3 ms·
> The reason we have too many PhDs In what sense do we have too many PhDs? The market for PhDs is pretty competitive.
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> The reason we have too many PhDs
In what sense do we have too many PhDs? The market for PhDs is pretty competitive.
- laingc 6y agoWe graduate an order of magnitude more PhDs than anyone has a real use for. Even ignoring arts and humanities PhDs which are obvious cases, in fields like biology a newly minted average PhD has roughly zero people competing for them. They’ll be lucky to find a job even close to their field. You have biology PhDs working as Clinical Research Associates, for heaven’s sake.
- chrisseaton 6y agoI don't understand - you can do thousands of jobs with a PhD. You can be a high-school teacher in your subject for example.- I don't think we have a shortage of teachers! Or you can work in industry. Not everyone does a PhD in order to get onto a tenure track at a college, which is what I think you meant.
- laingc 6y agoAs someone with a PhD who works in industry, that’s certainly not what I meant. There is a massive, massive oversupply of PhDs. We can argue about the magnitude of the oversupply, but the reasonable range of discussion is between “huge” and “gigantic”.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> There is a massive, massive oversupply of PhDs. There clearly isn't - since there's such huge competition to hire them. If there was a massive oversupply they'd be unemployed.
- laingc 6y agoThere is almost no competition to hire them, as far as I can see. Maybe top-flight CS PhDs from Stanford, I’d believe that. But your average biology or chemistry PhD? Every single one of them that I know struggled mightily in the job market.
- raincom 6y agoFor Chinese and Indians, it takes decades to get green card in EB-3, EB-2 categories. They can just do Ph.D, and get green card in O-1 and EB-1 categories. If one is 21, they can just come here for Ph.D in biology somewhere by the age of 25. Spend another three years PostDoc, while getting green card. You may ask, isn't it a waste of time going through this rigamole? Of course, it is a waste of time for the super brilliant people; however, majority of them are like average you and me.