8 ms·
Wooden iPad 2 cover outsmarts Apple's Smart Cover
- pohl 16y agoDo watch the video. Great design!
- spoiledtechie 16y agoThis is getting ridiculous. Why do we up vote something that is a given? HN, stop it! You only up vote things that make you learn something. Why on earth did pohl just get 16 points for nothing. We need to stop with the promoting of things like "thank you" or "good job" Im sorry, I just went on a little rant. The cover is awesome, but did I just learn anything from pohl? I don't care to see this comment over more informative comments below.
- Travis 16y agoThank you for mentioning this. (Couldn't resist a little joke at your expense, sorry about that. I actually appreciated the parent comment -- most of the time I never play videos, because they take me out of my normal flow. But due to his comment, I actually watched this one, and am now impressed.)
- mcav 16y agoNo, it's useful. It means that with N upvotes, N people agree with the comment. That gives a great indicator as to whether or not the video is worth my time. The comment could have easily said that the video is a waste of time, which would also be helpful. People won't upvote it if they disagree.
- mbreese 16y agoAn upvote doesn't necessarily mean that you agree with the comment. They are supposed to mean that the comment is worthwhile or adds something to the discussion. IMO, the ggp comment doesn't.
- mcav 16y agoThey mean whatever the upvoter wants them to mean: agreement, approval, or a meant-to-click-downvote instead. In practical use, people often do upvote because they agree.
- jarek 16y agoSo I'm a newbie here, my account is less than a year old, god knows I've trolled and flamed my share, etc. But when I first joined, I saw the guideline/notion that upvotes should indicate contribution to discussion rather than agreement and was impressed. I'd be sad if this position was abandoned. Upvoting for contribution to discussion promotes good discussion. Upvoting for agreement promotes hivemind, of whichever variety.
- mcav 16y agoIn 2009, I wrote a little parody of the Zen of Python that includes a bit about what I felt upvotes were/should be used for: http://marcuscavanaugh.com/zen-of-hn/ http://marcuscavanaugh.com/zen-of-hn/ -- I think that regardless of what guidelines were created initially, people do upvote as agreement, whether we like it or not. I like upvotes as an expression of agreement because it gives an indication of the truthiness of the comment (wisdom of the crowd). If someone says something in a field I'm not familiar with, and I don't know if they're right or not, I know that the following will occur: - If they're right, people will upvote. - If they're wrong, people will either downvote or reply stating why they're wrong. And since I don't think any of us want comments like "I Agree", upvotes are our only option for providing a vote of confidence in a comment.
- schrototo 16y agoBut shouldn't the votes on the link itself already be enough to decide that?
- ugh 16y agoI don’t think many people on HN like watching videos. Linking only to videos is often criticized. My assumption would always be that most people on HN do not watch videos if it doesn’t seem obvious what additional information the video could provide (like in this case). Pohl’s comment makes perfect sense in that context. My assumption would be – and this might also be pohl’s assumption – that the video would simply not be watched if nobody says that the video is truly worth watching.
- pohl 16y agoYes, that was my motivation.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- VladRussian 16y agodo you think you have any credibility to teach people here what to vote for? With 1.57 avg?
- kgermino 16y agoWhat does his average have to do with it? spoiledtechie has been around much longer than you or I, and was only expressing his opinion about the usefulness of the top comment. Now I happen to disagree with him and may down-vote the comment because I think meta-discussions about the quality of HN are much more annoying than any decline in quality that may or may not exist, but that has nothing to do with his credibility, and neither does his karma, comment average, or much of anything else.
- VladRussian 16y ago>What does his average have to do with it?....neither does his karma, comment average, ... in his post spoiledtechie clearly connected upvotes/points and informativeness. If we accept that connection, having 1.57 average, he can't credibly make statements about informativeness.
- jarek 16y agoOf course he can. This is the old point about reviewers not having to be creators again.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- gobongo 16y agoI have to say, I agree. Just think about all those starving kids in Ethopia with no upvotes and here we are on HN sitting in our comfortable Aeron chairs just pissing our upvotes away. Proof positive we are in the karma bubble here!!
