3 ms·
If I stood on one leg “to exhaustion” — until it hurt too much to continue — a few times, I woke up feeling more rested Wouldn't it be easier to just exercise?
by keiferski 16y ago
If I stood on one leg “to exhaustion” — until it hurt too much to continue — a few times, I woke up feeling more rested
Wouldn't it be easier to just exercise? Regular physical activity leads to better sleep, and doesn't require you to stand on one leg.
- jcl 16y agoWhat he's doing is exercise. He's working a muscle to exhaustion, which is essentially weightlifting without the weights. I guess the value is that he's found a simple workout that gets the results he needs in eight minutes a day with no equipment. It would be interesting to find out if he would get better or worse results through cardio instead of working a muscle to exhaustion, and whether or not it is important that the legs be that muscle. Some people suffer from restless legs syndrome which keeps them from achieving deep sleep, and maybe exercising the legs is countering this. (I wish there was some way he could experiment that wasn't subject to the placebo effect, though, which makes the results moot when applied to anyone else.)
- keiferski 16y agoWell, yeah. It just seems a little strange (and likely less efficient) to do leg raises, when a decent workout of real exercises would be just as easy and more effective. Even if you stick to the legs, exercises like bootstrappers, squats, and lunges would be significantly better.
- peterwwillis 16y ago(see above comment) dynamic exercise is only more effective at increasing muscle twitch force. isometrics will be more effective at increasing strength at joint angle. for example, i could do more squats in a minute (up to 90) after i did isometric holds vs before.
- keiferski 16y agoFair enough. I just didn't get the impression that the OP took an exercise approach to his experiment. It seemed less isometrics and more "I'm gonna stand on one leg until I get tired."
- peterwwillis 16y agoIt's actually a good alternative to regular physical activity. You can do it anywhere for any length of time and it will dramatically increase the load you can withstand at a given angle. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isometric_exercise http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isometric_exercise "While dynamic exercises are slightly better than isometric exercises at enhancing the twitch force of a muscle, isometrics are significantly better than dynamic exercises at increasing maximal strength at the joint angle. Flexibility may be increased when isometrics are performed at joint range of motion extremes. These isometric contractions recruit muscle fibers that are often neglected in some dynamic exercises. For example, gymnasts are extremely strong at great ranges of motion through the practice of isometric holds."