2 ms·
I never understood octaves. Two sounds of different pitch that are supposed to sound "the same" somehow? Obviously if you shift a melody by multiplying every no
by Asooka 6y ago
I never understood octaves. Two sounds of different pitch that are supposed to sound "the same" somehow? Obviously if you shift a melody by multiplying every note by 2 will keep it sounding the same melodically, even though it's immediately obvious it's higher pitched. Beyond that, I have never been able to perceive the "sameness" between equivalent notes on different octaves. When I was younger and played adventure games, sometimes there would be a puzzle involving listening to a short melody and playing it back on some instrument. Literally the only way I could solve those was by analysing the original melody with a spectrometer, then analysing the instrument, and figuring what sequence of keys to press that way.
- tylerrobinson 6y agoI read this yesterday and it really stayed with me, enough to find this comment again. Do two notes an octave apart not sound harmonious in a particular identifiable way to you? From another view, it may help to think about it like this: Tones have a certain relationship with each other, and we split that into octaves in Western music to keep track of them. Just like the number 9 precedes 10, and 19 precedes 20, 10 and 20 are "the same number" in base 10 since that's where the pattern repeates. We could count in another number system, but the underlying physical truth of the numbers would be the same.