5 ms·
Apple is a hardware company, they don't earn a cent knowing who you are. This is why they can lean hard on the privacy aspect, Google (an ad company) can never
by theshrike79 6y ago
Apple is a hardware company, they don't earn a cent knowing who you are.
This is why they can lean hard on the privacy aspect, Google (an ad company) can never follow them there all the way.
- russdpale 6y agoBut the app store allows that apps that collect all sorts of data on you, and doesn't apple get a cut of the sales from apps? Just because its a few steps transient doesn't mean apple has clean hands here.
- miskin 6y agoTrue, but arguably they are making spying harder with each ios release. If profiling and ads were their bread and butter, they would act differently.
- retpirato 6y agoIt may not be their "bread and butter", but that doesn't mean they don't do it. Every time I see somebody talking about Google spying on users but 'X' company doesn't do it, I start to think there just a fanboy to Apple or whatever the company in question is. You should just assume EVERYBODY is spying. Just because it isn't their primary source of revenue, doesn't mean it isn't a source of revenue at all or isn't of value to them.
- theshrike79 6y agoThere are levels of "spying". There is "enable microphone, listen in on conversations and adjust ad preferences" and "upload all photos in the background for analysis" and "check the clipboard for interesting stuff every few seconds" Then there is just normal telemetry, anonymised and used for internal product development.
- ricardobeat 6y agoSince around 2016 Apple does not expose a stable unique identifier to apps. Users can reset their identifier at any time, opt out of location-based and personalized ads. Apps submitted to the store must follow those guidelines. There is a lot wrong about their policies but you have to give it to them for respecting privacy: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT205223 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT205223
- nojito 6y agoOnly if you let them. Apple forces developers to ask the user for permission constantly.
- colordrops 6y ago> they don't earn a cent knowing who you are. This is absolutely not true. It's just not their main revenue stream. That doesn't mean they don't collect and monetize your data in one way or another.
- ricardobeat 6y agoWhat would that revenue stream be?
- dodobirdlord 6y agoTheir own marketing and product teams surely use this data.
- pests 6y agoSo companies can't even look at their own data now? I'm pretty sure most people are okay with that.
- serf 6y ago> So companies can't even look at their own data now? I'm pretty sure most people are okay with that. people start caring when those companies own half the world. Apple owns tons of media groups. I don't want to participate in a pseudo market-testing-group just by virtue of owning an iPhone. We're not talking about data and analytics being collected on phones for phones, we're talking about data and analytics being collected on phones and then sat on for a future project, likely not phone related. I'm a people, and i'm not okay with that.
- pests 6y agoI understand the argument, my issue was with people conflating three things: 1. Collecting data for internal use 2. Collecting data to sell targeted ads with. 3. Collecting data to directly sell to other parties. My problem with your suggestion to limit internal data analysis (option 1) is where is the line drawn? Can "Netflix Streaming Department" share data with "Netflix Original Programming" in your idea? Isn't that the whole point tho?
- haltingproblem 6y agoThis is replete with multiple levels of irony. Google pays apple billions to make Google the default search engine. Apple does not sell ads directly but they profit mightily from sale on those ads. When the mafia breaking your legs is owned by your adversary or rented by them is a fig leaf of a distinction.
- nojito 6y agoWhat ads? Apple has been cutting out Google Search with every single iOS update.
- haltingproblem 6y agoGoogle is paying Apple $9b~ a year. https://www.pymnts.com/apple/2019/google-safari-search-engine-deal/ https://www.pymnts.com/apple/2019/google-safari-search-engin...