- bjoernw 16y agoWhat's with this hostility on HN lately? Everyone has a choice to upvote or not and some people use upvotes as a way to identify with a response. I got the same vibes in the Instagram resume post yesterday. You are not protecting the quality of a community by barking at every behavior you don't approve of. This arrogance has been a turnoff lately. Maybe it's just me or I only come across the pessimistic comments.
- pohl 16y agoWhy on earth did pohl just get 16 points for nothing Whoa there, cowboy. I posted that so that those who clicked-through to the article but impatiently left would stay for the demonstration. Only lever-pushing, pellet-munching hamsters care about the points. P.S. I modded you up.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- spoiledtechie 16y agoIts not the points I care about. Its the fact that it was the top rated item. I would rather have something at the top I can take away from.
- pohl 16y agoMy one line of text pales next to the off-topic meta rant thread you spawned though, doesn't it. Had you been motivated by the noise and not the points you wouldn't have done that. Or shouldn't have, at least. (+1 from me again)
- mapster 16y agogood point, but comments that hi-jack a thread should be down voted :)
- dstone 16y agoIf that's a solid sheet of microfiber on the inside, then I'm sold. The thing that irritates me most about the Smart Cover is that it leaves streaks on the glass where the indentations are.
- nazgulnarsil 16y agocan't be solid. if it was tight when rolled up it would be loose when flat.
- s3graham 16y agoMaybe making it elastic-y would be enough extra length to work in both states?
- barista 16y agoWhat's cool about AAPL is that it inspires such innovative designs. Beautiful.
- HelloBeautiful 16y agoSomeone have drunk too much Kool-Aid ... What's so uncool about AAPL is the closed platform, that killed so many innovations.
- fleitz 16y agoI do like apple products but really what innovation did they kill? Do you know how unthinkable an app store model was 5 years ago? Sure there are innovative things happening on android but would it even exist without iPhone?
- HelloBeautiful 16y ago>>I do like apple products but really what innovation did they kill? All kind of products that would've competed with Apple bundled apps, or could've been seen as illegal in some state, or had some erotic content ... >>Do you know how unthinkable an app store model was 5 years ago? Microsoft had a store 5 years ago. What does it have to do with Apple closing their platforms, to make higher profits, while stopping a lot of innovation? >>Sure there are innovative things happening on android but would it even exist without iPhone? Symbian, Windows CE and many more existed before the iPhone. As the price of hardware falls and mobile devices become more powerful/useful more and more users are getting smartphones. Android would've made perfect sense, w/o iPhone.
- raganwald 16y agoAre you saying that Apple doesn't inspire design? Or are you saying "Yes, they inspire great design, but here's this other completely unrelated gripe I have, so I'm going to grind my axe every time Apple is mentioned with any kind of positive tone?" I'm not slamming you on this, if you could show a connection between the two things, that would be very interesting. Sticking to software and not to hardware, I might say that Microsoft and the PC manufacturers allow anybody to make anything, so there are nice PC-Windows things but they are drowned in a sea of dreck. But Apple retain a tight fist over software and filter out the crap. It might appear that Apple inspires great software, but that's only because the proportion of nice stuff to dreck is higher when someone's filtering the dreck out. In reality there might be 2x or even 10x as much nice stuff in total written for Windows, it's just drowned by 100x as much dreck. Now, I am not saying that, it's a strawman put up as an example of drawing a connection between their closed platform policies and great design by third parties. Perhaps you can draw a better connection? I actually sympathize with you... I have written several blog posts criticizing Apple's policies. I just don't see the connection here and need some help connecting the dots.
- yumraj 16y agoWhats amazing about Apple is that even a cover for one of its products makes it to the top of HN. Update: If it wasn't obvious, I was being sarcastic and sad.
- Terretta 16y agoThis isn't about Apple. It's about an innovative 'hack' using organic materials to beautify and humanize a technology device. At least, that's how I see this case.
- yumraj 16y agoOf course its about Apple. Think about it, would it have made it to the top of HN if it were a cover for Galaxy tab, or something else for that matter.
- HelloBeautiful 16y agoYes.
- pohl 16y agoAre you suggesting that there are awesome innovations inspired by the Galaxy tab out there being ignored by HN? Post some!
- beaumartinez 16y agoThe key in the title is that it says it "outsmarts Apple's Smart Cover". The Smart Cover was incredibly well-designed yet incredibly simple. Anything capable of giving it a run for its money should be equally as interesting (at least from a design stand-point).
