8 ms·
Tesla lags auto industry in quality, finds new J.D. Power study
- tomalpha 6y ago> Tesla isn’t officially part of the study because it doesn’t allow J.D. Power access to customer vehicle registration data. Interesting quote. Does that mean if I buy a non-Tesla car in the US, that my personal details automatically get passed on? I'm not always a Tesla fan, and you could always claim this is because 'they have something to hide', but I very much like the sound of it from a privacy perspective.
- ponker 6y agoThere’s a company called RL Polk that Hoovers up basically everything you could imagine about car sales and resells that information for very high prices. Don’t know where they get their data but they have a row of data for each car sold.
- dillonmckay 6y agoI would guess vehicle registrations is where they are obtaining the data from.
- dotnetdev6 6y agoMy company Cross-Sell Reports does the same thing. We buy the registration data from each state. But it's a job to secure contracts from each states DMV. Sort of like securing licensing from nba or mlb teams.
- jeegsy 6y agoIs the government allowed to sell that data?
- dotnetdev6 6y agoYeah they are.
- dillonmckay 6y agoThere were quite a few articles. I believe maybe half of US states sell driver’s license data, including photos. https://www.newsweek.com/dmv-drivers-license-data-database-integrity-department-motor-vehicles-1458141 https://www.newsweek.com/dmv-drivers-license-data-database-i...
- MDWolinski 6y agoPer the WSJ article on the same topic: "J.D. Power asks vehicle buyers about their experience during the first 90 days of owning a newly purchased car or truck. The Silicon Valley electric-car maker avoided past scrutiny by the 34-year-old survey because of a quirk in some state laws that require an auto maker’s permission to use new-vehicle registration data to contact customers. Tesla hasn’t provided that permission, according to J.D. Power." It goes on to say that the data was collected from 35 states that do not require Tesla's permission.
- kleiba 6y agoAs far as I remember, this was already stated in early assessments by European car manufacturers about Tesla, too. But then again, there is an obvious bias why such statements would come from the competition.
- tomalpha 6y agoNot just the manufacturers - motoring journalists have generally said the same thing from the get go: https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/tesla/model-s/first-drives/2017-tesla-model-s-p100d https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/tesla/model-s/first-dri... > Inside the car there are plenty of rich feeling materials, but Tesla still hasn’t quite worked out how to put them together yet. There was the odd squeak from the interior trim when on the move, and some very large gaps around a cubbyhole’s lid.
- kleiba 6y agoInteresting. So basically, this J.D. Powers study brings nothing new to the table?
- tomalpha 6y agoIt looks to be another data point, and that's generally a good thing IMHO. There's a comment above somewhere that casts doubt on its methodology, but reports of Tesla quality issues certainly aren't anything new [0][1] To be fair to Tesla in the above article [0] they legitimately question the sample size and some later articles point to improvements [2]. Personally, I'm wary of the quality issues but I still want a Model X. Make of that what you will. [0] https://www.businessinsider.com/survey-uk-drivers-say-tesla-model-s-most-unreliable-car-2018-9?r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/survey-uk-drivers-say-tesla-... [1] https://www.topgear.com/car-reviews/tesla/model-3 https://www.topgear.com/car-reviews/tesla/model-3 [2] https://www.businessinsider.com/tesla-fixing-quality-issues-nearly-5000-model-3-owners-say-2019-10?r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/tesla-fixing-quality-issues-... Edit: formatting, typos and missing reference
- michaelt 6y ago
- ggreer 6y agoAnnoyingly, I can't find the original report by J.D. Power. Ars Technica has a more detailed summary.[1] Apparently the study favors cars with fewer features, as that means fewer things can go wrong. The results contradict brand stereotypes. Honda and Toyota are below the industry average. Volvo is one of the worst, along with luxury brands such as Mercedes-Benz, Audi, and Land Rover. The best rated are Dodge, Kia, and Chevrolet. Also this survey reflects initial impressions, not long term reliability. Seriously though: I would pay money for a news organization that always linked to primary sources. Bonus points for archiving them at the time of publication. I don't need a journalist to play Chinese whispers with me.[2] I'm an adult and I can interpret the information for myself. 1. https://arstechnica.com/cars/2020/06/teslas-are-the-most-unreliable-new-cars-in-the-us-survey-finds/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2020/06/teslas-are-the-most-unr... 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_whispers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_whispers
- moooo99 6y ago> Also this survey reflects initial impressions, not long term reliability. I also find that a very weird measure, especially when you want to report on the quality of said vehicles. It'd also be interesting to know what kind of problems customers face. A not perfect paint job is annoying, but its certainly not as bad as motor problems in the early beginning. I cannot prove this with numbers from the study, but I'd also assume that, depending on the car the customer buys, he usually has a diffferent idea of what can be considered good quality or not. I know people who were annoyed because the stitches of their drivers seat were off by a bit. On the other hand I know Ford owners that lost buttons on their infotainment unit and just hot-glued them back in. But as you said, just reflecting on the initial impressions of a vehicle doesn't say anything about more important measures like long term reliability, TCO etc. Having a study evaluate the problems a vehicle sees within the first 75.000km would be a lot more interesting and would also allow better conclusions. However, this study proves the several reports of automotive journalists around the world. Most people considered the Tesla vehicles decently good, but not matching the price tag Tesla puts on them quality wise. During the Model 3 production hell the quality problems became especially apparent with completely misplaced side-panels, the worst paint jobs I've seen on a mass produced vehicle among several other issues.
