3 ms·
>to send officers to target chronic offenders, or identifying places where crime may occur. Those are two very different things in my mind. Targeting individu
by Havoc 6y ago
>to send officers to target chronic offenders, or identifying places where crime may occur.
Those are two very different things in my mind.
Targeting individuals is very Minority Report and definitely not cool.
Focusing on problematic areas seems like good policing common sense though? A bit like the local nightclub near me has a police car chilling in front of it every Friday night because there are always drunks slugging it out.
- seaish 6y agoThey usually use past crime to determine the problematic areas, and this past crime is a source of bias. If there's any sort of racism in the system, problematic areas will turn into areas of specific race. Races and especially income levels aren't spread evenly across Santa Cruz or any city.
- thereisnospork 6y agoIf cars are being broken into on a specific block at a rate higher than average for a precinct are you suggesting that it is 'bias' to focus resources onto that block? Or are you referring to places where formerly charged/convicted persons live/hang out? Here I'd agree, punishment should end at the end of the sentence/fine and people deserve the benefit of the doubt/presumption of non-recidivism. I'd also posit that many problematic areas are areas of a specific race and caution that a policy of under-policing these areas to avoid appearing racist will be disastrous to public safety and order.
- wongarsu 6y agoDrug use is consistently found to be about equal between White and Black Americans, or higher among White Americans. Yet arrests and sentences for drug use are far more frequent for Black Americans than for White Americans, presumably because higher policing. Wherever you drive in America you will find drug abuse. But if you focus on any one area that leads to more arrests there, increasing their crime stats, leading to more policing, leading to more drug arrests, ... https://www.hamiltonproject.org/charts/rates_of_drug_use_and_sales_by_race_rates_of_drug_related_criminal_justice https://www.hamiltonproject.org/charts/rates_of_drug_use_and...
- ReptileMan 6y agoIt is complicated at best. I think that in most jurisdictions seriously planing a crime is a crime in itself. >A bit like the local nightclub near me has a police car chilling in front of it every Friday night because there are always drunks slugging it out. And what happens when said policemen block the entrance of the club and start patting down everyone leaving for pico or weed? A police presence can calm down an area, but also can be used to harass the population there. Rules of engagement matter.
- Havoc 6y ago>what happens when said policemen block the entrance of the club Why on earth would they do that?
- ReptileMan 6y agoI have no idea, but some people are worried about that kind of behavior.
- QuotedForTruth 6y agoAre they actually focusing on problematic areas or just areas that they previously focused on? Wherever the most police resources are spent, you will have the most crime. That then justifies spending more resources there. The algorithm may not be racist, but it is guaranteed to perpetuate our objectively racist policing of the past.
- sfj 6y ago> The algorithm may not be racist, but it is guaranteed to perpetuate our objectively racist policing of the past. Depends on how the algorithm is formulated. If it's based on number of crimes found, by policeman, by hour, then this would eliminate that concern (vs just number of crimes per hour).