- edw 16y agoHow exactly does this cover outsmart Apple's? I can't fold it in half. I can't fold the whole thing over save one quarter, so that the rear camera lens is exposed. It's nifty, it's another option, but is it better? Better for what? I'd ask, and I'm sure it's more exclusive but from an everyday use perspective, I just don't see it.
- samirg 16y agoOnly thing they didn't show was whether the hinge snaps on/off as easily as the Smart Cover.
- beaumartinez 16y agoFrom the looks of things it didn't use one? (Or at least I managed to completely miss it.)
- isleyaardvark 16y agoThere's no hinge. He turns the iPad completely around at about the 0:25 mark. That's a pretty big aesthetic difference.
- mattberg 16y agothe part around the 41 second mark where he flips open the cover concerns me a little, notice him placing his left hand on the hinge area for support. i wonder if maybe it comes off too easily.
- calloc 16y agoOr it is a completely natural gesture when rolling up the cover in a certain position to help create the stand ...
- CoachRufus87 16y agoDid Apple patent their cover design?
- cletus 16y agoReally? A wooden cover for the iPad 2... with magnets. That's what makes the top of HN? I can see this belonging on Engadget but what's the value here? Don't get me wrong: I have an iPad 2. I love my iPad (1 & 2). I just don't see how a wooden cover for it is HN-worthy.
- borism 16y agoReally? A wooden cover for the iPad 2.. yes. it's much more ingenious than iPad 2 if you think about it. In fact this thing made me consider for a second that maybe I should get an iPad.
- TomOfTTB 16y agoA few reasons (as far as I'm concerned) 1. Startups could learn a lot about presentation from this guy. I don't know about anyone else but I was struck by the video's simple, matter of fact style. No flash or funny animations. Just a smart guy showing what his company had done (and then thanking me for my time) 2. People deify Apple too much. Apple's great but you can compete with them if you put some effort into it. Sure most people won't want a wooden iPad cover but some will and it very well may be enough to make a profit off of. 3. Some people might want a wooden iPad cover and this lets them know about it (isn't that the same thing all those "Tell HN" threads do) For a community centered around startups I think those insights are valuable which is why I up-voted it.
- viraptor 16y ago> No flash or funny animations. Just a smart guy showing what his company had done Well... the product does come from Holland. Try watching some Finish videos if you want more of that. People in both of those countries are pretty straightforward in life (based both on personal experience and anecdotes, YMMV).
- mixmax 16y agoActually, being from Denmark, this is one thing that annoys me about a lot of Americen advertising. It's awfully obnoxious and in-your-face.
- vnchr 16y agoA lot of really negative and unnecessary comments on this blog. did the TechCrunch trolls ousted by their new FB commenting plugin find a new home?
- jobu 16y agoNo kidding. I haven't seen this many useless comments since people were spamming HN with blog posts about Ruby.
- cegascon 16y agoSimple, Great, presentation
- dotBen 16y agoStill trying to work out how this wooden iPad cover outsmarts Apple's own cover (as promised in the title). Can anyone help me out?
- bane 16y agoIt's similar, but the customer pays more for this one instead.
- fakelvis 16y agoI'm not quite sure that's entirely true, as is pointed out in the article. In the NL Apple Store, polyurethane Smart Covers costs €39 each while a leather one costs €69 (in Apple's eyes €1 = $1). This wooden cover costs €50. I don't think it's fair to compare wood to polyurethane, but feel free to do so in order to make your argument stand.
- bane 16y agoNo you are right, in the US store, the leather case is ~$70 and this wooden one is ~$70 (not counting shipping or anything). Ugh, when did cases get so ridiculously expensive? These are really rather exorbitant prices IMHO. For what these things are, I'd maybe part with...$12-15 for the polyurethane one and $20-25 for a leather? At $40 or $70 (respectively), I'd need a case to protect my case.
- apotheon 16y agoThat's easily the best thing about the iPad.
- linker3000 16y agoOne thing's for certain: leave that thing on the kitchen while food's being prepared and your iPad will soon smell of chopped onions and garlic.
- tlowrimore 16y agoWow. I never really wanted an iPad until I saw this sexy little cover. Hmmm... I may have to go stand in line.