6 ms·
Unfortunately, like all such descriptions, this one misses the mark also. I've never heard a good explanation for what a photon "is", or any particle for that
by jiggawatts 6y ago
Unfortunately, like all such descriptions, this one misses the mark also.
I've never heard a good explanation for what a photon "is", or any particle for that matter. That's because physicists don't know either.
No, seriously. Ask a randomly selected set of physicists about any core concept in Quantum Mechanics and you'll discover that their answers diverge wildly. Ref: https://arxiv.org/abs/1301.1069 https://arxiv.org/abs/1301.1069
Basic things like: "Are the photons quantised or is it just the photon interaction with atomic orbitals that's quantised?" I've personally asked this question and had working physicists confidently state that either the former or latter is true, and the other is false.
(PS: Compare this to biologists, chemists, or engineers. They all 100% agree on all core concepts. So do astronomers, and physicists studying classical mechanics and relativity. It's only quantum mechanics that's so fragmented.)
Ask any working QM researcher to clearly show how "a single photon" interacts with an electron in an orbital and they will without a doubt draw you a cartoon diagram. Never in the history of theoretical physics has anyone, ever, anywhere made a numerical visualisation of this. This is because both the QM mental model and the mathematical theory applies only to ensembles in potential wells.
This is a very narrow scope of applicability that was explicitly called out in the QM papers back in the early 1900s, but is now glossed over. People assume that what applies to a special case is the hard rule that applies to all things. It doesn't. There are no photons in free space. There are no little hard particles of light. You can't have a point with a wavelength. You can't have a single pure frequency with a finite duration. This is all gibberish, it's just a simplification to make the maths tractable when done with pencil and paper for special cases! The output of this simplified model is a 0-dimensional scalar. It can't do output much else, such a simulation of a full 3D interaction of any type.
Trying to work backwards from such an oversimplified model in order to explain the deep nature of reality is futile. This is like pointing at the bandwidth measurement in Windows Task Manager and saying "we can understand how the Internet works by watching this number go up and down".
- mhh__ 6y ago> I've never heard a good explanation for what a photon "is", or any particle for that matter. That's because physicists don't know either. The aim of many/most physicists is to predict rather than to know. Biologists, Chemists, Engineers can agree all they want but their theories aren't tested to 5-sigma (I'm sure some are but that's not as good of a metaphor). We have extremely accurate and predictive models of how photons behave (Quantum Field Theory not solely Quantum Mechanics). You're arguably right, we don't really know - however, we can only know what we can see with our eyes. There may be some all-encompassing structure hiding at any energy level we haven't yet reached but the explanation given is as good as it gets in terms of explainable what we have observed in nature. As to Quantum Mechanics, the only place you'll find Physicists disagreeing about the "core concepts" is on the absolute fringes of what can be considered science. You will find Physicists arguing about the interpretation of those concepts but it's not like they don't work. As to that interpretation, there is disagreement but I think it is fair to say that very few physicists actually think about it - i.e. "Shut up and calculate" is a common outlook.
- madhadron 6y ago> PS: Compare this to biologists, chemists, or engineers. They all 100% agree on all core concepts. Biologists certainly don't. What is a species? Is Linnean taxonomy useful or merely confusing and obsolete? What is a gene? > I've never heard a good explanation for what a photon "is", or any particle for that matter. What would such an explanation look like, and why do you think that there is such an explanation? In many cases when people ask what something "is", they want a category defined in terms of categories they are already familiar with. We can build up a set of observations and build a formal model to summarize them whose terms we can map to the results of various observations. We name the various parts of our formal model for convenience. But there is no requirement that the model be able to satisfy queries that depend on things that don't exist in the domain of the model. > Basic things like: "Are the photons quantised or is it just the photon interaction with atomic orbitals that's quantised?" I've personally asked this question and had working physicists confidently state that either the former or latter is true, and the other is false. Sure, because you're not asking a question about anything observable, so it's a question of how people put names on the various internal parts of their model. It doesn't matter if people agree on that, because when anyone sits down to actually use the formal model to model something, vague naming of internal parts of it is irrelevant. So I think the right answer is: stop looking at the photon! There's a charged thing wiggling somewhere, and the interaction between two charged things that wiggle is quantized. If I have an electron at one point making small oscillations and another electron at another point, I can calculate the transition probability of the first electron oscillating with one less quantum and the second one oscaillating with one more, or vice versa.
