4 ms·
This is one of those ideas that sound good in theory but then immediately causes bad effects. The problem with cutting and pasting isn't bots, it's people. Unc
by jychang 6y ago
This is one of those ideas that sound good in theory but then immediately causes bad effects.
The problem with cutting and pasting isn't bots, it's people. Uncle Joe posting 5 links a day from <bad news source> is completely allowed under your system, and yet if there are a million Uncle Joes on your network (and there definitely is a large portion of the population like that), then you'd just be back to square one.
- vkou 6y agoUncle Joe is unlikely to have thousands of followers. And if he does, those followers are again, unlikely to each have thousands of followers. Remember spam chain e-mails back in the 0's? There were a lot of stupid viral ideas going around in them, but their reach was rather limited, and they were, generally speaking, not very successful in breaking into the social zeitgeist. "15 million people liked this" is a lot of social proof. "Uncle Joe + a few dozen other people liked this" is not nearly as much social proof... And viral ideas live and die by the amount of social proof they have. It's quite possible that what I suggest may not be the best possible fix. In fact, I'll go so far to say that it's not. But I have a hard time imagining that we currently live in the best possible world, such that no amount of tweaking the parameters of these sites will result in improvement. The current outcomes are horrible.
- ianwalter 6y agoI think some version of this idea has promise. It's kind of like social distancing and COVID-19.