3 ms·
Reminder: OKCupid is owned by Match Group (also owns Tinder, Plenty of Fish, BlackPeopleMeet, OurTime, Twoo, match.com, and others), which sells their entire pr
by sneak 6y ago
Reminder: OKCupid is owned by Match Group (also owns Tinder, Plenty of Fish, BlackPeopleMeet, OurTime, Twoo, match.com, and others), which sells their entire profile database (unredacted(!), with full names, sexual preferences, locations, and photos) to data brokers[1].
Very few services are immune from this. I learned recently that Airbnb (YC W09) actually sells your chat logs[2] and stay history(!) to data brokers, which can be used for stalking or kidnapping in the wrong hands.
Coinbase (YC S12) is also one of the companies that sells your activity log (including IP addresses and timestamps, which amounts to a location tracklog) to a third party without your explicit consent (other than creating a Coinbase account).
1: https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/59vbp5/shady-data-brokers-are-selling-online-dating-profiles-by-the-millions https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/59vbp5/shady-data-brokers...
2: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/04/business/secret-consumer-score-access.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/04/business/secret-consumer-...
- pjc50 6y agoSounds like a GDPR fine waiting to happen.
- dreggie 6y agoCCPA is really focused on sellers and aggregators of personal data, and this is a perfect example of why they need regulation.
- crobertsbmw 6y agoThat vice article is more interesting than the OPs one.
- sukilot 6y agoRemember that YC prefers to fund "naughty" founders, to use their own term.
- Drdrdrq 6y agohttp://paulgraham.com/founders.html http://paulgraham.com/founders.html What We Look for in Founders 4. Naughtiness Though the most successful founders are usually good people, they tend to have a piratical gleam in their eye. They're not Goody Two-Shoes type good. Morally, they care about getting the big questions right, but not about observing proprieties. That's why I'd use the word naughty rather than evil. They delight in breaking rules, but not rules that matter. This quality may be redundant though; it may be implied by imagination.
- mercer 6y agoJesus. I imagine getting the 'big questions' right is so vague as to remove any culpability from both YC and those it funds. I mean, if I had a friend who openly claimed to be 'naughty' in this way, I'd start being very cautious around them.
- gmantg 6y agoYC is right, though. People who play by others rules rarely succeed. All these senior managers, vps, execs, business owners arent known for following the silly rules.
- rapind 6y agoBasically our society rewards douchebaggery...
- econcon 6y agoNearly all products, markets and human interactions operate on specific model which makes some assumptions, those assumptions often end up as rule - so that the model stay predictable for the people governing it. By not following those assumptions (rules) you can make a new better model which might have better accuracy at representative real world problem than the existing model. It doesn't mean that it's unethical or morally wrong. It doesn't have to be.
- deleted 6y ago
- bhntr3 6y ago> I learned recently that Airbnb (YC W09) actually sells your chat logs[2] and stay history(!) to data brokers, which can be used for stalking or kidnapping in the wrong hands. That's a pretty big misrepresentation of the NY Times article. From the article: > Sift doesn’t sell or share any of the data it has with third parties. Sift is a third party risk analysis provider. One of its big selling points is that it can correlate fraud signals across multiple data sets. So, essentially, companies that DON'T want to share data with each other can share data with sift and rely on it to provide aggregate results back. In this way it's the opposite of a data broker. Companies trust it to hold sensitive data they don't want to share. There are a lot of reasons why any centralized fraud prevention service is concerning and I know that many companies, including Airbnb, limit their use of these signals for that reason. Truthfully, I think the dangers of such a service far outweigh their value and it simply shouldn't exist at all. Regardless, it's quite different than selling your data to a data broker. If there were any indication that Sift were selling or sharing this data I guarantee they would get dropped instantly. If you believe that a company can't really care about its users' privacy (and you might be justified in that) just consider that sharing this data would be the same as sharing it with the fraudsters it ostensibly tries to stop. That would defeat the entire point of the service. To a sibling poster, the premise of the NYT article is that Sift allowed end users to download their own data because of GDPR not in violation of it. There are often threads on here criticizing Airbnb for allowing fraud on the platform and saying they do nothing to prevent it. Here we're criticizing them for sharing data with a centralized fraud system to gain signal on potential fraud. I think this is the crux of the discussion about the surveillance state vs "defund the police". Algorithmic fraud detection is a frequently racist invasion of privacy. But fraud and crime are also both bad and tend to have a more significant impact on a company's brand / reputation than overreaching in terms of data collection and surveillance. So it's very important to hold them accountable for their use of data but let's not muddy the argument by misrepresenting what's happening.
- sneak 6y agoHow did Sift get it, if it wasn’t disclosed by the second party in the first place? I don’t want my booking site disclosing my location to others who may use it to harm me, full stop. I have no idea what internal controls, if any, Sift or any other service provider has in place to screen their own staff or their own data handling procedures for safety. Even Equifax didn’t get this stuff right. If I am telling a vendor where I sleep and when I am sleeping there, it is a huge breach of my privacy and safety for them to tell third parties without my explicit consent. This includes even relatively innocuous stuff, like database hosting. One disgruntled employee and a .torrent file later and many people’s lives or safety are put at risk.