- jiggawatts 6y ago> Biologists certainly don't. What is a species? Is Linnean taxonomy useful or merely confusing and obsolete? What is a gene? These are human definitions for classifications, and biologists agree on that. However, if you make a statement that "two groups of animals that can never reproduce successfully with each other are separate species" then nobody will argue that. Similarly, nobody argues about what the mechanism is for species reproduction success or failure. Everyone knows how chromosomes and DNA works. There's no debate. Every chemist uses the same periodic table with the same elements. Etc... > What would such an explanation look like Equations that can be evaluated numerically that shows the behaviour of the EM field, in 4D spacetime, capable of demonstrating interactions with charged particles. That's all. That's not asking much. > why do you think that there is such an explanation? Because it's a thing that happens. There are atoms that have electrons that electromagnetically interact with light and change orbits. Quantum Mechanics provides a highly simplified model of this in a very narrow use-case. That's not wrong, or mathematically invalid. But it's not the whole picture, and isn't a valid source from which to answer questions like "what is a photon". That's not describing the nature of light in the real physical world, it describes the nature of an abstraction in a simplified model. The photon exists in the equations. That's why it's so hard to visualise and "pin down" with a simple description. It's a property of the model, not the world. > We can build up a set of observations and build a formal model to summarize them whose terms we can map to the results of various observations. The models in this case are tiny subsets of all physical behaviour and generally only cover certain categories of scalar observables. E.g.: "The detector went off or not". Hence the cartoon diagrams and focus on the observables covered by the model. > But there is no requirement that the model be able to satisfy queries that depend on things that don't exist in the domain of the model. I agree. But photons are a thing that exist in the model. What I'm saying is that the photons exist only in the model. > Sure, because you're not asking a question about anything observable See, you made the same mistake as everyone else! Atoms aren't the only things that exist! There are free particles in vacuum chambers, particle accelerators, outer space, etc... that aren't atoms. There's a device called a "free electron laser" that has a continuously adjustable output frequency! > There's a charged thing wiggling somewhere, and the interaction between two charged things that wiggle is quantized. Only if they're in potential wells. Even then it's not entirely clear if all interactions are quantised. > I can calculate the transition probability That output is a scalar. The electron is in an orbital though, right? With a defined angular momentum, position in space, and everything. Even if you abandon the concept of point particles, it has a bunch of properties. Now show me all of those properties changing as it absorbs the photon. Classic QM can't, because it doesn't even try. It focuses on the narrow case of "near resonance" light and then handwaves over how the photons actually change their orbitals. Cartoon diagrams and statistics. That's fine if you're designing a laser or something, but that's not what is physically happening with a single electron around a single atom.
- knzhou 6y agoI mean, that's because the language of physics is mathematics. If you ask vague questions with inherently undefined terms, you shouldn't be surprised if you get different answers! I bet chefs wouldn't agree on whether a taco is a sandwich, either, but that doesn't mean they don't know what they're doing. Furthermore, as someone with a lot of experience thinking about photons in many different limiting cases, your objections don't make sense to me, because in general, absolute statements like "There are no X" in physics don't make sense. For almost any value of X, X can be a useful way of thinking in some limit or other, and whether or not you want to invoke X depends on the calculation you're doing. When you say there is no X and everybody who thinks otherwise is wrong, you're just inviting a debate over semantics, which we physicists are naturally not interested in.
- jiggawatts 6y ago> I mean, that's because the language of physics is mathematics. But it is not a study of it! Mathematics is a tool, not the thing being studied. This is lost on some people. There are properties of the real world that are studied, and there are properties of the mathematical models that are used. They are not interchangeable. Similarly, saying that the "this specific mathematics is all there is, just understand that" when a simple verbal statement can be made that is not covered by the mathematical model doesn't mean that the statement is somehow invalid, it means the model is incomplete or narrow in scope. There is this downright perverse notion in QM that the models are what reality is. If the model can't answer something, then the question is meaningless, etc... Meanwhile the model has assumptions and simplifications such as linearisation, no GR or even no SR, and so forth. My point is simply this: The mathematics of QM is not equipped to answer fundamental questions like "what is a particle" or "what is a photon". > whether or not you want to invoke X depends on the calculation you're doing. I'm not debating that the simplified models aren't useful, widely applicable, numerically useful, make predictions, etc... I'm simply stating that physical reality behaves in single, definite way.