- 6y ago
- 01100011 6y ago> The top-rated brands were Dodge and Kia Is it possible that owners of certain brands are less likely to notice certain classes of car problems? For example, are people who purchase Kias less likely to care about a squeaking seatbelt? If I buy a car that costs $70k, I'm going to complain about every minor defect.
- csunbird 6y agoIt is all about expectations I would say. For example, I had a car that was worth 3k Euros at that time and I was happy with it, even though its quality was bad, it was running without problems and accomplished the task of getting me to work. The story would be much different in that case if my car had been worth 30k Euros.
- KaiserPro 6y agoWhilst that might apply in some cases, I don't think its universal. my 2009 kia rio has a superior paint finish, and more consistency in fit for doors and windows compared to a showroom tesla. This genuinely surprised me. I wish I had taken some photos to prove my point, because without it its all going to be put down to subjectiveness. The Kia rio has "generous" gaps around doors, boots and bonnets. However they all have consistent distances, its not like one door sits higher than the other. The showroom model 3 had one door higher than the other. The weather seals are going to be asked to do a lot there. Then there is the paint job. In the showroom all the model exhibited paint issues. Stuff like uneven coating, or incorrect ratios of pigment/mica to binder, so that where there are sharp corners there is bunching, lumps or roughness. So yeah, whilst I agree, people who own low end models are going to complain less, having seen (and wanted to buy) a tesla, I'm not surprised that fit and finish is such a problem.
- burntoutfire 6y agoThere was a study which showed that Skoda (or was it Dacia?) owners in the UK are very happy with their cars, far happier than the owners of premium cars. It confirms that happiness/contentment in a large degree is about mindset and expectations.
- stunt 6y ago
- thdrdt 6y agoDirect link to the 2020 Initial Quality Study page: https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2020-initial-quality-study-iqs https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2020-initial...
- Ice_cream_suit 6y agoJ.D Power Initial Quality Study (warning !!! PDF ): https://www.jdpower.com/sites/default/files/file/2020-06/2020070%20U.S.%20IQS.pdf https://www.jdpower.com/sites/default/files/file/2020-06/202... J.D Power press release : https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2020-initial-quality-study-iqs https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2020-initial...
- berkes 6y agoOff topic: but why do we always warn for PDFs? It's not as if they contain malware, crash phones or freeze your OS, is it? I too add a "PDF Warning" to links most of the times, but have no idea why I should continue doing it, now that I think about it.
- thecopy 6y agoI like PDF. They contain no ads, no javascript and no scroll-highjacking. I know what to expect and it 'just works'.
- Accacin 6y agoI thought that PDFs could contain JavaScript too!
- Tepix 6y agoThey can but viewers don‘t execute them with very few exceptions (and even Adobe Reader has it disabled by default i think)
- Cu3PO42 6y agoChrome does and it may be one of the most popular viewers currently in use. If you've never seen it, I encourage everyone to try breakout.pdf [0]. I know it doesn't work in Firefox's viewer, but it does in Chrome's. And yes, it's exactly what it sounds like: an implementation of the classic Breakout game in PDF. [0] https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/gh/osnr/horrifying-pdf-experiments@master/breakout.pdf https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/gh/osnr/horrifying-pdf-experiments@...
