5 ms·
yeah, early on and even now, all Covid19 information was disseminated in a way to maximize emotional response. That guaranteed either news worse than the facts
by chasd00 6y ago
yeah, early on and even now, all Covid19 information was disseminated in a way to maximize emotional response. That guaranteed either news worse than the facts or news that was better than the facts. Everything, and i mean _everything_, was sensationalized in order to get you to click or register your outrage somewhere with a link back to the source.
Reality is reality and as time progressed it became clear what was happening with the information delivery and now no one trusts anything from anyone.
Covid19 is pretty bad but what happened to informing the public is near worst case scenario in my book.
- NotSammyHagar 6y agoActually what you're saying comes across as scaremongering. You're trying to say that there are no legitimate sources, the legitimate sources like the New York times or major medical journals are not trustworthy. You're arguing in favor of what you said is a problem.
- AndrewBissell 6y agoThe NYT was definitely on the "news that was better than the facts" train for quite awhile in the early days of the pandemic. I would argue the media as a whole is still largely downplaying how bad things are, likely as a matter of serving the imperatives of their corporate owners, but this isn't an idea which finds any purchase with conservatives (who want not to be inconvenienced by COVID in any way) or liberals (who are allergic to most criticism of the news media or anything which can be painted with the "conspiratorial" brush).
- apatters 6y agoNeither the NYT nor academic journals are a legitimately useful source of COVID-19 information for a layperson. The NYT's coverage has been full of scaremongering and speculation and the world would probably have been better off without it. And a layperson doesn't have the time and training to understand journal articles in context. The best sources are public health authorities like the WHO and CDC. They have consistently made careful and measured statements, been fairly accurate, minimized scaremongering and speculation without understating the seriousness of the situation, and issued useful recommendations. Most people would be better off following these authorities directly and ignoring other coverage.
- toomim 6y agoI mostly agree with you, but the WHO and CDC famously told people not to wear masks for way too long after data was distributed showing mask's effectiveness for preventing infection. I would not trust them.
- NotSammyHagar 6y agoThe not wearing masks things was terrible, because it seems like they probably recognized there was some benefit but they wanted to reserve them for health workers. That what I always thought and I'm not alone. The WHO seems to have a series of flawed statements (like the one recently where they made a misleading comment about asymptomatic people). It's like the who needs to hire a competent pr agency. If only they had said "there's some protective affect by wearing masks but we want to prioritize health workers getting ppe while we ramp up manufacturing".
- DanBC 6y ago> but the WHO and CDC famously told people not to wear masks for way too long after data was distributed showing mask's effectiveness for preventing infection Do you have links to that data? For you to make this claim you'd be able to link to a meta-analysis or a well run RCT.
- apatters 6y agoAs usual there is nuance to this story which the incendiary popular media failed to capture, because it doesn't bait clicks. Early on the WHO's biggest concern was that panic buying would lead to mask shortages for health care workers. If you have to choose between an unmasked public and unmasked health care workers, having the public go without is definitely the better option. So IIRC around March they issued the guideline - if you feel sick, wear a mask, otherwise don't. And it made sense in context, because after masks worn by health care workers, the infected are the next most effective place to deploy masks in terms of protecting public health. Eventually mask supply increased because everybody started producing them. The WHO then changed its recommendation to "everyone should wear." So I don't really think the WHO did anything wrong here. But because of the one-sided way it was portrayed in the media, the negatives got amplified and we ended up with "WHO NWO EXPOSED MILLIONS DEAD!! BILL GATES EUTHANIZES AFRICA CONTINENT GLOBAL ELITES KILLING VACCINE PEDOPHILIA" all over YouTube. Again.
- rumanator 6y ago> You're trying to say that there are no legitimate sources, the legitimate sources like the New York times or major medical journals are not trustworthy. Newspapers are at best a secondary source, not primary. Academic journals are intended to disseminate articles to be subjected to peer review, which means they are intended to spark discussions over observations among researchers in the field. This means that, with the exception of academic fraud, it's expected that their content doesn't reflect solid understanding of the issues involved. Otherwise they would be pointless as scientific papers.