- madhadron 6y ago> Similarly, saying that the "this specific mathematics is all there is, just understand that" when a simple verbal statement can be made that is not covered by the mathematical model doesn't mean that the statement is somehow invalid, it means the model is incomplete or narrow in scope. Not necessarily. It may mean that the verbal statement invokes a language game to define a category that has rules incompatible with the rules of the formal model. > My point is simply this: The mathematics of QM is not equipped to answer fundamental questions like "what is a particle" or "what is a photon". Sure it is. A particle in QM is something that obeys the formal structure laid out. Dijkstra had some very biting things to say about being unable to cope with true novelty because you're trapped in reasoning by analogy (EWD1036).
- Ono-Sendai 6y ago> Ask any working QM researcher to clearly show how "a single photon" interacts with an electron in an orbital and they will without a doubt draw you a cartoon diagram. Never in the history of theoretical physics has anyone, ever, anywhere made a numerical visualisation of this. I personally have made a simulation of this. It would be called a semi-classical approximation, in that it's a simulation of a Schrodinger equation-described electron in a hydrogen (Coulomb) potential interacting with a classical EM wave. However I suspect that's how nature works anyway.
- jiggawatts 6y agoI'd love to see the video of this, or even a still picture. If you have some time, please upload it to YouTube or something, because it would be the only such video on there. It would have significant educational value.
- Ono-Sendai 6y agoOk yeah I'll dig up the code and capture a video of it. I'm currently working on a Dirac equation simulation which should give a more accurate picture of an electron.
- eigenspace 6y ago> However I suspect that's how nature works anyway. Uh, could you clarify what you mean here? Are you saying you don't beleive that the electromagnetic field is quantized?
- Ono-Sendai 6y agoYeah pretty much. (I say this not from a position of profound knowledge or anything like that, just that I'm not familiar with a good argument for why it is, not that I have looked into it in great detail. My knowledge of QFT is very basic)
- eigenspace 6y ago
- hpcjoe 6y ago> There are no photons in free space. Um ... I'd suggest rewording that, as this wording is incorrect. Cosmic background photons would likely want to have a word with you on this as well. It is true that what a photon is in a physical sense is poorly understood (double slit experiment, etc.). The goal of physics is to try to narrow this range, so that we understand more, and have a smaller null space of "here be dragons and photons" that we don't quite grasp. If you can accept analogies, it would be reasonable to assume that photons are the free space analogs of phonons. Phonons are excitons of an underlying system, with stress/strain tensors. Phonons interact with physical particles, scattering them. Phonon-like things are responsible for Cooper pair formation (effectively a Bose Einstein condensate of two electrons which are fermions, into a pair of fermions with net integer spin). Cooper pairs are responsible for superconductivity. I am not sure if phonons (which I believe are bosons) would be considered particles mediatiating interactions in solids, but I am guessing a good/strong case could be made, along those lines. The analogy may be apt. But the question that immediately arises is, given that phonons are excitons of an underlying material, is there something analogous for electromagnetic waves? Up to the very early 1900's, they called this thing the "aether". Transverse waves (oscillating perpendicular to velocity vector of travel) of phonons are called optical modes. Longitudinal waves (think like sound waves, compression and rarefaction) are called acoustic. I don't know if we have a longitudinal equivalent in photons. There are many questions remaining. We don't completely understand QM, up to, and including if QM is the right theory. These questions and tests are good. The more questions a theory answers correctly, the less likely it is to be incorrect. As Feynman noted, you only need one conclusive irrefutable result running at odds with a theory to render the theory defunct. Even with that said, some "wrong" theories (like the "law" of Newtonian gravity) are immensely useful in practical matters, as long as you pay particularly careful attention to range of applicability. Feel happy you don't normally need to pull out full 10-D general relativity to go to the moon. Newtonian mechanics plus corrections works well enough (for now). This will change the farther we want to go. This all said, there are many open questions in physics, including numerous things that you hear about every day. Anyone claiming, ever, in any field, that the "science is settled" is either not a scientist, a poor scientist, or someone with an agenda. Science is never settled. Good science is looking at data late at night in your office when you should be home with your family, and saying "hmmm, that's funny ..." (recovering computational theoretical physicist here, who used to quantum mechanically simulate semiconductors on supercomputers ... quite inception-movie like)