2 ms·
It would be interesting to see stats from the CAs about which of the Blessed Methods is most popular. (This article is about Let's Encrypt using tls-alpn-01 whi
by tialaramex 6y ago
It would be interesting to see stats from the CAs about which of the Blessed Methods is most popular. (This article is about Let's Encrypt using tls-alpn-01 which is an implementation of 3.2.2.4.10 "TLS Using a Random Number"). Doubtless Fly aren't the only people doing tls-alpn-01 in bulk but we don't have a good overview as far as I'm aware.
In principle they can all generate those statistics because they (are supposed to) log enough information to identify what went wrong when, inevitably, something is misissued. Logically that also includes at least which method was used to verify domain authorization or control.
One of the things wrong at Symantec is that it turns out some of the records were notionally kept at CrossCert, a separate Korean company. CrossCert simply did not keep any records (or if it did they were in such disarray that it seemed less likely to attract retribution by refusing to disclose them) and Symantec had seemingly never checked.
Knowing which methods are popular with Subscribers, and whether that varies considerably between CAs would be valuable in trying to figure out how more of the worst Blessed Methods can be deprecated or improved, and who we need to be talking to about that.
For example maybe Let's Encrypt is doing almost all the 3.2.2.4.19 ("Agreed Upon Change to Website - ACME") then there's no point ragging on other CAs for the shortcomings of relying on plaintext HTTP in this method. Or maybe DigiCert are doing a lot of 3.2.2.4.15 ("Phone Contact with Domain Contact") so they are the people to talk through any proposed improvements around stuff like leaving a Voice mail.