3 ms·
Zoom is Level 4, any experimental SDCs is Level 4 and all production SDC technology is Level 2. Few manufacturers thought L3 is simple enough to at least try, b
by numpad0 6y ago
Zoom is Level 4, any experimental SDCs is Level 4 and all production SDC technology is Level 2. Few manufacturers thought L3 is simple enough to at least try, but all were abandoned for above reasons. By definitions,
Level 2: driver always pays attention
Level 3: car pays attention, may request driver
Level 4: car do not require driver
This seems simple enough, but Level 3 requires car to be able to drive entirely by itself + be able to predict situations minutes into the future, including situations that cannot be predicted. That requirement far surpasses Level 4, or laws of physics known to humans, Level 3 classification is thus invalid and there are only Level 2 and 4.
- hevelvarik 6y agoThanks for defining. I’m missing something: what is the purpose of level 3. Isn’t level 4 all you could ask for?
- numpad0 6y agoAutomotive industry wanted a gradual transition from manually driven cars to fully robotic cars. That’s fine, but they didn’t ask for inputs from software engineers about how to do it. So they worded that that you may have either: 1) no wheels, or 2) wheels that may shear off, or 3) wheels that may shear off but continue to support weight for a while, or 4) wheels that don’t shear off under normal conditions, or 5) wheels that don’t shear off under any circumstances. Simple enough right?
- csours 6y agoIf you're a consumer, you probably don't want level 3. If you're a company selling self driving cars, you probably don't want level 3. If you're a research organization developing self driving cars, you will find yourself stuck at level 3, because level 4 is really really hard. Going from level 3 to level 4 means getting rid of any problem that would keep you at level 3. Disclaimer: I work for GM, not on SDC, this is solely my opinion.
- mynameisvlad 6y agoAs someone who owns a Tesla, I think a lot of people want level 3 even if they don't realize it. Obviously if level 4 was available, people would go for it, but perfect is the enemy of good, and even with Tesla's L2 technology, it makes driving significantly easier. Continuously being ready to take over control vs controlling is a huge leap already.
- csours 6y agoI think a lot of people would use and enjoy level 3, but some people would have a real bad time.
- mynameisvlad 6y agoRight, so why do you think consumers wouldn't want level 3 if you think a lot of people would use and enjoy it? I definitely agree it won't be perfect, some people would indeed have a real bad time, but that still doesn't mean an improvement over the current status quo wouldn't be a seller. Perfect is the enemy of good, after all. Current level 1 and 2 systems wouldn't have been nearly as popular as they are if consumers didn't want them. Honda wouldn't have made it standard on all their cars, etc.
- wutbrodo 6y agoThe difference is simply non-realtime corner cases. Most of driving is relatively straightforward processing for the human brain. But every once in a while, something weird happens: humans controlling traffic in an unexpected way, something weird happens to the road and a new emergent order arises from communication with the driver, a cop comes to the window and tells you some detail about the way the road is closed. I don't drive much, but I still hit cases like this periodically, especially when driving through the canyons. From the user's perspective it's effectively the equivalent of taking transit, with very occasional non-realtime takeovers. By contrast, L4 can do all the things that don't require a human in the car at all, like cargo or getting to their next pickup.
- Judgmentality 6y agoI've had to explain this aspect of Level 3 to so many people before, and in my experience few people get it. I think there's a bit more nuance to it though. How far it has to predict something into the future is however long it takes for a person to safely take over - let's say 10 seconds. The thing is though, a Level 4 system also has to be able to predict things into the future in terms of erratic drivers and pedestrians - so the problem is surprisingly similar. If you want to know what's really going on with self-driving, talk to the prediction teams at any of the companies. It's pure research, because how can you predict the future? And it's not a hypothetical problem, because pedestrians do weird shit and you need to predict if they're going to walk in front of you 5 seconds from now all the time (at least for urban driving). Humans do this instinctively - we slow down in uncertain situations and are constantly monitoring it for changes. When the robots try to do this, they slow down and then just stop because they can't really guess what's going to happen next. For computers, I'd argue it's roughly equivalent to solving hard AI.
- treis 6y agoThere's gotta be a level 3.5 here. Cars almost always don't require a driver and can safely stop and transfer to a driver when they do.