4 ms·
TL;DR: Physicist Angelo Bassi is trying to experimentally test the GRW collapse model [1], which is in fact experimentally testable. Personally, my money is fi
by lisper 6y ago
TL;DR: Physicist Angelo Bassi is trying to experimentally test the GRW collapse model [1], which is in fact experimentally testable. Personally, my money is firmly on the side of these experiments failing, but I would not bet my entire life savings on it. These experiments may well succeed, and if they do, that will be the biggest breakthrough in physics in 100 years. It's great that someone is actually testing this.
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghirardi%E2%80%93Rimini%E2%80%93Weber_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghirardi%E2%80%93Rimini%E2%80%...
- hatmatrix 6y agoInteresting that such a potentially grand idea is published unceremoniously in a specialized journal (Physical Review D).
- lisper 6y agoFoundations work has historically not been taken very seriously within the physics community.
- leephillips 6y agoPhysicists generally publish their physics in physics journals. There is usually no public ceremony involved.
- deerpig 6y agoPhysical Review D is not a light weight journal. You don't get published there unless you are being taken seriously in the scientific community.
- seiferteric 6y agoNice! This is my favorite theory since it's so conceptually simple (I can actually understand it) but that of course has no bearing about it being reality.
- systemvoltage 6y ago> The imprecise talk of “observer” and a “measurement” that plagues the orthodox interpretation is thus avoided because the wave function collapses spontaneously. Why? Measurement is just a photon you shoot at something. Or electron. Wikipedia is saying we cannot define what an observer is and what constitutes “measurement” - sure we do, measurement interacts with the quantum mechanical system because we need to use something - a photon or an electron or some particle to see how it interacts with the system.
- gotostatement 6y agoI'm not knowledgable of QM. But I don't think that's necessarily true, because photons/electrons are interacting with the system at all times, but the wave function doesn't collapse until we actually observe the result of one of those photons/scatters/whatever, right?
- systemvoltage 6y agoSame, not too knowledgeable but I thought this was no longer a mystery.
- gotostatement 6y agomy point is that, a photon bouncing off the system doesn't suffice as a measurement, because photons and electrons are always interacting with the system, but the measurement/wave function collapse doesn't occur until there's some other type of observation that occurs, e.g. a photon that's specifically sent and read by the experimenter
- aeternum 6y agoSuppose you fire a photon through a polarizing filter. If the photon's polarization is orthogonal to the filter, it will be blocked however if not orthogonal, the photon can pass through with some probability. Does putting the photon through the filter count as a measurement?
- 6y ago
- andrewon 6y agoagreed. More physicists (but not all) should be doing something like this. This is what tenure system for.