3 ms·
Why would it be impossible to have >1 chip access the SDRAM? Like Amiga did. Especially if the GPU already had custom silicon for it. Whether it would be good
by fulafel 6y ago
Why would it be impossible to have >1 chip access the SDRAM? Like Amiga did.
Especially if the GPU already had custom silicon for it.
Whether it would be good engineering (cost, time to market, risks) is of course another issue.
- phire 6y agoIt works for the Amiga because the Amiga has simple DRAM. It gets harder and harder to do such external muxing as the ram gets more and more complex. With multiple banks, row open delays, bursts and more complex signalling (fast and faster ual data rate at lower and lower voltages) it's near impossible to control modern DRAM without a proper controller. And that controller has to live inside a single chip. It would be insanity to try and have two different dram controllers multiplexing the same DRAM chips.
- zozbot234 6y agoThe Amiga "chip" memory was actually quite slow to use, precisely due to it being accessed by both the CPU and chipset - the solution was to add "fast", CPU-only RAM. The address space was unified between "chip" and "fast" memory, but the underlying hardware arrangement was different.
- fulafel 6y agoThe chip mem slowness only came in the later Amiga models with faster CPUs with 32 bit memory buses I think? Part of the constant trend of custom chipset falling behind, after the first machine. (With a few increasingly laggard refreshes)
- rasz 6y agoAmiga worked exactly the same way. All memory access to the so called "Chip" ram had to go thru Agnus. CPU address lines didnt touch ram chips directly. CPU was just a passenger riding on the back of powerful GPU. https://www.pmsoft.nl/amiga/A500-block-diagram.jpg https://www.pmsoft.nl/amiga/A500-block-diagram.jpg
- fulafel 6y agoNotice the data bus is shared but the address bus is not in the pic. So there was arbitration by Agnus but the data didn't go through it.
- rasz 6y agoLow level implementation detail. Agnus is the memory controller here, handling refresh and addressing. Block diagram tristate latch (74LS244 & 74LS373 in real hardware) should be considered part of the chipset (controlled by Gary). Take away Agnus(or even Gary) and CPU cant do anything, cant really say there is any ">1 chip access the SDRAM" here. We would have to go back all the way to C64 to say cpu and graphic chip share same sdram bus ~equally.