4 ms·
But enviromental effects billions of years ago could have be by any cause. They might indicate something, but much more solid would be real artifacts. Structure
by hutzlibu 6y ago
But enviromental effects billions of years ago could have be by any cause. They might indicate something, but much more solid would be real artifacts. Structures. Chemical compounds, etc.
But yes, the question is, what trace would our civilisation leave, if abandoned today, in a billion years, if the tectonic plates move in those timescales?
- ganzuul 6y agoMoon landers.
- noir_lord 6y agoPossibly objects in an L4/L5 lagrange point as well. Though I couldn't find an answer on whether those are stable on geological time scales, Earths only Trojan has been there for thousands of years but that isn't 60 million either.
- TomMarius 6y agoIf they got to the Moon, surely they left some space junk?
- ganzuul 6y agoWe should go take a look.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoIn a micrometeorite environment, they'll last a million years at most. All that will be left after a million years is a curious and anomalous concentration of metallic particles. After a billion years it will be buried and very easy to miss.
- hutzlibu 6y agoAnd probably hard to distinguish from a old meteor with the right metal combination.
- simonh 6y agoThat's true, but we are actually reasonably good at identifying those causes, as the examples in the article show. For example the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum was also caused by a huge release of stored carbon, but over a 50,000 year period the per-year rate of release was tiny compared to our rate of output over the last few centuries. It is also associated with evidence of volcanism and geological uplift. Other causes would also leave other traces. Nobody is saying that carbon release by itself just as a single undifferentiated data point proves anything. Of course there can be other explanations, those possible explanations are discussed in the paper. These criticisms are clearly well known to the authors, addressed in the paper and contextualised by the evidence. But it's only one dimension of evidence, and I don't think dismissing it is so easy or useful.