5 ms·
People are missing the point of the article. It's not about hipocrisy, or the ability of ground-up change to solve climate change, but instead about the credibi
by rayiner 6y ago
People are missing the point of the article. It's not about hipocrisy, or the ability of ground-up change to solve climate change, but instead about the credibility of people demanding sweeping government intervention to address climate change. When someone who advocates for banning abortion turns out to have paid to have his girlfriend have an abortion, it obviously doesn't have any bearing on the moral question of abortion. Nor does it have any significant aggregate effect on the number of abortions. But it eliminates that person's credibility, for the simple reason that it highlights the negative implications of the person's proposed policy. It underscores that having an unplanned child can drastically change the course of a person's life in ways they may be desperate to avoid. And it suggests that the person may not even believe their moral premise, and wants to ban abortion as a pretext for something else. By contrast, people who lead by example signal that they're willing to live with the consequences of the policies they wish to impose on everyone--and in the process demonstrate to people that those consequences can be lived with.
The same thing is true for climate change. When people who demand a war-time mobilization of the economy to combat climate change still emit gigatons going on foreign vacations, that signals to people one of two things. One, the reduction in standard of living required to address climate change must be enormous, because even those who believe catastrophe is at our doorstep won't suffer that reduction unless the government forces them to. Or two, those people don't really believe climate change will be that bad, and their demand for government intervention is a pretext for something else.
- WhompingWindows 6y agoIndividual choice has a very small role in climate change. The author has done nothing, zero, to contextualize the issue in numbers and data, which clearly demonstrate that individual choice is maybe 5-10% of what we need to decarbonize. Foreign vacations (which aren't even occurring in 2020) are a pittance here...we're talking about billions of fossil-fuel powered engines, hundreds of millions of livestock, heating and cooling homes for upwards of 10 billion humans, the production of steel, fertilizer, plastics, concrete, electronics, mining operations, shipping, trucking...it's just so much more vast than the hypocrisy of rich leftist environmentalists going on vacations.
- leeoniya 6y agounfortunately consumers have been pre-conditioned to pricing structures and behaviors that completely discard all externalities. it would be a rude wake-up call for most if suddenly this stuff had to be produced responsibly, without planned obsolecense or presumption of free landfill storage. however, this is exactly what needs to happen. and it needs to happen via regulation of the giant producers, because capitalism is not compatible with anything but maximizing profits and minimizing costs. individual action is mostly meaningless - if people had to personally kill the cattle they eat many would likely swear off meat. without direct involvement in the damaging process of production consumers are fsr too removed to stop consuming ethically-compromised, cheap goods.
- golergka 6y agoYou're missing the point, again. It's not about actual role in climate change. It's about your image, as an activist, in a public eye. Publuc eye is stupid. It's certainly guilty of logical errors you accuse it off – you're right about that. However, you will not be able to actually convince this public eye that he makes these mistakes, exactly because it's pretty dumb. So, if you actually want to convince people en masse about something, you have to play by the rules of this PR game, even though you may very well understand that the rules are stupid and people make logical mistakes.
- walleeee 6y agoYour comment is exactly what OP is talking about. The article is about credibility, not the role of individual choice. Obviously climate change is bigger than rich people going on vacations. Neither the article nor OP disputes this. The point you're missing is that people who advocate for sweeping policy change - the sort that will require people to drastically change their lifestyles, as well as drastically changing the way human industry operates - are more likely to be taken seriously when they change their lifestyles in advance.
- milsebg 6y agoWell that is exactly the point. Of course, climate activists reducing their individual leisure demand would decrease global carbon emissions only insignificantly, if at all. That's not the point here. The point is that climate activists ask their government for big changes because they fear civilization could end otherwise. And those big changes would have significant impact on the lifestyle of almost all people affected by these laws. So, why should one be willing to (and thus, vote for the changes) change ones lifestyle, if the advocates just say "well, I stop travelling abroad, when everyone else stops as well (and other carbon emission is reduced, too)"? The OP is about credibility, or, even lower level: sympathy. Maybe it becomes more obvious if we look at one specific example. In the Netherlands they lowered maximum speed on highways to 100 km/h (from 120 km/h). Correct me if I'm wrong but the carbon saving from that law is close to non-existent compared to the whole economy's carbon emissions. Or, the whole EU banned light bulbs. Also, the energy saving compared to the whole EU's energy consumption is probably sub 1%. And with the advent of white LEDs, people just use more light and the overall effect is even less. Both measurments combined have an impact less than your claimed 5%-10%. Does that mean that government should stop taking small steps, and only the "big shot" counts? Or can small steps (by governments OR individuals) be a tool to increase awareness?
- minkzilla 6y agoHypocrisy is an interesting thing because in your example the immediate reaction is yeah that guy is full of shit. However, there is also scenarios were the person knows better than anyone because they’ve been through something. A meth addict telling you never do meth because it’ll ruin your life isn’t being hypocritical, they are speaking from experience and regret that they did it.
