3 ms·
So Americans love nothing more than to see the world as a collection of slippery slopes so there'll be the Assange defenders who argue this is an attack on pres
by cletus 6y ago
So Americans love nothing more than to see the world as a collection of slippery slopes so there'll be the Assange defenders who argue this is an attack on press freedom but... I urge you to look a little deeper.
There are two major issues here:
1. Assange actively participated in the acquisition of classified material. This came up in the Chelsea Manning. Pointing to tools that can be useful. Prompting action. That sort of thing; and
2. Assange was playing politics. This should've been clear from Assange's actions with respect to the DNC emails.
Think about (1) for a second. Imagine the Attorney General had committed a crime. Proof of that was in a safe in his house. Which of the following is acceptable conduct in obtaining that information?
- Breaking into his house to get it;
- Destroying the safe to get at the contents;
- Holding him at gunpoint to open the safe;
- Holding his family hostage until he provides the information;
- Hiring someone to do any of the above;
- Someone offers the information to you without you knowing how it came to be in their possession;
- Someone notifies you of the information's existence and location. You pay them to acquire it. Or give them a gun. Or threaten them if they don't.
The point of these examples is to show that:
1. There is no absolute defense here and certainly not "journalism". The alternative is robbing banks as an expression of journalistic freedom; and
2. If you commit a crime, you commit a crime and the authorities can prosecute you for that.
The other side of this is recent administrations seem to have adopted a disproportionate response approach to dealing with leaks and whistleblowers, likely as a deterrent (they hope).
- bluesign 6y agoImagine for a second, someone telling you there is proof in safe, you telling them to acquire this proof from this safe (which has access), then this person is caught and later pardoned by potus. Later they come after you. I am not from US, but this kinda doesnt look right.