4 ms·
Why is that a ridiculous system? The risk of someone illegally residing in a country is different by nationality. The chance of a Canadian illegally staying i
by refurb 6y ago
Why is that a ridiculous system?
The risk of someone illegally residing in a country is different by nationality.
The chance of a Canadian illegally staying in the US is super low. The chance of someone from Haiti is high.
Why wouldn’t there be different requirements?
- scoopdewoop 6y agoIt might seem ridiculous to section off the entire world with armed guards and determine who can go where based on the lottery of birth.
- kube-system 6y agoMost countries are not asking about nationality at their borders because they care about nationality, but because they care about other factors which correlate with nationality and are much harder to measure.
- centimeter 6y agoSure, if you have a completely myopic understanding of the practical realities of immigration.
- refurb 6y agoIt's impossible for a country to be sovereign and at the same time not have control over who enters or leaves a country. So yeah, if you want to get rid of the very idea of countries, it could work...maybe.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThat is asserted often but I doubt the truth. Argentinia constitutionally considers migration a human right. They are a minority and not the most prosperous example of a country but they certainly aren't exceptionally worse off even if they wound up with the awkward combination of an overrepresentation of both infamously Nazi refugees and lesser known refugees fleeing from the Nazis historically.
- refurb 6y agoIf I was from India, I'd need a visa to travel to Argentina. Not a great example.
- elliekelly 6y agoSo most of Europe isn’t sovereign then?
- refurb 6y agoCan anyone in the world just walk into the EU? No.
- ajconway 6y agoEntry regulations are fine, every nation has the right to decide who they want to see on their land. However, being treated differently based not on your personality or track record, but on where you hail from is... I don't know, but seems to be somewhat similar to what the current protests are about. I guess there is no solution to that. You are right that a member of a nation (or a community) where people often cause trouble mathematically more likely to break laws. I guess it would be unwise to use this to minimize the risk to your citizens.
- refurb 6y agoI guess there is no solution to that. That's kind of what Global Entry is. If you're willing to give up your privacy and have the gov't examine your profile as an individual, you can avoid be screened based on nationality alone.
- ajconway 6y agoIt’s a solution for a person who really wants in. I’m just saying that when you think about it, it feels weird — privileges literally depend on the “color” of one’s passport. Must be inherent to our civilization.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- emilecantin 6y agoBecause it's super-racist. Yes, what you say might be statistically true. However, in this specific case we're talking about 2 people that live and travel together, and have done so for years. They met while studying in the US. Just because one of them is from Haiti doesn't fundamentally change the situation, they're each as likely to try and stay illegally as the other (which is not much). The system is based on where you're from, but it really should be based on where you're going (in life in general, I mean).
- heneudjsns 6y agoYes discrimination by nationality is statistically true but immoral but discrimination by economic circumstance is statistically true but moral. Self interest seep into your moral compass all the time or just when convenient?