3 ms·
> the display is nice even tho its only 1080p This is absolutely crazy why are we still putting screens into laptops that would be disappointing on a CRT from
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> the display is nice even tho its only 1080p
This is absolutely crazy why are we still putting screens into laptops that would be disappointing on a CRT from the year 2000? How can you work with just a thousand lines?
- gowld 6y ago>1080p was quite rate in the CRT era. https://www.lifewire.com/crt-computer-monitor-buyers-guide-833080 https://www.lifewire.com/crt-computer-monitor-buyers-guide-8...
- bashinator 6y ago1600x1200 is only about 10% fewer pixels than 1920x1082. The former was quite common twenty years ago.
- wmf 6y ago1600x1200 was for a 20" CRT; why does he want the same or higher resolution on a 15" laptop?
- chrismorgan 6y agoAt a given resolution, CRTs pixels made for much more readable text (provided the refresh rate was sufficient; I found 60Hz nigh unbearable, 90Hz tolerable, and 120Hz preferable). LCD pixels are much more precise, which means that they appear much less smooth, so that you want a much higher resolution. CRT pixels were fundamentally imprecise, and that was actually really good for text. It’s about a decade since I last used a CRT, but my feeling is that text would look better (be smoother and more legible) on your 1600×1200 20″ CRT (100dpi) than on a 1920×1080 15″ LCD (141dpi). I think that the last CRT I dealt with much felt fairly similar in legibility &c. to my first laptop, and those were 1280×1024 19″ at 120Hz (~86dpi) and 1680×1050 15.4″ (~128dpi).
- chrisseaton 6y agoThat exact resolution? Yes I guess so. But XGA (768 lines) was the most common in 2002 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Display_resolution#2000s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Display_resolution#2000s. WUXGA (1200 lines) was also very common. Why haven't we progressed more than a couple hundred lines in 20 years? What's going on?
- boudin 6y agoBecause it's not that needed? I'm fine with 1080p on my laptop, i don't feel the need for 4k.
- freehunter 6y agoI have no idea what makes chrisseaton so passionate and adamant that CRTs commonly had resolutions higher than common LCD panels today but I had basically this exact same argument several days ago. I actually remembered it because they wrote almost the same comment word for word. For some reason they are convinced that all old CRTs were commonly 2k and 4K resolutions and the existence of cheap 4k LCD panels doesn’t excuse the fact that it’s still possible to buy a 1080p screen (which is I guess a bad thing?) Some people have unusual passions I guess.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thekyle 6y agoNot sure if this is sarcasm or not, but, I think 1080p is a totally reasonable resolution for a laptop. I have a 4k display on my laptop and it's way overkill. I've had it for a few years now and regret spending the extra money on it. I'd rather spend less money getting the 1080p option and have longer battery life.
- chrisseaton 6y agoDo you not find text (which is mostly what I use my display for as a programmer and author) is extremely blocky and blurry at this resolution?
- beckingz 6y agoNope. 1080p has enough pixels to display most text nicely.
- rpdillon 6y agoNo. I specifically buy laptops with 1080p displays and avoid hidpi if possible due to compatibility with various apps, as well as power consumption/battery life issues. I have a hidpi MacBook for work and a 1080p System76 machine for personal use, and I vastly prefer the System76 machine. I accept that others see it differently, but I have this lingering suspicion that the whole hidpi movement is mostly marketing. Most folks simply don't need it, or even really benefit from it, as far as I've been able to tell.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thesandlord 6y agoA 27 inch 1440p monitor has a PPI of ~108. These are what all high end consumer displays like the Apple Cinema displays, Dell U2711s, etc had before they all moved to 4K. A 27 inch at 4k has a PPI of ~163. This is basically industry standard for high end consumer displays. Sure there are a few 5K screens, but they are not common. I've also seen a lot of folks use 32 inch 4k displays which would have even lower PPI. A 15 inch 1080p screen has a PPI of ~146. So not as good as a 4K screen at 27 inches, but still MUCH higher than the 1440p monitors.
- slantyyz 6y ago> How can you work with just a thousand lines? The answer is super simple. Because I'm not you. Which means I'm not sensitized to the same things that you are sensitized to. For example, I can't stand working in a room that is not brightly lit, which isn't a problem at all for most other people.