4 ms·
I don’t think you can dismiss the problem of plate tectonics so easily. Vast amounts of the former surface of the earth are now several kilometres under our fee
by simonh 6y ago
I don’t think you can dismiss the problem of plate tectonics so easily. Vast amounts of the former surface of the earth are now several kilometres under our feet. That’s not something you can wave away.
Also it’s not reasonable to compare species fossil hunting with artefact hunting as equivalent. T-Rex as a species existed for 18 million years, with total cumulative population numbers estimated in the trillions or thousands of trillions across huge geographic areas and time spans. We have fossil fragments for only 50 individuals. That’s a staggeringly minuscule sample for a species spread out over a considerable span in both time and space.
An ancient civilisation might have existed for only a few thousand years, less than the blink of a geological eye. Unless you were to look at exactly the right strata at exactly the right layer you’d miss them completely. As a result it makes much more sense to look at environmental level effects, massively expanding the scope of your available evidence.
- hutzlibu 6y agoBut enviromental effects billions of years ago could have be by any cause. They might indicate something, but much more solid would be real artifacts. Structures. Chemical compounds, etc. But yes, the question is, what trace would our civilisation leave, if abandoned today, in a billion years, if the tectonic plates move in those timescales?
- ganzuul 6y agoMoon landers.
- noir_lord 6y agoPossibly objects in an L4/L5 lagrange point as well. Though I couldn't find an answer on whether those are stable on geological time scales, Earths only Trojan has been there for thousands of years but that isn't 60 million either.
- TomMarius 6y agoIf they got to the Moon, surely they left some space junk?
- ganzuul 6y agoWe should go take a look.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoIn a micrometeorite environment, they'll last a million years at most. All that will be left after a million years is a curious and anomalous concentration of metallic particles. After a billion years it will be buried and very easy to miss.
- hutzlibu 6y agoAnd probably hard to distinguish from a old meteor with the right metal combination.
- simonh 6y agoThat's true, but we are actually reasonably good at identifying those causes, as the examples in the article show. For example the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum was also caused by a huge release of stored carbon, but over a 50,000 year period the per-year rate of release was tiny compared to our rate of output over the last few centuries. It is also associated with evidence of volcanism and geological uplift. Other causes would also leave other traces. Nobody is saying that carbon release by itself just as a single undifferentiated data point proves anything. Of course there can be other explanations, those possible explanations are discussed in the paper. These criticisms are clearly well known to the authors, addressed in the paper and contextualised by the evidence. But it's only one dimension of evidence, and I don't think dismissing it is so easy or useful.
- SiVal 6y agoYou're not likely to have much evidence to show of a civilization a billion years ago if all you have is excess carbon dioxide that might be due to any number of natural phenomena: forest fires due to overgrowth followed by drought, asteroid strikes thawing the tundra or whatever. Good luck claiming ancient civilizations if all you have is "a lot of organic material returned the CO2 to the atmosphere" but with no artifacts or anything else to show. Now, I'm just using a billion years as a huge stretch to make it harder to find the artifacts I'm talking about. Anything within a 100M would be leaving fossils of all sorts of junk. A fossilized piece of an obviously artificial concrete building or bridge would be solid evidence and clearly Plan A compared to arguments about the cause of ancient CO2 fluctuations if you are purely interested in evidence of ancient civ.
- notahacker 6y agoCarcasses of tyrannosaurs were small, biodegradeable and tasty though, so their preservation was the rare exception rather than the rule. It would be rather harder to miss evidence of industrial cities of tens of millions of people spread across entire continents, many of which have not been subsumed by plates. Most of the skeletons of the ancient Egyptians aren't found, but their pyramids are very much in evidence, and this was a civilization far too small and unsophisticated to leave obvious traces in the form of global warming. I don't think we can rule out the possibility that past species used tools and communicated in ways which resemble human language, but if they'd been numerous and advanced enough to disrupt the climate with their Industrial Revolution, one can reasonably assume remnants of some of its products more substantive than evidence of temperature fluctuations or nitrate residues would exist. Easier to get excited by false positives by widening the search space though: the same geological forces capable of disappearing nations are surely capable of causing temperature anomalies.