5 ms·
I think it's a reasonable solution at the margins as long as the situtation in countries like Venezuela is as bad as it is. I don't think many people dispute th
by Barrin92 6y ago
I think it's a reasonable solution at the margins as long as the situtation in countries like Venezuela is as bad as it is. I don't think many people dispute that.
But as a solution for the institutional failures it still is not a replacement and obviously the solution in Venezuela needs to be repairing the system.
Same with Sci-Hub in this case. The Bitcoin donations alleviate financial pressure somewhat, but of course the lawsuits and IP-infringement will still haunt everyone involved.
- cinquemb 6y ago> I think it's a reasonable solution at the margins Reasonable solutions at the margins tend to be adapted in some major way by the masses in time, like bottleneck microstates can end up driving steady state long term behaviors of systems in glassy dynamics… technical solutions to make lawsuits and IP-infrignment have no teeth are being adopted more everyday but not as fast as some would like.
- mariuolo 6y ago> the lawsuits and IP-infringement will still haunt everyone involved. I suspect donations are used mostly to keep the lights on.
- lend000 6y agoThe point that you're missing is that there will always be Venezuelas and Zimbabwes, and Bitcoin, in its current form, serves as a baseline financial system that unfortunate citizens of failing states can fall back on. It has plenty of issues when it comes to buying coffee and small transactions, but perfect is the enemy of good and it has properties that make it much harder to censor than USD based services, which will just comply with the state.
- andai 6y agoI often hear the argument that BitCoin is unsuitable for small transactions. That's certainly the case (at least in recent years). What I don't understand is why people don't then just use one of the literally thousands of other currencies -- most of which handle small transactions just fine. For small transfers I use DogeCoin and the fee is 0.2 cents.
- spurdoman77 6y agoBitcoin for me is a "savings account". The tx fee is certainly important, but more important is the long term value appreciation. I have changed btc to other cryptos to spend them, so I pay less fees, but Im not holding other cryptos long term.
- bouncycastle 6y agoa savings account that loses 50% of its value in a matter of days? If anything, the crash last March has proven that BTC is not a safe asset and not immune from a global financial meltdown. Other way around - its very sensitive to it actually.
- ric2b 6y agoIt's very volatile but usually you don't touch a savings account regularly so it doesn't matter what it does day to day, only long term.
- bouncycastle 6y agoIt seems like the whole meaning of "savings account" has been lost in one generation.. In the old days, the very point of a savings account is that it keeps the value stable, and pays interest on top. The more long term you save, the higher the interest. Compounded.
- onefuncman 6y agoYeah, that whole thing doesn't exist for my generation. We've never had savings accounts that beat inflation in our lifetime.
- lern_too_spel 6y agoSavings accounts aren't meant to beat inflation.
- DarkWiiPlayer 6y agoThis sort of "Once we've made everything perfect" reasoning doesn't really reflect reality all that much though; the point is that centralized systems will always be vulnerable to these problems; even if we temporarily fix them, that'll be an exception and sooner or later the systems will fall back into their broken state. From that premise that the probem is universal, the deduction that the solution is also not just a temporary fix seems like the only reasonably conclusiont to me. I'm not completely sure whether you're arguing that the bitcoin hype will pass once we've sorted out a few problems, or just that it'd be a nicer world if that could ever be the case; but either way, I don't think cryptocurrencies should be a last resort but instead become the norm. Offense is the best defense, after all.
- Super_Jambo 6y agoI would argue that centralization is inherent in most humans instincts. To put it another way, many people like having a leader. In fact people like leaders so much that exposed to a capricious and cruel world they'll invent imaginary and often cruel ones just to give the world a sense of order. Think the old testament God or lizard people conspiracy theories. Given we're going to huge groups of people running around following leaders I think our best effort is spent trying to make the selection of those leaders pick non-evil people who run vaguely meritocratic and fair systems. Rather than trying to engineer ideal de-centralized systems _which will also have to be robust against the mob following their evil leaders. Obviously this is a false dichotomy and we can do both, but please don't give up on good leadership, people need it and there's plenty of examples of it exiting.
- danwills 6y agoThis causes such a problem with governance though: Instead of voting for (or contributing to) ideas/policies directly, you have to translate your preference into a selection/ranking of the people who sound like they might support the ideas that you would like to see in your democracy. Sounds like a pretty crappy codec for that kind of signal tbh.
- zimbatm 6y agoI would go even further in your argument and say that the escape-hatches are a requirement to keep the centralized system in check. This is a bit like the free market argument in the sense that it creates competition.
- mbdesign 6y agoAlso consider using a stable coin like DAI, USDC etc if your use case is to mimick somewhat of a bank account without crazy volatility.
- Siira 6y agoThey’re a scam. They have no real reserve.
- loriverkutya 6y ago> But as a solution for the institutional failures it still is not a replacement and obviously the solution in Venezuela needs to be repairing the system. The point you seems to be missing, that the system cannot be repaired in a day and people need to eat, while they doing the repair.
- arcticbull 6y agoIt doesn't address the problem of Venezuela at scale: the initial distribution problem. If you trade BTC for Bolivars between people in Venezuela then the total number of Bolivars, hence welfare within the system, remains unchanged. If you trade Bolivars for things outside, you can trade outside the country, and are better off with literally anything you can get outside the country. I don't doubt for a small handful of people who got their hands on some BTC they individually are better off. That doesn't change the fact it's not a reasonable solution at scale.
- exo762 6y ago> But as a solution for the institutional failures it still is not a replacement I don't think one can call PayPal an institution. As for an ability to transact - I don't see why shouldn't we replace institutions that prevent us from transacting. Failing business models of Elsevier and likes are a problem of their shareholders. I, personally, want them crushed.