4 ms·
That's like saying because everyone else has 'pervasive multithreading', BeOS won even when it was a commercial failure. Everyone else did it better. It's not
by rvz 6y ago
That's like saying because everyone else has 'pervasive multithreading', BeOS won even when it was a commercial failure.
Everyone else did it better. It's not about who invented it first, its about innovating over other inventions.
Symbian still failed commercially in the market and couldn't compete or innovate with the other competitors.
- edent 6y agoYes, that's exactly what I'm saying. In the marketplace of ideas, both Symbian and BeOS eventually won the argument. They didn't win commercially.
- braythwayt 6y agoI make a similar argument when I say that “CoffeeScript was merged to main.” Yes, JavaScript 2015 won... By adopting all of the ideas that CoffeeScript made mainstream for front-end web development. I realize this is a philosophical distinction, but it really does come down to whether you are attached to the fundamental characteristic of a thing, or the label/name/brand of the thing. Financially, the brand matters. If Uber fails commercially, but ushers in an age of gig economy transportation, the idea won but the brand did not. As an investor or employee, you care deeply about the brand. But as someone trying to change the world, you care deeply about the idea coming to pass by any means necessary. Sutherland did not get rich. But do we say he lost because “The Mother of All Demos” was not an Apple II or Macintosh?
- gravitas 6y agoIn this era I was into mobile phonery (is that a word?) and in 2006 the Nokia e50 (Symbian 9.1) was such a great phone, it went to many countries that year and I just loved it (it was maybe my 3rd Symbian). Not as a developer but an end user hacker lite, all the flexibility it offered over other choices at the time (most devices were "dumb"). Until the end of 2006 when T-Mobile (US) introduced the BlackBerry Pearl; it was at that point Symbian/S60 died in my life when I realized how limited it was and what it could have been, haven't touched one since (the Pearl being eclipsed by the first Androids after that in 2008). They had a shot and a solid following on HowardForums and just sort of blew it and let the competition outrun them.
- bulka 6y ago"Everyone else did it better" - by some very loose definition of "better" maybe. Author is agreeing that Symbian failed for good reasons at the very end of a very short blog post.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoIf the 'winners' have to adopt your ideas, you've won. At least if your ideas where more important to you than 'winning'
- mola 6y agoThey innovated away privacy and security by relying on the human poor ability of impulse control and hardship with delayed gratification. Basically they made everything shiny and addictive. Is that really innovative? Perhaps 'bad' ui is better when you consider higher order consequences as opposed to concentrating only on first order popularity contest? I'm not saying Nokia and symbian were better BTW. Just noting how our contemporary value system where, "it makes money"="it's good" is short sighted at times.
- kanox 6y agoThis is a ridiculously shallow dismisal. Android and iOS "won" because the phones were vastly more capable.
- mola 6y agoDismissal of what? I'm not saying symbian was a better os. I'm saying sometimes innovation and commercial success are not indicators of better solutions. And sometimes moving fast and breaking/distrupting things, is not a good thing.
- secondcoming 6y agoExcept they weren't. At the time, the US had really crap phones compared to Europe (which itself was behind Japan). The Nokia N95 could do everything. The original iPhone was pretty much laughed at by Nokia insiders because it lacked so many features. It turns out most users didn't care about most of these (MMS, DTV, Bluetooth)
- jbverschoor 6y agoExcept that they didn’t have a proper browser. People tend to forget that you had a desktop quality browser in the first iPhone.
- secondcoming 6y agoOpera was available for it
- dfox 6y agoIt is only tangentially related, but Symbian in fact had even more pervasive multithreading than even BeOS. IIRC "correctly behaving" EPOC/Symbian GUI application was supposed to have at least three threads (UI and application logic in separate threads and additional "housekeeping" thread).
- jbverschoor 6y agoBeOS had a thread for each BWindow. So 5 browser windows is 5 threads for the windows and 1 for the BApplication.
- juliend2 6y agoI'm currently reading The Infinite Game by Simon Sinek, and he talks about exactly that: is your game finite or infinite? If infinite (like any business), there is no "winning" in that kind of "game" because there are so many standards by which one could say he beats the competition (win): is it market share, cashflow, valuation, innovation?... Symbian was probably right about how it was handling of security, but it "lost" by disappearing from the game.