4 ms·
That was a great reply. A couple of nits: I believe the queen can technically veto any bill from Parliament and can also appoint the Prime Minister.
by tomcam 6y ago
That was a great reply. A couple of nits: I believe the queen can technically veto any bill from Parliament and can also appoint the Prime Minister.
- twic 6y agoDecline to sign rather than veto as such. Those are indeed formal powers the crown has, but in practice, they are used strictly in accordance with convention, rather than at the queen's discretion. The crown is a sort of legal machine which operates through the physical body of whoever the monarch happens to be at the time. It would be much better if all that was properly set down in law, but in practice, it works smoothly enough that nobody has bothered. Except in Australia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1975_Australian_constitutional_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1975_Australian_constitutional...
- mcv 6y agoIn 1990, the Belgian parliament declared the king "unable to govern" for day because his conscience didn't allow him to sign a law. So Belgium was a republic for a day, the government signed the law in absense of a king, and the next day the parliament voted to declare the king fit to govern again, and everybody was happy.
- phaemon 6y ago"That was a great reply". Yup, sure, that's what your average HN punter would say to some halfwit BritNat propaganda. Well done on blending in.
- tomcam 6y agoI appreciate your constructive input. What was inaccurate about the parent comment? P.S. I resent being called an average HN punter. I am definitely a below-average HN punter.
- phaemon 6y agoEvery single sentence of it is wrong or misleading. First sentence, "There are no laws, rules, or taxes which apply everywhere else in the UK which don't apply in the City." Yeah, there are laws which apply to the Corporation of the City of London which don't apply elsewhere. That's the point. Second sentence, that the Queen is a "purely ceremonial figure", again, utter crap. The house of Windsor (née Saxe-Coburg and Gotha) is one of the richest, most powerful and influential entities on the planet. Etc etc...I can't be bothered with a Gish Gallop. It's all crap. Look it up for yourself.
- twic 6y ago> Every single sentence of it is wrong or misleading. First sentence, "There are no laws, rules, or taxes which apply everywhere else in the UK which don't apply in the City." Yeah, there are laws which apply to the Corporation of the City of London which don't apply elsewhere. That's the point. Would you like to try reading the sentence which i wrote, and you quoted, again, squire? I agree with you that people should look all this up for themselves, though!
- phaemon 6y agoNo, because I got it and pointed out why it was misleading. Try reading my comment again and understanding it.
- aryehof 6y agoIn the United Kingdom, "Parliament is supreme, and cannot be bound by previous Parliaments". The Queen and her ceremonial roles and duties exist because it is the will of the people. Those can be removed by an Act of Parliament. The people through their representatives in Parliament rule the United Kingdom.