5 ms·
There are reasons not to use cloud services for backups, not trusting them with your data being a major one. But then you should still be using some kind of int
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
There are reasons not to use cloud services for backups, not trusting them with your data being a major one. But then you should still be using some kind of internal backup system.
There is no excuse for not having backups.
- jtokoph 6y agoIf you don’t trust them with your data, you can encrypt it with your own keys.
- briffle 6y agoReally, someone just did that for them, for the bargain price of $1.4M. I'm guessing they saved at least that much by outsourcing their entire IT department a few years ago.
- znpy 6y agoThis is really the best possible answer. you just did the root cause analysis for them too (you should send them an invoice). Nothing new, in a way: cut the spending on IT, lower quality, get incidents. Meh.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoBut then you lose the main advantages of using them to begin with. It becomes harder to use, it may not be able to do efficient differential backups or snapshots anymore or require you to do some complicated thing to make it work because their interface isn't meant to be used that way etc. And if it's actually important for the data to remain private, you then have to get the cryptography right, not think that your backups are "encrypted" because you used TLS, or use some snake oil encryption software which is using export ciphers or bad random number generation or anything like that. In-house backups aren't that hard. The hardest thing is to make sure everything is getting backed up that ought to be, and actually test that it is, which is no different with cloud backups.
- throw0101a 6y ago> But then you lose the main advantages of using them to begin with. Poppycock. There's plenty of software that can do encrypted incrementals / differentials: Commvault, NetBackup, Veeam, tarsnap, Duplicity, ZFS snapshot send-recv,
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoYou're asserting that these things are as easy to use as keeping all your junk on a shared Google Drive or whatever it is many companies are currently doing? They all require you to have a level of technical competence equivalent to what would be needed to implement the backups yourself.
- throw0101a 6y agoIf you're talking about something that is worth paying US$ 1M in ransom, then paying someone a few (tens of) thousands in cost centre chargebacks upfront, and probably an ongoing annual fee, is cheap insurance if you want to go with the 'enterprise software'. And if you want 'consumer software' that offers cloud / offsite encrypted back, then Backblaze offers it in a very clicky-clicky fashion that most folks can handle with a bit of hand-holding: * https://help.backblaze.com/hc/en-us/articles/217664688-Can-you-tell-me-more-about-the-encryption-Backblaze-uses- https://help.backblaze.com/hc/en-us/articles/217664688-Can-y... As does Arq, with a documented file format: * https://www.arqbackup.com/arq_data_format.txt https://www.arqbackup.com/arq_data_format.txt Every cloud-capable backup system (for consumers and enterprises) does encryption nowadays, so talking about 'data access' in the cloud is a straw man.
- justinclift 6y agoIf you really want to include NetBackup in that list, then for a real world deployment you'll generally be looking at more than US$1M+. Assuming it's for an actual enterprise or at least large dept. Source: Used to be a NetBackup engineer on enterprise accounts :)
- nindalf 6y ago“No, we can’t use leading cloud providers to store this data. What if someone unauthorised looks at it?” This attitude leaves the victim paying millions in ransom. Look, Microsoft and Amazon probably have a better handle on security than your IT dept which is two people who also have to fix any issues like the WiFi not working or software not updating.
- bpfrh 6y agoThere are stories of MSPs who got their offline backup from the same provider who they bought their cloud based RMM tool. One day an account get's exploited and suddenly the backups are deleted and the systems are all encrypted remotely. Cloud backups are not offline backups, if you want security use tapes or remote systems which turn on manually.
- nindalf 6y agoA backup that can be overwritten is not a backup. It is possible to use a cloud provider and also write an immutable backup.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> This attitude leaves the victim paying millions in ransom. Not if they still have backups that aren't cloud backups. > Look, Microsoft and Amazon probably have a better handle on security than your IT dept which is two people who also have to fix any issues like the WiFi not working or software not updating. And that's part of the problem, right? Your IT department isn't too bright, so they encrypt their cloud backups with a tool that does the encryption wrong, and the smarter engineers at the cloud provider know that it's vulnerable so now they can read your data when you thought they couldn't. Or you use a weak password for the cloud backup account and then some third party breaks in and gets them. Not really a concern with a backup tape stored in a fire safe.
- vinay_ys 6y agoThere is no reason to believe clouds don't have security issues or software bugs that cause inadvertent data loss. Just because the cloud provider is a big company doesn't mean the security is better. At the end of the day, they are a team of software engineers with all the usual people and org problems and can have usual human mistakes. But cloud solutions are better in practice due to totally non-technical reasons. Here's how - If UCSF can afford to pay millions in ransom, they can definitely afford to hire the right experts to do their IT systems properly. It is likely that they hire the right people, but then the most commonly recommended security policies were considered but not implemented due to resistence from powerful non-security team members inside the organization. (Usually, the highly paid CISO is playing politics with peers to keep the job by ignoring those security experts). If it also possible that the IT+security team is incompetent and is only good for deploying expensive but useless vendor solutions that do a lot of security theater but do very little to improve actual security. Also possible that the vendor solutions are susceptible to be misconfigured easily to become insecure. Public cloud solutions can help overcome these above shortcomings of in-house security+IT teams in a org politics friendly manner.
- throw0101a 6y ago> […] not trusting them with your data being a major one. Which is why you encrypt the data before sending it over the wire. Just like how you'd use encryption on LTO tapes before sending them offsite.