity, and moral outrage into forgiveness, it will only continue to worsen. Yes, we are to have deep sorrow and compassion regarding acts of injustice, but grace and forgiveness are the only legitimate exits from the emotional/spiritual burdens they impose.
[1] Romans 8:1-2
- thu2111 6y agoThanks for posting this. Very insightful. I've come to believe lately that this sort of thing is caused, to some extent, by the decline of Christianity in the west. I'm not religious myself and used to consider that a virtue (rational man yadda yadda). These days I'm much less sure it's such a good idea. It appears that with the decline of the Church all that's happened is people invented a new one, but a rather nasty one that sounds a lot like the religions of a couple thousand years ago: obsessed with converting heretics whether they want to be converted or not, a whole lot of destruction of pagan idols, making people into martyrs and so on. On balance, given a choice between the kind of hate filled behaviour the article describes, or God-fearing people, I'd much rather be around the latter. And if forced to choose a tribe I guess I'd pick them too, as the modern religious seem much nicer, calmer and more accepting than the "woke".