5 ms·
I think this is completely backward. To a first approximation, Apple only cares about video producers, software developers, publishers, and musicians, in their
by samatman 6y ago
I think this is completely backward.
To a first approximation, Apple only cares about video producers, software developers, publishers, and musicians, in their Mac strategy. In approximately that order.
The only reason developers are on that list, is because XCode is how software gets written for the rest of their platforms; the dominance of Macs as personal workstations for Valley-style development is only a side effect of that.
These users provide a halo for everyone else. A college student might spend an extra $1000 on their laptop because they want to moonlight on some beats, or have a YouTube channel, that sort of thing.
I remember seeing this disconnect when the new Mac Pro was released and many here dismissed it as too expensive. Someone who works in CGI came around to say that, no, $50,000 is a normal amount of money to spend on their workstations and that their company was ecstatic to be able to keep working with macOS.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoYeah, unless you’ve actually priced out business-class setups, the Mac Pro’s pricing seems crazy. I’ve repeatedly found that the “Apple Tax” is at most something like $500: other companies tend to advertise configurations that I wouldn’t buy, and when I tweak them to match my requirements, their price is not notably different from a Mac
- rrmm 6y agoIf you price like for like sure. My issue is usually that I almost never do. I usually fall into needing something akin to a mac mini but slightly bigger. The last mac pro I bought was a dual-G4 model when the gap between the mac pro and lower end models didn't seem so severe. (Although I obviously do not represent a sizeable demographic of the market). For Apple, not catering to every particular consumer whim/need out there is just smart business. But for the consumer, that is just another weakness of the mac ecosystem.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoIf you include the iMacs (e.g. the iMac Pro), I think there aren’t really all that many gaps in the product line, spec or price wise. It’s mostly that you can’t necessarily get the machine you want in the form factor you’d like.
- hakfoo 6y agoThat's sort of a deal-breaker for a lot of use cases. Think of all those small corporate desktops out there which are beefier than a Mac Mini and wired to cheapo VGA-only 19" LCD monitors because finance isn't going to pay to replace a working screen. The iMac form factor is never gonna compete there. And of course the neglected "I just want internal drives or expansion cards" demographic. I;m not sure if the cheese grater design fixes it, but with the trashcan Mac Pro, there were plenty of configurations where the equivalent Dell/HP/Lenovo workstation was one clean self-contained box stuffed with PCI-e cards and SATA/SAS drives, and the Mac Pro was an angry squid of Thunderbolt, USB, and power cables to feed an array of external drives and devices. I understand that their brand is based on seamless design and we-make-the-decisions-for-you presentation, but it feels like there'd be an opportunity for them to use a small-scale clone program as a market research tool. Have it sell the form factors that Apple won't. The long-whined-for xMac. Units with servicable/cleanable designs for embedded markets. A mini-ITX Mac mainboard you can fit into existing kiosk/appliance designs. A rebranded Toughbook running MacOS. Something in a huge rackmount/server cube case that you can fit with a dozen internal drives. Frankly, I'd envision it as a wholly-owned operation, that charges over-the-odds prices. If people are still willing to put their money where their mouth is, they can claim epiphany and make an Apple version of the same design. If not, they can declare the business a failure, shutter it in a year, and start over next time they want to trial a product.
- rrmm 6y agoI dunno I guess I've been around a lot of people who fall in the middle, that's a place that Apple doesn't cater to. By the middle I mean, small studios (one or a few people). Their high-end stuff certainly caters to higher-end professional markets. What's more the way they've handled their software (Logic, transition to FC X) doesn't seem like professional users are foremost on their mind.
- whywhywhywhy 6y ago>Someone who works in CGI came around to say that, no, $50,000 is a normal amount of money to spend on their workstations You'd still be crazy to spend it on a Mac Pro unless you had very specific MacOS needs. Building a threadripper multi-Nvidia GPU PC is going to outperform it in any meaningful way with a modern CGI workflow. OS starts to matter very little when it's a choice of seeing almost a finished image in almost real time which is what you get with CUDA backed rendering engines VS having to still chug away on CPU.
- lproven 6y agoI submit that it's not just about performance. Both Linux and Windows still take a _lot_ more maintenance than macOS. If you have a room full of creative video artists, who are not techies, then you want them to have maximum productive up-time. You do not want to have to employ a small army of system support techies to keep those boxes running. I used to work on a PC magazine in the West End of London. The mag was about Windows PCs, and was written on Windows PCs, but it was laid out on Macs. I supported both, and the servers and the network. The PC side of things needed more than 10x as much support. That's not materially different even today. Secondly, it's not just about the boxes and their OS. It's also about the apps. A lovely fast sleek Linux distro is no use at all if it doesn't run the apps you need... and if those apps only run on one vendor's kit, or even just run best on that vendor's kit, then that is the kit you buy.
- rrmm 6y agoI can believe that. What sort of support did the non-mac systems mainly need compared to the mac systems?
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoI get that but it is about performance when we reach the magnitudes GPU rendering is over CPU rendering. This isn't 20% faster, it's the difference between seeing the image in almost finished form and interacting with it with real time responsiveness vs having to wait minutes for an image. [1] [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gf_P1G_wbK8&t=0m33s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gf_P1G_wbK8&t=0m33s