3 ms·
> Strike Russia, who has many more nuclear warheads, and stronger anti-nuclear protection? Yes, what's use of a superweapon if you can't make use of it? From
by baybal2 6y ago
> Strike Russia, who has many more nuclear warheads, and stronger anti-nuclear protection?
Yes, what's use of a superweapon if you can't make use of it?
From my childhood experience, some times you need to commit without reservations to completely hopeless, no chance fights, as the only hope for a way out. Strong adversaries often don't expect the weak to even attempt to fight back.
- schoen 6y agoThere is a whole major plot in one of the Three-Body Problem books about this issue. It arises in maybe a kind of contrived way, but then it's explicitly posed in more or less the way you said.
- dragandj 6y agoThe point is that the results of using it would be: - would the weapons be neutralized in most or all cases by Russia before it reaches the targets? Perhaps yes? I don't know much about that sort of thing. - it would give a carte blanche to Russia to wipe out Ukraine, which it has the means to do if it comes to total war. That's why I'm skeptical that nuclear weapons bring more benefits than trouble for smaller players.
- pvaldes 6y ago> it would give a carte blanche to Russia to wipe out Ukraine But the final result would be the same as Russia deliberately bombing themselves and amputating a big chunk of their own country forever. The radioactivity would not stop in the Ukranian frontier. All nuclear weapons are boomerangs