- tanseydavid 6y agoA meth addict telling you never do meth -- does not amount to 'policy'. I think that a better comparison would be "a still-active meth addict who advocates for government action that would likely deprive them of the ability to continue using meth." In this scenario the addict actually has some 'skin in the game' as opposed to just preaching.
- koheripbal 6y agoI agree with you that that is the point of the article. But I think the article misses the point. In a classic Tragedy of the Commons problem, the participants don't need to abstain from feeding in the commons in order to organize a ban on it. In fact, such self-abstainments are self-defeating because they cause the good actors to lose economic power and then have less ability to force systemic change. I find that telling people to live with low CO2 footprints to be a whataboutism distraction to have them economically nerf themselves, hence silencing their economic power to force systemic change. ...now imagine that on a global international level. The ability to force change is correlated to economic power - which "good actor" countries are sacrificing, and "bad actor" countries are filling the void. For these reasons, change can only happen with a global international accord that has an enforcement mechanism. ...and hence one of the reasons, I personally don't think Climate Change will be stopped.
- burlesona 6y agoI think this is pretty accurate, and a closely related variation on the theme is the idea that most of the proposals to fight climate change sound like they’ll make “ordinary life” more difficult and expensive. Poorer countries see richer countries say “no more fossil fuels” and could easily think “gee it’s convenient that you built the whole world economy around fossil fuels then try to stop their use just as we’re catching up.” In the same way, in the US a lot of folks react to climate policy things with: “so rich folks will still be able to fly cross-country for 10x the price in an ‘eco plane’ but regular people will be cut off from that freedom.” At the end of the day people are pretty much not willing to accept a quality of life cut voluntarily, especially not a significant one. Thus you see people say: okay so the oceans will rise, but I don’t live within an hour of the ocean so I’m fine. Yep, not willing to sacrifice my personal luxuries and freedoms for that. Folks should just move as the waters rise. I think the far scarier issue is the second Order effects we can’t predict. But because we can’t predict it, the people who aren’t inclined to want to give up their quality of life (almost everyone), are even less likely to want to make preventative changes.
- svara 6y agoI agree with what you're saying, I think people do have a moral obligation to try to be consistent in their beliefs and actions. But there's also a different way to view this: This is a textbook tragedy of the commons situation. Basically we're stuck in regime where at the individual level, you're hurting yourself if you're doing the right thing, for almost zero gain to the environment. Getting out of that regime takes concerted action, which most likely will not happen without regulation. The most effective way to help solve the problem is therefore to push for that regulation. That's probably unless you're a celebrity or something.
- milsebg 6y agoAnd one way to "push for that regulation" is giving an example that you are not hurting yourself too much if your choices reflect the legislation you demand. If you ARE in fact hurting yourself too much, then you prove that people can chose one from the following: A) keep the status quo, but the planet will most probably heat up and very bad things happen. B) change the status quo to something that really, really hurts. But the reward for your surrender is that there is a chance that the planet does not heat up so much and less bad things happen a few decades from now. That is what most people perceive in climate activists.
- svara 6y agoYes, it makes sense that it could be perceived that way. But that would not be entirely accurate, since it will get much cheaper to emit less CO2 once there is effective regulation in place. For example: If a really painful Carbon tax was introduced over night, the next day people's lives would look a lot different. Activities that used to be mundane would suddenly be expensive luxuries. However, that's ignoring the fact that the economy would start to route around this tax. What are currently still niche low-carbon technologies will get a lot cheaper due to economies of scale. Photovoltaics are already a super cheap way of making electricity while the sun shines - suddenly there's going to be a huge incentive to building out storage. (Of course, you wouldn't actually do that over night.)
- 6y ago
- mgolawala 6y agoI agree with you, the author of the original post, and your summary, however I have one nitpick with his rape analogy. With something like Rape, it is wrong and cannot be tolerated in even the smallest amount. Zero is the only acceptable level of rape. Pollution is different. We all know that exterminating the majority of the human population and returning to a hunter/gatherer society is not an option. The realistic goal isn't to eliminate all forms of pollution everywhere, it is to reduce the pollution to a level that is less harmful to the planet. The problem is in identifying where and how deep to make the cuts. Such a situation allows for a person to continue to eat meat, live in a big house and take vacations, while simultaneously calling for cuts to deforestation, legislating for EV transport and nuclear power, and do so without hypocrisy. Essentially you can have each group say "make the cuts, and make them deep, but make them over there".
- LatteLazy 6y agoPeople don't start with credibility. Credibility is an excuse for things they already decided.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ajmurmann 6y agoIndividual action will accomplish nothing too fight climate change other than lowering that individual persons quality of life. If I stop traveling by airplane nothing changes about climate change. In fact action of a individual country even accomplishes nothing if other countries don't pull in the same direction. It's the classic tragedy of the commons.