- oehtXRwMkIs 6y agoIs J.D. Power even trustworthy? I remember doubting them ever since Chevrolet starting spamming all their J.D. Power awards ads with "real people".
- dchest 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSBsq6HBBzw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSBsq6HBBzw
- kwhitefoot 6y agoThis is not news. Every Tesla owner knows that if they spent the same amount of money on a Mercedes or even better a Volkswagen that they would get better finish. But quality isn't just about finish. It's about having the features you want: mind bending acceleration in what is essentially a family or executive car, a good electric car before anyone else had one, a better driver assistance package, a simpler ordering process, a service organization that comes to you to fix things, a user interface built for this century not the one before, a charging infrastructure that not only works but is nearly ubiquitous. The old car companies could have done all those things but they chose to protect their existing product lines instead. When they finally get their act together then Tesla will have a hard time, until then, I'll stick with my five year old Model S and to hell with the fact that the finish isn't quite as good as a Mercedes E class.
- alkonaut 6y agoI think the order process thing was basically a US thing where Tesla could sweep in and disrupt an archaic system. In many other places you could order a new custom built car online fifteen years ago. That this is somehow revolutionary in the US still is pretty unique.
- trabant00 6y agoWhat are you talking about? This is not about finish but quality as in things breaking down or not. > a good electric car before anyone else had one This motivation is sad.
- milkytron 6y ago> a service organization that comes to you to fix things Even if they come to you to service your car, aren't there still issues with actually getting fixes in a timely manner? I recall reading about customers who needed replacement parts and having to wait weeks/months to get it fixed.
- kwhitefoot 6y agoYes, it sometimes is a a problem. I have had two mobile service visits. One to replace the 12 V battery that was done under warranty and happened quite quickly and on time; another to replace a smashed door mirror that was delayed by a week because of a mistake in their internal processes. The biggest problem I have with Tesla (the company not the car) is that they are very bad at communication. Unlike the supercharger network, which is very nearly ubiquitous in northern Europe, their telephone service is almost impossible to use because it is simply permanently overloaded. This is a major problem if you are trying to call them from a mobile phone in an area with poor coverage such as when one has blown out a tyre by hitting a pothole on a rural road in north Devon in the pouring rain.
- renewiltord 6y agoIs J D Power a real company? I just assumed they were some made-up bullshit. I don't think I've ever believed they were worth anything.
- beyondcompute 6y ago“When surveying computing device owners we found that an average abacus user reports 14 problems in the first three months and a laptop user reports 18”.
- surfpel 6y agoI learned a great deal about this from Sandy Munro, an automotive manufacturing consultant, who has torn down and analyzed several Teslas, posting his findings to YouTube. These videos are quite enlightening on this topic. In this series below, he took apart a model Y in its entirety, revealing some quality/production issues as well as some innovative (mechanical) things Tesla has done. 1. https://m.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLkiDlGyJnprdFftxAZ85a5Rp1LlET4Wbr https://m.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLkiDlGyJnprdFftxAZ85a5R...
- safgasCVS 6y agoHaving priced warranty insurance products in the past, the relative cost of repairs standardised by new vehicle value at the time of sale, JD power ranks were not bad proxies but bit and miss for their mid-field. Toyota being below average in reliability? Not in warranty claims it isn’t. Porsche usually does well on JD power but their actual warranty bills (again, standardised for their price) are very high. JD is mostly based oN subjective impressions and electrical niggles in the first 90 days of ownership (niggles including difficulty of operation not necessarily failures). If they have changed the method since I last checked my apologies for spouting nonsense
- mlvljr 6y agoMahk would have something to say on this.
- julianlam 6y agoIsn't this what a pre-delivery inspection is for? Most days the only time I hear about PDI is when people advise other people to try and get their PDI fee waived, because it's literally the salesperson checking boxes on a clipboard. > “Unlike other manufacturers, Tesla doesn’t grant us permission to survey its owners in 15 states where it is required,” Doug Betts, president of the automotive division at J.D. Power, said in a statement. “However, we were able to collect a large enough sample of surveys from owners in the other 35 states and, from that base, we calculated Tesla’s score.” ... and we're letting Tesla do this exactly... why?