5 ms·
I think that one doesn't fit with these examples because it wasn't a misinterpretation. There are the two separate questions of: * Was person X bigoted? * Was
by renewiltord 6y ago
I think that one doesn't fit with these examples because it wasn't a misinterpretation. There are the two separate questions of:
* Was person X bigoted?
* Was the 'punishment' befitting what they did?
Well, donating against gay marriage is some big-government bigoted shit, not gonna lie. You can still ask the second question, though.
- TAForObvReasons 6y agoThe punishment befits the situation. There's a profound difference between a normal worker supporting anti-gay-marriage causes with a donation and the CEO doing the same thing, since the CEO is near the top of the org chart and a large number of employees are under his org tree. The CEO's views reflect poorly on the organization and hiring practices to a more significant extent than any normal non-management worker
- ameen 6y agoI don't think any CEO (bigoted or not) can retaliate against their employees for their sexual orientation - it's illegal. While it reflects poorly on him, it seems to be the norm in the U.S. to donate to lobbies.
- scarface74 6y agoIt wasn’t illegal in all states until the recent Supreme Court decision. I wouldn’t want someone in a position of power that went to Klan rallies on the weekend either. They aren’t going to outright say they are discriminating against you. They are going to say the person isn’t a “culture fit”.
- zebnyc 6y agoYou are equating making a donation to a political cause (which was a mainstream opinion at that time) to the Klan. A bit extreme don't you think?
- scarface74 6y agoWhat’s the difference? In both cases someone wants to take away rights from someone else because of their own belief system.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoWhen the donation was made when a super majority of United Statians opposed allowing same gender marriage. That said I've come to agree that leadership should be held to a higher standard. And IIRC Eich did not, and still has not, publicly expressed support for such marriages.
- Ymous 6y agoI'm thinking about this and am wondering, does this mean that in an ideal scenario (where CEOs of every company maximally considers the larger impact of their personal actions reflecting upon the company they're helming), they must all support the same things? I can imagine two CEO's of companies A and B (which each own exactly 50% of an industry and are precisely equivalent in public visibility and internal policy). The CEOs are also identical in every way except that one supports a opinion M and the other supports a opinion M' Assuming that they both make public their support, which one would get executed in the court of public opinion? Would it be fair for (any)one of them to get expelled from his/her post just because the masses collapsed the narrative to uphold either only M or M'? (I'm assuming that whether M or M' is the majority opinion is irrelevant) The only solution I can see is that both CEOs collude and decide to either not support anything, or support the same, agreed-upon thing. Assuming that is so, what if we extend this past 2 companies, and into 2000? ---- I'm not convinced that the punishment does befit the situation.
- TAForObvReasons 6y agoThe leadership is expected to reflect and uphold company values, which may differ from company to company. Incidentally, we have a perfect case study with CFA and its COO (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chick-fil-A_and_LGBT_people https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chick-fil-A_and_LGBT_people refresher) CFA's entire organization is built around family values and good Christian values. It starts from the ground level -- you can't become a manager without the company checking your friends and family. So that type of sentiment pervades the organization. The comments and donations were mostly in line with company culture. This isn't to say every CFA employee was anti-gay-marriage, but they value family enough that it is plausible that the employees would support the COO. Mozilla is the opposite situation, emphasizing diversity and trying to cater to the (generally more socially liberal) tech community at large. Eich's donations flew in the face not only of the values Mozilla were trying to espouse, but also directly affecting a nontrivial number of its employees. If Mozilla had the culture of CFA, Eich wouldn't have been removed. In order to uphold their image, Mozilla couldn't have kept him.
- hpcjoe 6y agoThat there was 'punishment' for expressing an opinion that is not aligned with a particular world view, by donating money to support something that was in the majority world view less than a decade before ... should be terrifying. To everyone. That someone supports the concept of "punishment" for expressing a view different from what you (and some collection of people) arbitrarily believe should be a widely held view ... is ... unconscionable. And quite frightening. There's literally a science fiction short story about this. And it doesn't end well. I have to look up the title, haven't read it in 35 years or so.
- renewiltord 6y agoThe 'punishment' involved people saying they don't want to: a. work for you b. use your products unless the guy goes. That's a free action by free individuals. And the idea that we would force individuals to work for people they don't like or that we'd force individuals to use products from people they don't like is authoritarian. Freedom to choose to work with someone also involves the freedom to choose to not work. Freedom of speech gives you the ability to say you like things and also say you don't like things.
- Animats 6y ago"Eich donated $1,000 in 2008 in support of California’s Proposition 8, which banned gay marriage in the state until it was struck down by the Supreme Court in June." So he supported a ballot proposition which won. That was a majority political position.
- renewiltord 6y agoThat's right. A majority political position that was bigoted. It's pretty common for a plurality to be bigoted.
- harryh 6y agoThat was a majority political position. Majority political positions can still be morally wrong.
- username90 6y agoShould we fire a majority of people?
- marcinzm 6y agoThat's a straw man argument. He represented a company that claimed to be progressive which isn't what the majority of people do.
- hpcjoe 6y agoI've worked at a company where every single meeting I had with a certain set of engineers started and rapidly devolved into a political narrative of how bad certain groups where. I smiled and ignored them. I subconsciously made sure to avoid their input on important things. The narrative was in-your-face progressive activist SJW to the max. Many people I privately spoke with in the company were sick of this idiocy, but couldn't see themselves speaking up, as they needed the job. They couldn't risk being fired by the company. Imagine if you had to live that life. Companies should not have political opinions or leanings.
- analyte123 6y agoThe year that Brendan Eich donated for the proposition against gay marriage (6 years before he was fired), 52% of Californian voters and the president (Barack Obama) agreed with him. This is why anonymous voting is important, so that it is harder to retroactively punish the other 7 million people that supported the proposition, many of whom have probably changed their mind since then. Also, "big-government bigoted shit" would have to describe literally every government in human history before the year 2001 when the Netherlands formally recognized same-sex marriage as equivalent to opposite-sex marriage.
- renewiltord 6y agoThat's right. And the Chinese Exclusion Act was generally popular too. Also big-government bigoted shit. That's the funny thing about bigotry. It doesn't matter how big your posse is. You can still be bigoted. For instance, oppression of the Uighur community is generally tolerated in China. The support is greater than the 52%. Still bigotry.
- saagarjha 6y agoYes, that is something you could always do. But are you going to hold it against every single individual Chinese who supports such oppression? How about ever Chinese who “supports” such oppression? The environment you’re in has a huge effect on the views you have; should you be allowed to rethink those?
- renewiltord 6y agoI think it would be fair to hold it against anyone who believes it's acceptable. I'm pretty forgiving of those under a regime merely trying to survive, but if then they voluntarily gave 1000 RMB to a "Let's keep the Uighurs Oppressed" charity which tries to convince the Politburo that more attacks are better than fewer attacks, I think I'm going to judge them for using the instrument of the state as a weapon against people, yeah. And because my society is free, I get to judge. And because my society is free, I get to speak my mind. And because my society is free, I get to say, "I won't use this product". And because my society is free, you get to say, "Oh okay, I'll do what you want" or you can say "Fine, don't use the product". We're just people interacting freely. And thank god for liberty.
- apta 6y ago> Well, donating against gay marriage is some big-government bigoted shit, So freedom of speech/expression isn't when it doesn't align with group think, got it.